For what it's worth, I recently switched from a B-17 to a
Velo Bio logic for two reasons. After miles of comparative test riding, I found the Velo to have a slight comfort edge over the Brooks. Plus with the Velo, there are no maintenance issues. It doesn't care if it rains. 1500 miles later, I still ride the Velo.
Cost for the Velo is in the $30's, and there is no breakin required. It is the stock issue saddle for Dallas bicycle patrolmen. That's where I got the idea to try it.
Of course, it doesn't have the classic Brooks look which is important to a lot of people. i do miss that aspect.