Originally Posted by
Scot_Gore
It's not requiried that experts agree with each other.
Exactly.
Originally Posted by
Scot_Gore
So, the "Who's Right" question seems out of place.
Given the first quote of yours above, the "Who's Right" question seems quite appropriate.
The variety and experience of cyclists on these forums makes this medium the perfect place to pose such a question. The answers that follow can only cause us to gather more understanding than before.