Originally Posted by
Stolencar
This is where I am as well. I cursed for twenty minutes trying to squeeze the rack and fenders onto the same eyelet & came to the conclusion that it wasn't going to work. Off to buy a new rack this afternoon. Without the rack the Planet Bike fenders were still a pain in the butt to install but I got it done. I am worried still that I will need to tinker with the fenders all the time as they go in and out of alignment. I'll put that down as the cost not washing my jacket after every dirty wet commute.
You might just need to buy a longer bolt to make both fit on the same eyelet. Your LBS might have what you need, but I bought longer bolts (stainless steel) from a local Ace hardware store. Lowe's or Home Depot might even have what you need.
In my case, the store had some bolts that were a little too long, so I just used a dremel cut-off to trim the length to fit my needs.