General Cycling Discussion - what's the right bike for the job?

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




atomship47
07-18-07, 07:22 AM
...trying to think of an alternative title to another "which bike should i buy" thread.

i'm a roadie convert (from comfort/hybrid mup rides). here is my intended use....

i have a getaway place near galena, il. about 50% of my rides there are on less-than-friendly gravel roads. riding my roadie is out. i just use my trek 7300 to ride there. and i'm slowly converting this bike to be more road-friendly (28mm tires, rigid seat post, etc.).

i'd like a bike that i can bring with me to places where i can go on rides that are on a combination of paved roads and really rough gravel roads. before i went on my trip out west, i was thinking a 'cross bike would be the way to go. however, there was a 1-mile stretch of gravel road in teton n.p. that bounced me around on my roadie so much that it makes me think i need something with a suspension.

what are your thoughts?

-should i just use my 7300 but convert it to a more efficient road bike? the downside to this is i don't like the riding position. i think i'll need to swap out my stem/handlebars. also, i'm heavy and my front suspension is too soft...even at the stiffest pre-load setting.

-would a 'cross bike be a good bet or would rough gravel roads bounce me around just as much? i guess the only major benefit would be a sturdier wheelset.

-should i look at mtn bikes? i'm not going to be rock-hopping or stump jumping. i'm thinking a pure mtn bike may not be for me since i'm looking for a bike that is road-friendly.



thoughts, comments, suggestions?


markhr
07-18-07, 08:01 AM
The cheapest option is just convert your existing bike but that never stopped anyone from buying a new bike for the sake of it - and don't let it stop you ;) :D

cyclocross with disc brakes - I am biased

try voodoo, redline, salsa, kona, opus, cannondale, mountaincycle, lemond, norco, etc

http://www.huntvalleybicycles.com/images/products/06bikes/06cannondale/06cann-cyclocrossdisc.jpg
http://2006.lemondbikes.com/images/2006_bikes/medium/poprad_disc.jpg
http://media.twango.com/m1/large/0014/55aa770bfd964d2b87f61b0cf43a35f7.jpg
http://www.norco.com/2007bikes/images/bikes_reg/96_1.jpg
http://brodiebikes.com/2006/images/bikes/large/romax.jpg

geo8rge
07-18-07, 08:53 AM
Try new smooth tires. If you are not going off road you probably do not need a suspension fork.

Folding bikes work for travel.
xooter.com swift, Bike Friday or Dahon Mu XL?


blickblocks
07-18-07, 09:29 AM
Get a CX bike. They rock.

dynamitemonkey
07-18-07, 10:00 AM
After reading many 'what bike should I get' threads while trying to pick a bike for myself, I found the general consensus to be: get a Surly Cross-Check . Either buy it complete or build it to your specifications. Everyone who has it loves it and it is good for a little bit of everything.

FWIW I just upgraded my current bike. That proved to be the cheapest way to get what I needed.

atomship47
07-18-07, 10:56 AM
i've got 28mm bontrager race lite's on the bike now.

when i was in teton n.p., my rides were mostly paved with some nasty gravel roads going up to trail heads. seemed like just the terrain for a cross bike. when i went to the lbs's in the area and asked about cx bikes, they said VERY few people ever buy them out there. they just get the ocassional special order.