Fifty Plus (50+) - Not going to be riding for a while
Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.
10-13-06, 04:07 PM
I was out Thursday, a beautiful sunny (albeit cold) day. Getting started on my usual 32 mile ride, and about 7 miles into the trail, my left pedal starts to wobble. I stopped to check this out, only to find that my pedal is not the problem, it is the crank arm and where it attaches to the bike. I head back, coasting only since I don't want to damage the crank. About 200 yards from the turnaround, it falls off anyway. Well I suppose its a good thing I am up hill from the house. Still, I ended up walking about 1mile, and now the bike has to go back to the LBS where I bought it. I can't do it till Monday though. I am working all weekend. I do hope they can get it repaired in one day. I certainly don't want to be without my bilke for very long:( I also hope that this will be covered by the warranty. I only bought it in April
10-13-06, 04:10 PM
That is one of the best reasons(excuses) to have 2 bikes!
Hope it gets fixed.
10-13-06, 07:41 PM
I had a similar event last year on my p8. I just continued to ride, pushing in with my left leg as I pedaled. Then tightened it at home. It was the first time ever that the crank had come loose on a bike I have owned since 1985
Ideally, the left crank should be affixed with a left-threaded bolt, but this was tried only once, to my knowledge, by Shimano, I believe. A dab of blue LocTite on the left crank's fixing bolt is probably a good idea. On a similar note, be sure to torque your car's lugbolts/nuts properly, particularly those on the left side.
10-15-06, 12:30 AM
That's probably a five-minute, $5 fix, unless you've rounded out the hole in the crankarm. Then it's a five-minute, $150 fix. I'd mention the warranty angle, on the basis that a crankbolt that was properly torqued when it left the shop wouldn't have worked loose, but I also understand the shop's probable defense: If you rode the bike after you realized the crankarm was loose, everything that happened after that was on you. Then you say, "But I was far from home" and they say "if you'd done proper maintenance, it wouldn't have come loose" and everybody's unhappy.
But I still say a bike that was assembled right when it left the shop wouldn't lose a crankarm.
10-15-06, 12:49 AM
Good Heavens.....I've ridden one bike (shame on me) without removing or tightening the crank arm for 8 years. You've had that crankarm on for only 6 months. They damned sure better cover it themselves...faulty assembly is a reflection on them.
10-15-06, 06:38 AM
You damn skippy. The bike shop bought that problem, even if you did round out the crankarm. Take it back and make them fix it
10-15-06, 07:13 AM
Sounds like a good reason to take a new bike in to have everything checked after the first couple of hundred miles…
10-15-06, 08:32 AM
I took the bike back in May for a 30 day free maintenance/ adjustment. I had some problems with the rear deraileur not shifting properly and they took care of it in a matter of minutes. I suppose I could have fixed the crank myself had the bolt not fallen out on the trail somewhere. When I first noticed the problem and stopped to check it, the bolt was still in and I could not remove the crank ( I would have taken it off at that point to avoid further damage). As it is, I coasted down the hill (Cherry creek Spillway) to the light at Yale. About 200 yards from where I turned around, the crank just fell off. I did not pedal at all. My foot was resting on the center boom.
On another note, I find it odd too, that the crank would fall off like that. I have ridden my Giant Sedona from 1994 until 2004. I had the crank set changed 3 times during those years and never once did the crank come loose and fall off. I had a Roadmaster, that my mom bought for me when we lived in CA, that had a pedal corrode and fall off, but this is a first.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.12 Copyright © 2014 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.