Originally Posted by
BikeGk
Ok everyone, I am 5'9" ish with my sneakers on. I just made some adjustments as per BarracksSi suggestions. Here's an updated pic. I haven't gotten a chance to ride just yet....but it looks better. I'm wondering If I should just flip the handlebar mounting bracket over so it is angled downward if I need them lower....
Well, it does look better. But - looks do not matter; your comfort and fit do.
I would just about wager that a 17.5 is too big a frame. However, if the bike fits you and you are happy, that is all that counts.
I'm not sure about flipping the bracket but that may be an option.
IMO (and it is ONLY an opinion) I think you might want to consider going back to your shop and seeing if they would let you try the next size down (15?). It's certainly your call but unless you have long legs, you may have an issue with the seat that high on a 17.5.
Good luck.