Bike Forums

Bike Forums (http://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Advocacy & Safety (http://www.bikeforums.net/advocacy-safety/)
-   -   Which is the better visibility color for vests? (http://www.bikeforums.net/advocacy-safety/251863-better-visibility-color-vests.html)

kf5nd 12-10-06 09:46 AM

Which is the better visibility color for vests?
 
See this website, then vote in the poll.

http://www.alertshirt.com/clas2safves.html

o-dog 12-10-06 10:57 AM

hi-vis lime yellow is definitely the best in my opinion

genec 12-10-06 11:03 AM

The lime yellow is supposed to be the best, but I have a vest that is both... I added blaze orange to a hi vis yellow vest... in the thinking that any one single color can be lost in certain backgrounds, so contrast was the most important thing. My helmet is black and white for the same reasons.

Wogster 12-10-06 11:38 AM

Of the vests at the link, one has both, and I think that would be most visible.

Gojohnnygo. 12-10-06 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by genec
The lime yellow is supposed to be the best, but I have a vest that is both... I added blaze orange to a hi vis yellow vest... in the thinking that any one single color can be lost in certain backgrounds, so contrast was the most important thing. My helmet is black and white for the same reasons.


+1 You need to outline the human form by using a different color. This is why hunters try to hide or conceal their outline.Some hunter use blaze orange(Deer can't see orange) in a camo pattern just to hide their outline but still be visible to others. Hunters want to blend in cyclist want to stand out.

Severian 12-10-06 01:37 PM

Ahh but if you get a blaze orange hunting jacket then you can wear it in the winter while cycling. Dual use! And if you have an Xtracycle then you can pack in and pack out on the trails while still being environmentally concious.

EDIT: and according to a bow hunting instructor I had years ago Deer can't see either lime yellow OR blaze orange... for some bizzare reason they just show up as dun colors to deer.

banerjek 12-10-06 01:39 PM

For most purposes the hi viz yellow is better. However, if you are riding into bright sunlight, I think blaze orange is better because it's further away from the color of the sun in the drivers' eyes.

I own both.

Severian 12-10-06 01:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by banerjek
For most purposes the hi viz yellow is better. However, if you are riding into bright sunlight, I think blaze orange is better because it's further away from the color of the sun in the drivers' eyes.

I own both.

This is precisely the reason why we need smartcloth that can color-change at the click of a button a la "Snowcrash" by Neal Stephenson.

One jacket to rule them all and in the darkness make them visible.

Bekologist 12-10-06 01:46 PM

I've got both, and have taken to wearing a blaze orange 10 mile-cloth surveyors' vest for middle of the day trips, and think the high vis yellow shows up better at nighttime or dawn/dusk.

I think the blaze orange works better in full light but bad visibility, and the neon yellows in dim light conditions. My experience and my observations of roadworkers, etc....

Gojohnnygo. 12-10-06 01:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Severian
Ahh but if you get a blaze orange hunting jacket then you can wear it in the winter while cycling. Dual use! And if you have an Xtracycle then you can pack in and pack out on the trails while still being environmentally concious.

EDIT: and according to a bow hunting instructor I had years ago Deer can't see either lime yellow OR blaze orange... for some bizzare reason they just show up as dun colors to deer.

The reason for that deer have no predators of that color, So they have no need to see that color. I wear blaze orange vest in the winter If we have snow on the ground it stands out better against the white back ground

deputyjones 12-10-06 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bekologist
I've got both, and have taken to wearing a blaze orange 10 mile-cloth surveyors' vest for middle of the day trips, and think the high vis yellow shows up better at nighttime or dawn/dusk.

I think the blaze orange works better in full light but bad visibility, and the neon yellows in dim light conditions. My experience and my observations of roadworkers, etc....

Agreed. Yellow will remain visible longer as light fades.

Frankenbiker 12-10-06 03:01 PM

I wear my blaze orange one during the day because I think the orange color stands out better against the green foliage. during evening/night/poor visibility conditions I prefer the lime green with reflective tape because the green shows up better in headlights than the blaze orange one.

vrkelley 12-10-06 03:06 PM

I don't see much color and didn't know the alert-shirt had lime-green in it...can only see yellow in that shirt. It would seem that Red should be an option.

ranger5oh 12-10-06 03:09 PM

Its been a proven fact for years that the lime-yellow color is more visible than the old orange.

SingingSabre 12-10-06 04:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by genec
The lime yellow is supposed to be the best, but I have a vest that is both... I added blaze orange to a hi vis yellow vest... in the thinking that any one single color can be lost in certain backgrounds, so contrast was the most important thing. My helmet is black and white for the same reasons.

There are ninja cyclists.

You, my friend, are a neon tiger cyclist!

UmneyDurak 12-10-06 04:55 PM

Riding in Police uniform.

Enigma198 12-10-06 06:42 PM

When I see orange, I think traffic cones, and barricades, not human. The high-viz really seems to catch my eye. I was impressed enough from seeing it at various construction zones that I bought a high-viz shell for winter, two high-viz jerseys for summer and traded in my orange traffic vest for a high-viz one.

CommuterRun 12-10-06 06:48 PM

I don't know why it's called lime. Don't believe I've ever seen any part of a lime that was that color.

Anyway, that's what I wear. But I typically only wear it at night for the orange reflective strips on my vest. During the day I normally just wear a white t-shirt. White showing up the best against the widest variety of backgrounds, under varying light levels. It very rarely snows here. Even more rare to get enough to stick.

sgtsmile 12-10-06 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Severian
Ahh but if you get a blaze orange hunting jacket then you can wear it in the winter while cycling. Dual use! And if you have an Xtracycle then you can pack in and pack out on the trails while still being environmentally concious.

EDIT: and according to a bow hunting instructor I had years ago Deer can't see either lime yellow OR blaze orange... for some bizzare reason they just show up as dun colors to deer.

They, like you (you in natural low light at dusk, they all the time), are 100 % colour blind.

AlmostTrick 12-10-06 10:33 PM

I have the Alertshirt vest and the sweat jacket in ANSI lime and I constantly get comments on how bright they are. Several people have even told me it hurts their eyes!

JamesV 12-10-06 11:24 PM

This chart is a real [ahem] "eye opener" -- it shows yellow-green is more than twice as visible than orange:

Human Eye's Response to Light

I found the text interesting. I did not know that under truly dark conditions, once the eye is completely dark adapted, the eye's response changes and blue-green becomes the most visible color (although it will look gray).

Frankenbiker 12-11-06 07:15 AM

Of course, proper bicycle safety attire on Remulak requires wearing both an ANSI lime vest and an orange traffic cone. :D

kf5nd 12-11-06 07:34 AM

Wow, not much of a content in that poll !!!

NA_CA 12-11-06 10:51 AM

Hi-viz yellow/green without a doubt
 
Check out www.pedigreen.com. We carry the hi-viz yellow/green colored items of apparel and lots of accessories. I can tell you our best sellers are the two tones items. T-shirts and vests that have the yellow/green body and orange (black even) used as a contrast. It has the WOW factor. :)

Gojohnnygo. 12-11-06 01:45 PM

I voted for Hi-viz yellow. I do also think that blaze orange is the best against a snowy back ground especially in very sunny conditions.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:07 AM.