Gabedamien

The Jamis is yet another nice bike that isn't quite what I'm looking for: the chain guard is barely there, the styling and geometry are both more modern than retro, the frame is aluminum, the tubes are welded instead of lugged, etc. Don't get me wrong, if someone gave me one I would be thrilled and no doubt enjoy it greatly, but for my money there are other bikes that channel the old-school vibe a little more elegantly. I might not have emphasized enough in my original post how high a priority that is for me.

The Giant Via is another decent call, and one I hadn't noticed before. If I hadn't found such a close candidate in the Papillionaire Classic, it would be contending with my other picks. Thanks.

I appreciate the continuing suggestions and feedback even though for the time being I think I've found my match. Who knows, I can always change my mind in the next month.