It is very typical to have comfort problems when you first start riding, or when you start logging more miles in the spring after a winter of less (or no) cycling. Your body will become more accustomed to riding and you should experience less discomfort as your mileage increases. I'd give it a little longer before you give up on the seat. As others have mentioned, the fit on the bike is at least as important as the seat itself.
However, it's quite possible that the seat just isn't the right one for you. There is no 'most comfortable seat' because it is a matter of personal preference and body type. Try and find a shop which will let you evaluate a seat and return it if is doesn't work out for you and has not been damaged at all.
Last edited by bikerider; 06-12-02 at 11:12 AM.