I've got 26x2" Supremes on my Pt Reyes and 26x2" BA's on the Big Dummy. The BA's ride nicer,the Supremes are lighter and stickier.
The
PR is all alloy,but playing with the air pressure in the Supremes makes it ride pretty good. If I was going to be riding it every day on bad roads,I would prolly go with BA's. But for just running around town,or riding in the rain,I'd go with Supremes.