Touring - Which pots to get for touring?

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




View Full Version : Which pots to get for touring?


avatarworf
06-15-06, 12:05 AM
Any advice on which pots, or rather what kind of pots, to get to cook in for a tour? We are pretty much sold on the MSR Whisperlite International but not sure whether we should go for stainless steel or splurge on titanium. We will be using them a lot so don't mind splurging but not sure it's necessary? I guess weight is a benefit of titanium, do they cook any better?


Bekologist
06-15-06, 12:36 AM
they do NOT cook better. the heat transmission is not nearly as good for cooking. actually the stuff sucks for anything except boiling water. aluminum billies are almost as light as ti.

Erick L
06-15-06, 01:30 AM
I've used MSR Alpine (SS), Blacklite (alu with coating), a bunch of no-name pots and now use GSI hard anodized Extreme Cookset. From least favorite to favorite:

MSR Blacklite - Not very durable, has separate lid and pan, which is nice. Not recommended.

MSR Alpine - Very tough, no need to worry about scratching the coating. The lid doesn't make a good pan.

GSI Extreme - Seems more durable that the Blacklite (haven't used it as much). Smallest pot is 1L, which is more practical for solo touring than the 1.5L pot of the MSR. Good pan double as lid or bowl. Only negative point is how the handle connects to the pot and pan. VEry minor point, just a little akward sometimes. I recommend it highly.

The MSR Duralite is the same as the Blacklite but is hard adonized like the GSI (more durable). It's almost twice the price of the GSI.


WestOz
06-15-06, 03:28 AM
I use stainless steel. They have no handles and are a no name brand. They have sealable lids and pack inside each other. I only take two, and they cook really fast on an MSR. I use a small alloy handle that grabs the rim of the pots.

I usually pack something in the inner pot, and then the inner pot goes in the next size up and fits neatly in a pannier.

ncscott
06-15-06, 07:03 AM
I'll second the GSI extreme comments. Excelent pots. I used the smaller one for my Appilachian Trail hike and still use it for every backcountry trip. Definately like the lid/pan.
Scott

Monoborracho
06-15-06, 07:53 AM
I have an aluminum coffee pot and pretty much use it for all my cooking. I also carry an older style military mess kit which I find to be excellent. (There's a reason our soldiers had them) With those things I can pack my stove, utensils, a real cloth towel, two fuel cannisters, fork/spoon, lighter, and anything else that fits in the coffe pot.

Bekologist
06-15-06, 08:48 AM
i use old 'luminum Bulldog billies! they're british and they're brilliant!
Perfect lid system!

never store an alcohol stove or fuel in your cookset. i wouldn't store ANY stove in the cookset, unless you are fond of potentially going blind from methanol or ill from accidental petroleum injestion.

kesroberts
06-15-06, 09:41 AM
We (spouse and I) carry just one big pot - a 3 liter stainless MSR with a lid/pan. It's big enough to cook about anything for 2 in and virtually all of our other cooking/eating stuff other than the stove fits inside. We also carry a cheap aluminum cup that works as a small pot for making sauces or as beer mug as the case may be. This set up has worked great on several tours, including the two weeks we just spent on the Norhtern California coast, possibly the coolest place I've ever ridden a bike!

BostonFixed
06-15-06, 09:46 AM
i wouldn't store ANY stove in the cookset, unless you are fond of potentially going blind from methanol or ill from accidental petroleum injestion.
What about a canister stove?

NoReg
06-15-06, 10:03 AM
How is the lead content in pots these days. The old aluminum pots used to be pretty bad, but that was before the likes of MSR started making them.

markf
06-15-06, 12:37 PM
i wouldn't store ANY stove in the cookset, unless you are fond of potentially going blind from methanol or ill from accidental petroleum injestion.

Since the MSR's have detachable fuel tanks, how can you ingest any petroleum if you detach the fuel bottle, give the white gas time to evaporate from the burner, put the burner in a plastic bag or stuff sack, and pack the fuel bottle separately from the stove? My Whisperlite fits perfectly in my MSR Alpine cookset this way.

cyccommute
06-15-06, 12:47 PM
I've used MSR Alpine (SS), Blacklite (alu with coating), a bunch of no-name pots and now use GSI hard anodized Extreme Cookset. From least favorite to favorite:

MSR Blacklite - Not very durable, has separate lid and pan, which is nice. Not recommended.

MSR Alpine - Very tough, no need to worry about scratching the coating. The lid doesn't make a good pan.

GSI Extreme - Seems more durable that the Blacklite (haven't used it as much). Smallest pot is 1L, which is more practical for solo touring than the 1.5L pot of the MSR. Good pan double as lid or bowl. Only negative point is how the handle connects to the pot and pan. VEry minor point, just a little akward sometimes. I recommend it highly.

The MSR Duralite is the same as the Blacklite but is hard adonized like the GSI (more durable). It's almost twice the price of the GSI.

I'd have to disagree on the MSR Blacklite. I've had mine for a long time and it's very durable. It heats evenly and isn't too heavy. I much prefer a teflon coating to trying to scrub out a noncoated pan. I have a 1.5 l and 2 l pot. I also carry a tea kettle since pouring water out of one of these pots is next to impossible. (The MSR Alpine pot is good.)

One precaution that I take is to line each pan and the lid with a spider mat. The spider mat keeps the pans from rubbing together in a pannier and has lots of uses during food prep.

I'd agree on titanium. Titanium has about the same density as aluminum so it won't save any appreciable weight and it cost a lot more.

Riderfan_lee
06-15-06, 01:35 PM
I just recently purchased a set of MSR Blacklite pots and they cook very well. They come with two pack cloths to place between pots to keep them from rubbing and come in handy for cleaning up. They don't make any noise at all when packed away. Nothing is worse than a set of rattling pots breaking up the silence when biking or hiking. I am a fan of aluminum pots as they are lightweight and seem to last a long time.

seeker333
06-15-06, 02:06 PM
just some general info -

1. alum
pro: cheapest, widest selection, disposable after some use
con: bends easily, from 2 ft falls or just cramming stuff in your bag

2. steel
pro: most durable alloy for cookware, won't bend easily, inexpensive
con: heaviest alternative

3. titan
pro: very minor weight advantage over alum
con: super expensive, bends easy, everthing but water and oil sticks to it (uncoated)

Some pots come coated with teflon. My experience is that teflon lasts a short time even on expensive gourmet level kitchen skillets, and you eat some of the teflon that comes off. I prefer uncoated pots, you can clean them in field with a bit of sand and water (this is not possible with coated).

I store my teensy store in cookware with no problems. Pack with bandana / paper towels to cut rattle noise.

I own 4 sets of all the above types of pots, plus several odd pieces, and i prefer my MSR Alpine stainless steel set because its tough, survives repeated trips / gorilla baggage handlers / my mistakes and cleans easily with soap and common sand. MSR has sold this cookset for at least 17 years (bought mine in 1989) with no changes needed. I use a titanium evernew pot on backpacking trips. Weight is less critical when BIKEpacking.

If you go with liquid fuel store outside of bag to avoid inevitable spills from damaging food/gear. Thats why you often see a fuel bottle jammed in the under downtube / third bottle cage position.

cyccommute
06-15-06, 02:51 PM
Some pots come coated with teflon. My experience is that teflon lasts a short time even on expensive gourmet level kitchen skillets, and you eat some of the teflon that comes off. I prefer uncoated pots, you can clean them in field with a bit of sand and water (this is not possible with coated).



Considering that teflon is a nonreactive polymer (that's why stuff doesn't stick to it;) ), ingesting it isn't a problem. It just passes right on through. Modern teflon coatings don't come off that easily however. I have cookware at home that has been used daily for 10 years and still has the coating. My Blacklite pans have been used for lots of camping and tours and has not a scratch. You can't scrub it with sand but you don't have to. Wipe the excess food out with a paper towel, use a little water and soap and a mild wash pad (a Dobie pad works well) and you are on your way. No need to scrub with sand and water which, by the way, isn't that good for streams. Fish don't really need nor like pasta.

avatarworf
06-15-06, 03:13 PM
Thanks all. I'm leaning towards the MSR Alpine set, largely because I don't want to deal with any non-stick coatings and while the GSI Extreme stuff looks good, it doesn't seem to be available in the UK. Thanks again for all your help.

tourbike
06-15-06, 05:16 PM
i wouldn't store ANY stove in the cookset, unless you are fond of potentially going blind from methanol or ill from accidental petroleum injestion.

I hate to disagree with you, but as a former fire-eater, I used white gas (benzene) as my fuel of choice for over 7 years, and I ain't dead yet. While I am sure it isn't good for you, a little residue doesn't mean much, when you consider I have probably drank the equivalent of a quart or more over my career.

Benzene or White Gas is a fairly purified form of gasoline that is the petroleum equivalent of alcohol, but obviously more flammable. I haven't suffered any ill effects yet, but then, I could die of cancer tomorrow. Who knows? It's been years since I performed. I think the best solution for taking care of residue is a little soapy water, you'll be fine... I've stored my Svea in my cookpot for years.

gpsblake
06-15-06, 09:22 PM
I use the Walmart grease pot. Real light, real easy to clean, real easy to eat out of. It's a favorite among Appalachian trail hikers who like lightweight cooking pots. Packs nicely also.

radical_edward
06-15-06, 09:49 PM
I use the Primus pots, which are hard anodized like the GSI pots, but also have a non stick coating. I have two pots, a pan and a kettle that nest. I also have a Kovea titanium cannister stove that fits inside the kettle. Also a kovea 'moonwalker' stove, and a small camp kitchen zip case (like a small toilet bag) with plastic bottles of salt/pepper/mixed herbs/oil, teabags and extra utensils.

I usually don't carry all of this kit! It depends on where I am going, and how large the group is. I only carry the kettle and stove if going lightweight. A pot or two if touring in a group, and the works if car camping on mountainbiking trips.

Non stick means non scrub! With these pots, when the non stick wears, there is still durable hard anodising underneath.

I carry a tiny silicone scraper (shaped like a leaf!) that I got from a japanese goods store but you can get silicone type scrapers from most dept stores and just remove the handle. This lets me scrape away most of the food, and then clean up requires a moist pack towel segment with some detergent, rinse the pack towel and wipe again. I can wash up two pots with less than a cup of water if I have to. As mentioned, use the pack towel to stop the pots clanking.

If you use lexan cutlery, then the problem of scratching the pots is eliminated. MSR make folding scoops and spatulas, but I much prefer using 'real' utensils and cutting the handles down.

derath
06-15-06, 10:35 PM
This is all I take when backpacking. It may not be the lightest overall, but it is DAMN cool to make up a pizza or bake some brownies in the middle of nowhere. The pan is teflon and works equally well for frying and boiling water. (well the water is a bit trickier due to the pan's shape, but it works).

http://www.backcountrygear.com/catalog/accessdetail.cfm?PRODUCTS__ProductID=BP1000


-D

Bekologist
06-15-06, 10:58 PM
exposure to benzene is toxic, and so is injestion of methanol. you don't want to be swallowing white gas if you can avoid it, i believe. methanol actually causes blindness and in very low concentrations

hey, i've gargled with %100 DEET jungle juice, and i ain't dead yet either, but i'm not going to recommend it as a way to keep mosquitos off.

ive stored my stove in my kit plenty of times over the last 30 years, but i don't anymore.

and i like SVEAs and whisperlites and trangias and what not.

Erick L
06-16-06, 05:50 AM
I'd have to disagree on the MSR Blacklite. I've had mine for a long time and it's very durable.

Mine didn't last very long, coating and the pot itself. They're not as durable as the Duralite, which are hard anodized. (they don't call it dura for nothing!) You can get the same hard anodized for almost half the price with the GSI, and they have a non-stick coating too.

cyccommute
06-16-06, 09:00 AM
I hate to disagree with you, but as a former fire-eater, I used white gas (benzene) as my fuel of choice for over 7 years, and I ain't dead yet. While I am sure it isn't good for you, a little residue doesn't mean much, when you consider I have probably drank the equivalent of a quart or more over my career.

Benzene or White Gas is a fairly purified form of gasoline that is the petroleum equivalent of alcohol, but obviously more flammable. I haven't suffered any ill effects yet, but then, I could die of cancer tomorrow. Who knows? It's been years since I performed. I think the best solution for taking care of residue is a little soapy water, you'll be fine... I've stored my Svea in my cookpot for years.

You did not use benzene as a fire-eater and live to tell the tale. White gas is not benzene. It is a cut of petroleum distillate that is commonly called naptha and contains only straight chain hydrocarbons. It has a low boiling point, a low vapor pressure and isn't that flamable (similar to kerosene which is also used by fire eaters). Like kerosene and diesel fuel, it is also not terribly toxic.

Benzene is a cyclic aromatic hydrocarbon. It has a slightly higher boiling point, a higher vapor pressure and is extremely flammable. It is used in gasoline as an antiknock agent and is a known human carcinogen. If you use benzene as fuel for a fire-eater act, I pretty sure that you would have incinerated the first couple of rows of your audience as well as yourself.

eubi
06-16-06, 10:56 AM
I'd get a pot big enough to do the job and small enough to fit in my panniers (or backpack).

I've used everything from fancy Titanium to an old coffe can, and you know what? They all work the same!

My favorite now is a no-name aluminum pot. I painted the bottom black with high temp paint for better heat transfer.

cyccommute
06-16-06, 12:09 PM
I'd get a pot big enough to do the job and small enough to fit in my panniers (or backpack).

I've used everything from fancy Titanium to an old coffe can, and you know what? They all work the same!

My favorite now is a no-name aluminum pot. I painted the bottom black with high temp paint for better heat transfer.

For several years, I used a pot set that I put together after trying several different cheap sets which meet their demise when I ran out of elbow grease to clean the charcoal out of the bottom. I used a regular 2l pot, a 1.2l pot and a small skillet, all aluminum with teflon coating. I removed the handles, wrapped the screw that the handle attached to with tape and then padded the inside of the pots with paper towels to keep them from rattling and to protect the coating. Because of the thickness of the pots (about 1/4"), they heated very evenly...even better than the MSR Blacklite I use now. The only drawback is that they are about twice a heavy. I still use them for car camping.

Losligato
06-16-06, 04:15 PM
Our MSR Blacklite is literally falling apart. AVOID!

The MSR Stowaway pot is great (http://www.rei.com/online/store/ProductDisplay?productId=2098&storeId=8000&catalogId=40000008000&langId=-1&color=&img=/media/601897Lrg.jpg&view=large). We make lunch in the morning and carry it with us until lunch time in this sealable pot. Very nice.

Timonabike
06-16-06, 05:56 PM
I'd have to disagree on the MSR Blacklite. I've had mine for a long time and it's very durable. It heats evenly and isn't too heavy. I much prefer a teflon coating to trying to scrub out a noncoated pan. I have a 1.5 l and 2 l pot. I also carry a tea kettle since pouring water out of one of these pots is next to impossible. (The MSR Alpine pot is good.)

One precaution that I take is to line each pan and the lid with a spider mat. The spider mat keeps the pans from rubbing together in a pannier and has lots of uses during food prep.

I'd agree on titanium. Titanium has about the same density as aluminum so it won't save any appreciable weight and it cost a lot more.

"Spider Mat"????

Can you tell us more about what this is and the 'lots of uses'?

Thanks,

Tim

Riderfan_lee
06-16-06, 06:27 PM
Our MSR Blacklite is literally falling apart. AVOID!

The MSR Stowaway pot is great (http://www.rei.com/online/store/ProductDisplay?productId=2098&storeId=8000&catalogId=40000008000&langId=-1&color=&img=/media/601897Lrg.jpg&view=large). We make lunch in the morning and carry it with us until lunch time in this sealable pot. Very nice.

How is it literally falling apart? Do you mean the coating? Because unless the aluminum is cracking or the coating is coming off, I can't see how it can fall apart. I am curious because I just bought a set and am pretty happy with them with the limited use I have had with them.

tourbike
06-16-06, 07:37 PM
exposure to benzene is toxic, and so is injestion of methanol. you don't want to be swallowing white gas if you can avoid it, i believe. methanol actually causes blindness and in very low concentrations

hey, i've gargled with %100 DEET jungle juice, and i ain't dead yet either, but i'm not going to recommend it as a way to keep mosquitos off.

ive stored my stove in my kit plenty of times over the last 30 years, but i don't anymore.

and i like SVEAs and whisperlites and trangias and what not.

Experience versus paranoia?

tourbike
06-16-06, 07:43 PM
You did not use benzene as a fire-eater and live to tell the tale. White gas is not benzene. It is a cut of petroleum distillate that is commonly called naptha and contains only straight chain hydrocarbons. It has a low boiling point, a low vapor pressure and isn't that flamable (similar to kerosene which is also used by fire eaters). Like kerosene and diesel fuel, it is also not terribly toxic.

Benzene is a cyclic aromatic hydrocarbon. It has a slightly higher boiling point, a higher vapor pressure and is extremely flammable. It is used in gasoline as an antiknock agent and is a known human carcinogen. If you use benzene as fuel for a fire-eater act, I pretty sure that you would have incinerated the first couple of rows of your audience as well as yourself.


Study up. The very same fuel that is called White Gas here in the US is the very same fuel used in Europe called Benzene. I'm not talking about the chemical Benzene, but the one you buy in stores. I've toured in Europe and the same product that is White Gas here, is Benzene there. I was speaking on the consumer-level. I'm just trying to speak to the market, the very people who consume.

hillyman
06-16-06, 07:46 PM
Experience versus paranoia?
Yes, but did you try eating fire and riding a bike at the same time? Could be very dangerous!

tourbike
06-17-06, 12:31 PM
Yes, but did you try eating fire and riding a bike at the same time? Could be very dangerous!

Now that would be something to see. Thankfully I won't be trying it as I quit years ago.:)

Losligato
06-17-06, 03:48 PM
How is it literally falling apart? Do you mean the coating? Because unless the aluminum is cracking or the coating is coming off, I can't see how it can fall apart. I am curious because I just bought a set and am pretty happy with them with the limited use I have had with them.


The exterior of our MSR BlackLite pot is peeling off of the aluminum. Also, we made popcorn once and the non-stick coating on the interior of the pot is now pitted. They are lightweight but not very duriable for a long tour.

cyccommute
06-17-06, 04:01 PM
"Spider Mat"????

Can you tell us more about what this is and the 'lots of uses'?

Thanks,

Tim

Sorry. "Spider Mat" was a brand name for a rubberized mat that sticks to stuff but it isn't adhesive. Target, and most home stores like Bed Bath and Beyond, sells it in rolls of about 24" wide by 3 feet long. Sears also sells the stuff for lining the bottom of tool draws to keep tools from sliding around. Grip liner (http://www.kittrich.com/MC/Grip/mc_non_adhesive.htm) is the product I got from Target. When I'm traveling, it acts as a good cushion between the pans and when I get to a campsite, the mat keeps stuff from sliding off tables, etc.

For example, I use Orikaso (http://www.rei.com/product/47907748.htm?vcat=REI_SSHP_CAMPING_TOC) for dishes. They store nice and flat, weigh next to nothing and are more civilized then eating out of the pot...especially if you aren't traveling alone ;) I carry one for each person and one for a cutting board for food prep. But they are horribly slippery! Especially when used as a cutting board. Put the rubber mat under them and you don't have to chase the damned things all over a table!

I also use this mat under pillows in my sleeping bag, to put stuff on that I'd rather not migrate during the night...like glasses, watch, etc...in the tent. It's useful for all kinds of stuff!

cyccommute
06-17-06, 04:22 PM
Study up. The very same fuel that is called White Gas here in the US is the very same fuel used in Europe called Benzene. I'm not talking about the chemical Benzene, but the one you buy in stores. I've toured in Europe and the same product that is White Gas here, is Benzene there. I was speaking on the consumer-level. I'm just trying to speak to the market, the very people who consume.

I would doubt very highly that white gas, or more correctly, naptha, is mislabeled in Europe as benzene. Considering that the chemical structure for benzene was derived in Germany and that Germans have a long history of producing excellent chemists, I doubt that they would mislabel a relatively nontoxic substances like naptha as benzene which is highly toxic. Benzene doesn't just have chronic toxic effects like cancer, but also has fairly immediate toxic effects. Whatever you bought that was labeled as 'benzene' most certainly wasn't naptha!

Bekologist
06-17-06, 08:15 PM
MSDS safety pretty well spell out toxcicities and cautions for all those chemicals commonly used as stove fuel. none is innocous, not even everclear grain alcohol....


In Germany, auto gasoline is benzin; white gas for stoves is kocherbenzin and a few other names too;

here is a link to worldwide fuel names, useful for world travellers....

http://members.iinet.net.au/~mbuckler/fuel/index.shtml

tourbike
06-17-06, 11:41 PM
I would doubt very highly that white gas, or more correctly, naptha, is mislabeled in Europe as benzene. Considering that the chemical structure for benzene was derived in Germany and that Germans have a long history of producing excellent chemists, I doubt that they would mislabel a relatively nontoxic substances like naptha as benzene which is highly toxic. Benzene doesn't just have chronic toxic effects like cancer, but also has fairly immediate toxic effects. Whatever you bought that was labeled as 'benzene' most certainly wasn't naptha!

Hey, you're the big expert. Me, I just went to Europe and Africa whereas White Gas is labelled as Benzene. Look, Science Guy, I am relating my experience as I know it. Funny thing about World traveling is that the same references you have at home don't always apply everywhere else.

I'm not denying some toxic effects, but then, I wasn't using pure Benzene, but White gas is labelled as Benzene elsewhere. Got it yet?

tourbike
06-17-06, 11:43 PM
MSDS safety pretty well spell out toxcicities and cautions for all those chemicals commonly used as stove fuel. none is innocous, not even everclear grain alcohol....


In Germany, auto gasoline is benzin; white gas for stoves is kocherbenzin and a few other names too;

here is a link to worldwide fuel names, useful for world travellers....

http://members.iinet.net.au/~mbuckler/fuel/index.shtml

THANK you.

cyccommute
06-18-06, 10:58 AM
THANK you.

Now it is you who need to study up. In German, benzene is benzol. Kocherbenzin is, literally, digester gasoline which is what naptha is. Naptha is sent to a "digester" or catalytic cracker to be made into what we call gasoline but in Germany is called benzin. And, if you had bothered to read through the list, in column 3, each of those names is a pretty direct translation to "white gas" or "naptha". Not a single one translates to 'benzene' which, as I've pointed out before, is an entirely different animal.

You see, I assume that chemists...even ones that don't speak the same language as me...would know that 'benzene' is toxic and wouldn't really want it out in general use because, after all, they are the experts!

cyccommute
06-18-06, 11:04 AM
MSDS safety pretty well spell out toxcicities and cautions for all those chemicals commonly used as stove fuel. none is innocous, not even everclear grain alcohol....


In Germany, auto gasoline is benzin; white gas for stoves is kocherbenzin and a few other names too;

here is a link to worldwide fuel names, useful for world travellers....

http://members.iinet.net.au/~mbuckler/fuel/index.shtml

I would agree that you don't want to be gargling with stove fuel on a regular basis but, compared to benzene or even gasoline, white gas is pretty safe. I'd carry it away from any food if I used the stuff but then I don't mix chemicals and food anywhere, anyway. It is always best to separate your foodstuff from any even mildly toxic chemicals you might be carrying. Fuel, DEET, sunscreen, dish soap, bath soap, shampoo, etc go in a completely separate bag from food and cooking hardware.

tourbike
06-18-06, 12:07 PM
Now it is you who need to study up. In German, benzene is benzol. Kocherbenzin is, literally, digester gasoline which is what naptha is. Naptha is sent to a "digester" or catalytic cracker to be made into what we call gasoline but in Germany is called benzin. And, if you had bothered to read through the list, in column 3, each of those names is a pretty direct translation to "white gas" or "naptha". Not a single one translates to 'benzene' which, as I've pointed out before, is an entirely different animal.

You see, I assume that chemists...even ones that don't speak the same language as me...would know that 'benzene' is toxic and wouldn't really want it out in general use because, after all, they are the experts!

You tire me, really, because you are only proving my point. The product called white gas in Europe isn't called "Benzene", and in Germany it is called 6 different variations of "Benzin" ;
Kocherbenzin
Feuerzeug Benzin
Katalyt Benzin
Reinigungsbenzin
Reinbenzin
Fleckenbenzin
Wundbenzin

How is "Benzin" pronounced in Germany? Exactly like our pronounciation of "Benzene". So when one walks into a camp store in most of Europe and wishes for white gas/naphtha, they say "Benzene". That was my freaking point, without having to go into descriptions of Benzene rings and molecular structure, I am very well aware of what Benzene is. I was talking about white gas/naphtha, you are the only who seems to be confused about this point.

I am also quite aware of what naphtha is, having worked with it on a professional level for years.

I'm pretty done with this, unless you absolutely MUST be right, but this isn't a chemistry forum.

sakarias
06-18-06, 12:54 PM
How is the lead content in pots these days. The old aluminum pots used to be pretty bad, but that was before the likes of MSR started making them.

I wondered if you could provide some reference(s) to this lead in (older) aluminum pots statement.

Thanks

Mike

vik
06-18-06, 01:18 PM
I have used MSR blacklite pots for several trips including a 3.5 month kayak trip in baja. They worked well for the trips that did not involve sandy environments. On our Baja trip the teflon coating got completely trashed. We were trying to be careful, but in a desert and/or on a beach when you live from your backpack/kayak sand eventually gets into everything.

If I was traveling in areas where I had access to lots of water and sand wasn't an issue I would use blacklite pots again. Just remember not to heat them without something in the pan/pot or the teflon coating can get damaged.

I have also used MSR's stainless steel pots/pans extensively and they work well and are very durable, but the clean up can be quite a hassle.

I am currently using MSR's Duralite anodized aluminum pots/pans. I think these may be a winner with better durability than the blacklite and better non-stick than SS. Time will tell.

cyccommute
06-18-06, 11:47 PM
You tire me, really, because you are only proving my point. The product called white gas in Europe isn't called "Benzene", and in Germany it is called 6 different variations of "Benzin" ;
Kocherbenzin
Feuerzeug Benzin
Katalyt Benzin
Reinigungsbenzin
Reinbenzin
Fleckenbenzin
Wundbenzin

Nothing like a little out of context quoting to try and prove your point. If you look at column 2 of the list, benzin is what we would call gasoline. All 6 of those variations translate to something that is used to make gasoline and none of them are 'benzene' or benzol.


How is "Benzin" pronounced in Germany? Exactly like our pronounciation of "Benzene". So when one walks into a camp store in most of Europe and wishes for white gas/naphtha, they say "Benzene". That was my freaking point, without having to go into descriptions of Benzene rings and molecular structure, I am very well aware of what Benzene is. I was talking about white gas/naphtha, you are the only who seems to be confused about this point.

I am also quite aware of what naphtha is, having worked with it on a professional level for years.

I'm pretty done with this, unless you absolutely MUST be right, but this isn't a chemistry forum.

It's been a while since I took German but benzin would have been pronounced with a long 'i' (like nine) and not an 'e' (like benzene) by all the teachers I had.

When you made your original post, you did not say anything about traveling in Europe. You stated, incorrectly, that benzene (english spelling) and white gas (naphtha) were the same and that you used benzene in a fire eating act without ill effect. This indicates to me that you don't know the difference and I was pointing out your error.

If you do know the difference, then you are providing people with information and advice that you know is incorrect, which I would feel that it is my duty to educate them about. This may not be a chemistry forum but people still need to know what is okay to use and what may harm them. Or do you absolutely NEED to be right?

avatarworf
06-18-06, 11:51 PM
Not sure if either of you remember, but I started this thread to talk about cookware. Unless you can keep it on topic and polite, may I respectfully suggest you make this discussion private. Thanks.

gregw
06-19-06, 08:22 AM
Not sure if either of you remember, but I started this thread to talk about cookware. Unless you can keep it on topic and polite, may I respectfully suggest you make this discussion private. Thanks.

I agree!!

My input is a single Aluminum pot (teflon coated) with lid. (unless you wash with sand paper, they do hold-up) Size big enough for the typical one pot wonder, ramen / Lipton, meal with added veggies and meat / fish. Stove of choice with good wind screen and pot cozy to save on fuel. If your pot has a separate handle, spray paint it a fluorescent color to keep you from loosing it. Mine came flat black and it in on the ground in the Tetons somewhere right now, my replacement is now neon orange

BigNoseWhipper
06-21-06, 06:14 PM
when on tour i like to use ak-47 or some purple haze

spokewrench55
06-21-06, 11:58 PM
i use old 'luminum Bulldog billies! they're british and they're brilliant!
Perfect lid system!

Dude!

My dearly loved Bulldog set is over thirty years old and still going. Are they still made?

Bekologist
06-22-06, 12:55 AM
my Bulldogs are older than dirt as well. i hope they are still made, i would hope so. anyone on the other side of the pond with great familiarity of camping equipment??

geoffs
06-22-06, 04:11 AM
We use the MSR Duralit when touring. Instead of spidermat we use a small packtowel between them which doubles as a teatowel.
We previously used the MSR whisperlite international but it doesn't simmer well so for our last 6 week tour we bought the Dragonfly which is brilliant. I cooked meals for 5 people with a few courses on the menu and a bit of juggling.
Crepes with Nutella always go down well.
Frypan is the GSI 250mm. Another invaluble thing to use is the silicon spatula that REI sells.

Cheers

Geoff