The Jamis Bosanova looked good except for the carbon fork. Just my preference. I guess I'm still leaning towards the Vaya or Casseroll. I like the steel frame/fork on both of them. I have always preferred steel, but have been riding aluminum for a while.
Craigslist isn't a viable option where I live. I have watched it for a long time and there is nothing there except $200 Schwinn Continentals and stuff along those lines. If there was a nice bike, some hipster has stripped it and turned into a fixie thinking that raises the value of it.