I doubt (although this all subjective opinion) the BAs will offer appreciably better puncture protection than Comet Kevlars 1.35/1.5 (the BAs are a lot wider which means there is a greater tyre surface area to attract more sharp detritus) but they will soften the ride if you want to go over rougher terrain, or if the Brooklyn roads are badly cratered...
The Marathon Racer might be a worth considering - 40/406.