Originally Posted by
MikeWinVA
Short rides on both. Frankly, they both feel similar. The Specialized is at a nearby shop, the Surly about a hour away. I prefer the local shop.
It looks like I can fit fenders on the Surly too. Maybe I can get the LBS to order it for me.
You can definitely fit fenders on the Surly - it is a full-blown touring bike.
These really are two completely different bikes - I'm sure the Surly weighs eight or nine pounds more than the Specialized. Much, much longer wheelbase and chain stays, much lower gearing.
If "go fast" is truly a concern, for whatever part a bike plays in the 'go fast' equation, you're better off with the Specialized.