Xanti Andia
01-17-07, 09:39 AM
Can I have an opinion on these two dents on a used bike I am looking at? Are they purely cosmetic or can they have an effect on the integrity of the frame? It is a CroMo frame.
View Full Version : opinion on two dents on a used bike I am looking at?
waterrockets
01-17-07, 09:45 AM
Cosmetic. The big one is on the down tube, which is a tension member, so it shouldn't matter at all. The little on is on the side of the top tube, which is a bit more of a concern, but it's such a small dent, that I wouldn't worry about it.
Nice S&S couplings by the way.
Nice S&S couplings by the way.
Leisesturm
01-17-07, 10:14 AM
Cosmetic. The big one is on the down tube, which is a tension member, so it shouldn't matter at all. The little on is on the side of the top tube, which is a bit more of a concern, but it's such a small dent, that I wouldn't worry about it.
Agreed, the dents themselves are not likely to be issues of impending frame failure but wouldn't a buyer observing them want to get that ruler out again and go over the alignment of the entire bicycle? Probably should be done anyway even if a bike looks cosmetically perfect, but here we have definite evidence of incidents in the past, minor or otherwise.
Agreed, the dents themselves are not likely to be issues of impending frame failure but wouldn't a buyer observing them want to get that ruler out again and go over the alignment of the entire bicycle? Probably should be done anyway even if a bike looks cosmetically perfect, but here we have definite evidence of incidents in the past, minor or otherwise.
TandemGeek
01-17-07, 10:28 AM
Can I have an opinion on these two dents on a used bike I am looking at? Are they purely cosmetic or can they have an effect on the integrity of the frame? It is a CroMo frame.
What did the folks at Co-Motion say when you sent them your question with your photos...???
I've seen worse and don't disagree that they're probably cosmetic; however, I would recommend getting the "best" informed assessment you can and that would most certainly come from the builder.
What did the folks at Co-Motion say when you sent them your question with your photos...???
I've seen worse and don't disagree that they're probably cosmetic; however, I would recommend getting the "best" informed assessment you can and that would most certainly come from the builder.
TandemGeek
01-17-07, 10:31 AM
The little on is on the side of the top tube, which is a bit more of a concern, but it's such a small dent, that I wouldn't worry about it.
Hmmm. Never seen a threaded water bottle boss on the top tube of a Co-Motion tandem.
Hmmm. Never seen a threaded water bottle boss on the top tube of a Co-Motion tandem.
Xanti Andia
01-17-07, 10:34 AM
What did the folks at Co-Motion say when you sent them your question with your photos...???
I did not ask them, perhaps I should, but good job identifying the maker!
I did not ask them, perhaps I should, but good job identifying the maker!
waterrockets
01-17-07, 01:35 PM
Hmmm. Never seen a threaded water bottle boss on the top tube of a Co-Motion tandem.
Oh, c'mon, it's the latest rage.
<my bad> got thrown by the angle, and thought I was seeing rear brake cable. Maybe that's just a bolt head and washer balanced on top of the tube :P
Oh, c'mon, it's the latest rage.
<my bad> got thrown by the angle, and thought I was seeing rear brake cable. Maybe that's just a bolt head and washer balanced on top of the tube :P
ElRey
01-18-07, 04:44 AM
Looks like my frame!!! You can't go wrong... so long as CO MO agrees the dents are not a concern.
Brian
01-18-07, 08:19 PM
Since they're so close to the coupler, they shouldn't be a concern. But by the same token, shouldn't competent builder be able to get in there and fix that?
vBulletin® v3.7.3, Copyright ©2000-2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.