Originally Posted by Brian Ratliff
(Post 16802870)
So, do you need a time machine to imagine Michael Jordan alone on the court against any NBA caliber team? I'm pretty sure you don't need a time machine to imagine Armstrong isolated against rivals. I mean, I think I saw a video of it the other day...
But, right, unknowable... :rolleyes: |
This started talking about national champs and olympics, why did it devolve into talking about amateurs? I don't even think anyone but pro/1/2 fields should have cash prizes, so no I don't care about a $10.99 trophy. But I do think pros that help a teammate win nats should get a little flag or something put on their jersey for the year. That would be nice.
|
I think every Category should get paid out - you are paying to enter a race, so some of the fees should come back to you. There is a race next weekend in Central Park - paying out $8,500 to the P/1/2/3 categories, $1,100 to Cat 3 and $750 to Cat 4. Cat 5 only gets medals. I think it's a decent amount of cash to win something that you enjoy to do, that's not your primary source of income. I like riding, and would love to podium and take home a few hundred bucks one time.
|
I think everyone in all races should receive ponies.
Even people who thought about racing, or want to, but just haven't made it out yet. Ponies for everyone!!!!11 |
Originally Posted by rankin116
(Post 16803077)
This started talking about national champs and olympics, why did it devolve into talking about amateurs? ... I do think pros that help a teammate win nats should get a little flag or something put on their jersey for the year. That would be nice.
|
Originally Posted by Brian Ratliff
(Post 16802703)
We can reward teammembers any way we want. We can give them all trophies and jerseys and money. We can mention them in race introductions. Sure. But the dude who crosses the line first will always be the rider most valued. You can fill a Tour de France team with Hinicapies and you'll never get that team the GC win. You can take one Lance Armstrong (juiced version), give him no teammates whatsoever, and he'd still be a favorite to win. That truth dictates the actual rewards and recognition, not any particular participation/recognition system of rewards.
Yes, if Ted King had somehow won nationals as the lone rider for Cannonwhale (1980s reference) this year, he would have done it without a team. (Forgetting, for the moment, the idea of a combine with other single riders.) And therefore, he would have to share the glory with no one. And it's certainly possible to win with almost no team. Timmy Duggan in 2012 is a good example. It was just he and King riding in the Liquigas colors that year. If at some point in that race Ted King's efforts helped ensure victory for Duggan, then it was a team effort. No matter how small the team.
Originally Posted by rankin116
(Post 16803077)
This started talking about national champs and olympics, why did it devolve into talking about amateurs? I don't even think anyone but pro/1/2 fields should have cash prizes, so no I don't care about a $10.99 trophy. But I do think pros that help a teammate win nats should get a little flag or something put on their jersey for the year. That would be nice.
|
Originally Posted by hack
(Post 16802385)
I didn't know this was you^
I imagine the task was equally if not more difficult when introducing some of the lesser accomplished domestic team members. I have my intros written out in advance. And I save them because I'll probably need them again in Colorado. |
Originally Posted by Gramercy
(Post 16803189)
I think every Category should get paid out - you are paying to enter a race, so some of the fees should come back to you. There is a race next weekend in Central Park - paying out $8,500 to the P/1/2/3 categories, $1,100 to Cat 3 and $750 to Cat 4. Cat 5 only gets medals. I think it's a decent amount of cash to win something that you enjoy to do, that's not your primary source of income. I like riding, and would love to podium and take home a few hundred bucks one time.
|
Most every recreational endeavor costs money to participate in. There are inherent flaws in a model where folks get paid for racing. Huge purses for park races, in a city with quite a large number of drug positives, incidences of cheating, and general recklessness seems to me a prescription for continued difficulties. I'd be happy with the $10.99 trophy, a medal, or a jersey. Cat 5s opining that they want to get paid out a few hundred bucks for winning a race is ponderous.
|
Originally Posted by rankin116
(Post 16803077)
This started talking about national champs and olympics, why did it devolve into talking about amateurs? I don't even think anyone but pro/1/2 fields should have cash prizes, so no I don't care about a $10.99 trophy. But I do think pros that help a teammate win nats should get a little flag or something put on their jersey for the year. That would be nice.
Originally Posted by gsteinb
(Post 16803314)
Most every recreational endeavor costs money to participate in. There are inherent flaws in a model where folks get paid for racing. Huge purses for park races, in a city with quite a large number of drug positives, incidences of cheating, and general recklessness seems to me a prescription for continued difficulties. I'd be happy with the $10.99 trophy, a medal, or a jersey. Cat 5s opining that they want to get paid out a few hundred bucks for winning a race is ponderous.
|
A bunch of years ago, in order to do a particular early morning series, my son needed to sleep over someone's house. Since I felt bad about it I have him my prize money throughout the series. He got a pretty good chunk of change.
|
Originally Posted by gsteinb
(Post 16803314)
Most every recreational endeavor costs money to participate in. There are inherent flaws in a model where folks get paid for racing. Huge purses for park races, in a city with quite a large number of drug positives, incidences of cheating, and general recklessness seems to me a prescription for continued difficulties. I'd be happy with the $10.99 trophy, a medal, or a jersey. Cat 5s opining that they want to get paid out a few hundred bucks for winning a race is ponderous.
|
What's the problem here.
If I had to base my opinion on my abilities on my results, my opinion wouldn't be nearly as high. |
Originally Posted by EventServices
(Post 16803240)
I had to fill 50 seconds. It was a challenge to shorten intros such as Jens' and a bigger challenge to lengthen intros such as the entire Bissell Devo team. They had nothing on their resume`.
I have my intros written out in advance. And I save them because I'll probably need them again in Colorado. Somewhere during the Amgen, I did see Tom Boonen referred to as a stage x winner of the 2010 Amgen (or whatever year it was), but nothing else from his cycling history. I can't imagine he'd have anything from the Tour of California as one of his personal race highlights. |
I think this is a great question, Jamie. I like the idea of teammates having a small icon on their kit, like a striped shield or something with the date in it.
Team tactics most certainly play a part in pro criteriums. Just watch Bissell or UHC chop their way to victory. |
Originally Posted by needmoreair
(Post 16800694)
Because it's not a team sport.
Unless I have missed something in the English dictionary, defining the word "Team" |
Originally Posted by hack
(Post 16803926)
Somewhere during the Amgen, I did see Tom Boonen referred to as a stage x winner of the 2010 Amgen (or whatever year it was), but nothing else from his cycling history. I can't imagine he'd have anything from the Tour of California as one of his personal race highlights.
I think all I said was "Ladies and Gentlemen, it's Tom Boonen!!" and the crowd filled the other 57 seconds with cheering. Less is more. #21 Tom Boonen age 33 Mol Belgium 4x winner of Paris Roubaix 3x Winner of Tour of Flanders multiple stage winner in all three Grand Tours 2005 World Champion TRIVIA: 2x World Champion. Road and….. TTT in 2012 TRIVIA - Has ridden for just two teams: QuickStep and USPostal So far in 2014. Winning Kurne Brussels Kurne 7th at Flanders 10th at Roubaix 2nd overall, the sprinters jersey, AND 2 stages at Tour of Qatar. Thus far this year, he has 5782.1 kilometers of racing According to procyclingstats.com And talking about what constitutes a TEAM and who gets a piece of the trophy... Even the NFL practice squad players get a Super Bowl ring. |
Originally Posted by Racer Ex
(Post 16802275)
Next time the receptionist at Oracle has to step in for Larry Ellison, let us know. Your analogy compared apples to fire trucks because they both are red. Businesses and bike racing have only the most superficial similarities.
And calling something asinine drivel isn't exactly overwhelming us with a cogent rebuttal. You are glue and I am rubber; consider taking your own advice. Defending your analogy does not consist of trotting out your Thesaurus to call something names. The comparison dealt with a leader receiving credit for doing what a leader does. That I have to break that down and explain it to you says enough on its own. Your asinine comment was just that. It wasn't a rebuttal, it was just you regurgitating vitriol because you had nothing else to contribute. Work on it. |
Originally Posted by waterrockets
(Post 16801750)
You think that's the only glory available at bike race?
You can take whatever glory you need to take to make you feel like you're doing something worthwhile. At the end of the day, the only glory is the one bestowed to the guy that crossed the line first. That's why we have "winners". That's why we have "titles". |
Originally Posted by EventServices
(Post 16802161)
I
So following this example, none of the NFL linemen should get a Super Bowl ring because they didn't experience the individual glory of scoring a touchdown. I know that's not exactly what you meant, but it's a pretty accurate parallel. Cycling is full of riders who can't win a race, but football is full of players who can't throw, catch, or run. Cycling isn't so they don't. That's why cycling isn't a team sport in that vein, it's an individual sport. My point all along. |
Originally Posted by grolby
(Post 16802648)
Exactly this. We reward bike races the way we do because that's historically how we've done it. At some point, people like needmoreair start to assume that things are the way they are because that's how they work organically, and that's when electrons start getting wasted moving hot air from one node on the network to all the others. But bike racing isn't organic.
Yeah, silly me, thinking a RACE is about something other than the fastest person getting across the line first. As if bike racing is the only sport utilizing such a "non-organic" system of rewarding the first person to finish the glory. How crazy we humans have been throughout history. |
Originally Posted by rankin116
(Post 16803077)
This started talking about national champs and olympics, why did it devolve into talking about amateurs? I don't even think anyone but pro/1/2 fields should have cash prizes, so no I don't care about a $10.99 trophy. But I do think pros that help a teammate win nats should get a little flag or something put on their jersey for the year. That would be nice.
A teammate that doesn't win nats is NOT the winner. This is a ridiculously simple concept and I'm having a really hard time figuring out how anyone can think that a person that does NOT win a race should be rewarded in the same vein as someone that does. |
Originally Posted by ColnagoC40
(Post 16804050)
Once you were selected to ride in pro team, became part of the team and worked with the team, you will understand that pro cycling is totally a "Team" sport.
Unless I have missed something in the English dictionary, defining the word "Team" But let me know the next time the entire team steps on to the podium after winning the weekend race/NRC race/Giro stage, etc. |
Originally Posted by needmoreair
(Post 16804250)
Yeah, silly me, thinking a RACE is about something other than the fastest person getting across the line first.
I know this might be a bit deep for you. |
Originally Posted by needmoreair
(Post 16804264)
No, apparently you just missed the definition of the word "winner" and how it's used in the context of bike racing.
But let me know the next time the entire team steps on to the podium after winning the weekend race/NRC race/Giro stage, etc. http://i300.photobucket.com/albums/n...scd2a1523.jpeg |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:53 AM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.