Bicycle Mechanics - How sharp is too sharp?
Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.
Jean Beetham Smith
08-27-01, 07:24 PM
We all know not to ride big ring-big sprocket or small ring-small sprocket because the chain is at too sharp an angle. Richard Ballantine in Richard's 21st Century bicycle book says that triple chain rings on 7,8, or 9 speed blocks you should avoid 2 cogs on either side of the extreme, and that the middle ring shouldn't be used with the extreme cogs either. Is there a rational way of figuring out which angles are too extreme? Does the chain width effect the acceptable angles? Does anybody really know these things or is it all trial & error? If so, why don't production bikes come with charts of the "right" gear combos and the no-nos?
08-27-01, 08:29 PM
A little trial and error I would say. You can really see when you are cross chaining badly. There really is no need for it. You should be able to find a comfortable gear without going to extremes. Personally, I ride 1-4 on the granny gear, 3-6, maybe 7th on the middle ring and 5-8 on the big ring. Just experiment...
08-28-01, 12:31 AM
Using the inside to outside small to small etc. combinations are a bad ida on 2 chainring bikes as well. On five, six and 7 speed compact clusters do not use one outer or inner cog with the opposite chianring. On 7,8,9 speed clusters two cogs.
My chain rubs on the outer chainring if I try to use either of my outer two cogs when I'm in my small chainring on my 53/39 X 13-23 set-up and others.
Extreme angles cause-
Uneven pressure, thus quicker wear on the bushings in the chainlinks. ( That's where "chain-stretch" comes from).
The chain plates to rub and erode the chain-ring and cogset teeth and against each other.
Ride that chain-line straight
You should be able to use ALL cogs when you are in the middle ring of a triple ring bike.
I was going to post a thread on why I can't adjust my Ultegra triple to quiet down when at the extremes.
Now, I find I shouldn't be there in the first place.
Once again, unexpectantly, I've learned something new.
Allowable chain angles are a function of lateral chain flexibility and chainring tooth profile. I agree that one should avoid the large/large and small/small combinations on almost any modern derailleur bicycle, but which (if any) other combinations to avoid depends also on chainstay length, chainring size difference, cogset width, and chainring-to-cog alignment. If you can make the chain run quietly and if it stays on the chainring when you backpedal, you are in a usable gear.
Both of my road bikes, which use 8-tooth chainring drops (50-42 and 52-44) and mid-size 7-speed freewheels (13-26 and 14-28), work well in all combinations except large/large. On my 3/7 mountain bike (48-40-24 / 13-26), I avoid 24/13, 24/15, and 48/26.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.12 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.