Originally Posted by
Erick L
The Arkel system isn't like other hooks and bungees.
The only difference is the addition of a lock block. You still have to hook the hook to the lower part of the rack, stretch the bungee (and bag) up so that the hooks can clear the top of the rack and lower the bag in place. Then you have to turn the lock block into place. If you want to take the bags off with stuff on the rack, you have to remove the rack mounted gear or fish around to find the lock block to turn it.
Compare that with the Ortlieb system. Pull up on the handle and the catch mechanism is opened. Slide the bag into place with the lower hook engaging the rack and the hooks engaging the upper part of the rack. Let go of the handle and the whole system is secure as the latch mechanism springs back into place. Since the handles are on the outside of the bag (to keep them out of the wheel), it's a simple matter to grab the handle and release the bag.
A lock block just isn't enough to convince me that the Arkel system is superior to the Ortlieb system nor that it's all that much better than any other hook and bungee system.