If you are intending to use the bike for commuting as well as other riding, I would get a frame with mounts for fenders and racks as well as clearance for larger tires. Thus, the All-City Space Horse or Soma ES would seem better choices, IMHO. If not, why are you posting your question in the commuting forum?
Some other bikes you might consider are the Salsa Vaya, Soma San Marco. The Gunnar Sport is another great option, although probably a little higher than your budget unless you bought used.