Bicycle Mechanics - I need a rapid-rise...

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




View Full Version : I need a rapid-rise...


FarHorizon
04-27-06, 06:56 AM
Yeah, I know what you're thinking - NOBODY needs a rapid-rise... Well, I (and Sheldon Brown) LIKE them. My problem is thus: I'm running a Exage-8 downtube shifter on my Klein Navigator with a XTR-960 rear. The 960 (for some obscure reason) does NOT have a cable-barrel-adjuster on the derailleur (I guess the XTR thumb-shifter had one?).

I'd prefer NOT to use an inline adjuster, so I'm planning on switching out the XTR-960 for another flavor of 8-speed rear derailleur that will work with my index-downtube-shifter and will also have an integrated cable adjuster on the derailleur.

I do NOT need all the cage-length (range) that my current XTR provides, but I DO want to retain the "low-normal" or "rapid-rise" style. In fact, my total difference from lowest to highest gear is only 16 teeth (44 front with 12-28 rear).

Now to the question: Of the Shimano 8-speed compatible Rapid-Rise rear derailleurs, which is the best in terms of quality and reliability that will also include an integrated cable adjuster? Obviously, I need not stick exclusively with the XTR line, as Shimano also (unless I'm mistaken) made some ROAD derailleurs in the rapid-rise mode. Pile all the derision on that you wish - just answer the question ;) . Thanks!


HillRider
04-27-06, 07:09 AM
I don't know of any road rear derailleurs with the rapid-rise configuration.

All 9-speed rear derailleur swill work fine with your 8-speed setup so look at any current rapid rise MTB rear der.

TallRider
04-27-06, 07:50 AM
Grant at Rivendell likes them, too.

IT's pretty weird that XTR rapid-rise RD doesn't have a barrel adjuster. The XT and LX rapid-rise RD's do have barrel adjusters. So you could sell your XTR on eBay and buy an LX (and probably make money on the trade-off) or rig up a barrel adjuster on the XTR.

As HillRider noted, Shimano only offers the low-normal configuration in RD's designed for use with a wide range cassette. But "mountain" deraillers work fine on a road bike with a narrow cassette - I used an XT on my road bike with an 11-21 cassette for years - shifted perfectly (I'd built an 8-speed triple before road triples were common).