Before and after surgery, I rode a HPV StreetMachine recumbent bike.
Then in a couple years I got back on an upright bike, often changing saddles.
A Terry Liberator seemed ok.
Then I went to a Brooks B17, which was very nice.
Next I tried a B68, not quite right - saddle is intended for a slightly different ride than it was mounted on.
Then the Brooks Imperial came out - It is great for me !!
The recumbent is still the most comfortable.