I have 5 bikes, all with Brooks B-17s and I will never ride anything else. The break in period is not that bad so be patient and you will love the results. FYI, the best buy today on the B-17 is
BikeIsland at $72 delivered for the black. I have never used the "soak" method and I have never regretted taking the time to break it in. The only thing to watch for is the transfer to the oil/wax to the backside of your shorts. I use an old pair that has already absorbed the stains.