i have a brooks b17, its great. its a little wide compared to the turbo. if you plan on living on your bike this is the one to choose.
i have a turbo, its on my most frequently used bike. its great as well. its a vintage perf one, so i can't really comment on the reissues because when you put them next to eachother they are different shapes and the weight is considerably less for the new one.
i ride a lot and haven't a bad thing to say about either one.
i have tried the charge spoon as well, and i think its a great deal and is a bit wider than the turbo. if you are looking for something wide but feels like a turbo i would recommend this guy. all are great choices and really think that other than these differences, preference is subjective. one can only choose based on the facts and hope for the best for the rest. good luck!