Vehicular Cycling (VC) - Hit and run in Hawaii, big island

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




View Full Version : Hit and run in Hawaii, big island


Buz Carragher
09-16-07, 04:16 PM
March 3, '07 hit by large pick-up truck and knocked out. Lots of injuries, coma 6 days, 2 weeks ICU. Police officer did not charge driver he said I fell and had road rash. Helmet crushed in rear but no body damage to rear, back or shoulders. Could not damage helmet by striking ground and not hit back unless LINDA BLAIR,

Police refuse to issue report and sight Hawaii Privacy Laws, only redacted report telling me who I am.
Help.


invisiblehand
09-17-07, 01:33 PM
March 3, '07 hit by large pick-up truck and knocked out. Lots of injuries, coma 6 days, 2 weeks ICU. Police officer did not charge driver he said I fell and had road rash. Helmet crushed in rear but no body damage to rear, back or shoulders. Could not damage helmet by striking ground and not hit back unless LINDA BLAIR,

Police refuse to issue report and sight Hawaii Privacy Laws, only redacted report telling me who I am.
Help.

There is a bigger audience in the regular A&S forum. I would post this there instead since this is not directly linked to vehicular cycling.

I would talk to a lawyer.

DCCommuter
09-17-07, 04:28 PM
You need to talk to a lawyer.


LittleBigMan
09-17-07, 05:32 PM
Get a reputable personal injury lawyer. They know the game, and play to win.

Bekologist
09-17-07, 08:07 PM
CBHI, any input?

Is Hawaii a 'no fault' state? are drivers required to have PIP coverage? What's up with this rider being unable to glean info from the authorities?

is your state that hostile towards bicyclists that they are prevented in attempts at recovering damages in traffic incidents because of 'privacy laws?'

what gives, CB?

LittleBigMan
09-21-07, 07:29 PM
CB Hawaii has posted continuously on the unfriendliness of his state towards cyclists.

Are you just now getting this? What gives, Mr. Bekologist?

Carrying Bike Lane Wars to the extreme?

I thought you were a friend to cyclists everywhere....? (I guess capitalizing on tragedy goes on all around.)

Bekologist
09-21-07, 11:25 PM
WOAH, lil' bigg.

i'm asking legitimate questions.... is or isn't Hawaii a no fault state? does Hawaii have mandated or optional PIP insurance coverage? why would a cyclist injured in a collision with a vehicle be unable to contact the drivers' insurance company?

your attempt at smearing me is lousy, lil big man. CBHI is the most active hawaii poster to the A&S forum. I'm not picking sides, dude - there is no 'war' in my post.

EXCALIBUR
09-21-07, 11:44 PM
Hawaii is a no fault state.

CB HI
09-22-07, 01:57 AM
Just got back from work on the Big Island, so tonight is the first chance to read the thread.

Hawaii is a no fault state and requires motorist to carry insurance. More important, state law requires motor insurance to cover personal injury to a pedestrian or cyclist, regardless of fault. Property damage depends on who was at fault.

As to privacy laws prohibiting the release of a traffic accident report, that is pure BS. Most likely a case of a Hawaii County Police Officer, from a small town knowing the motorist and feeding such BS to the cyclist to try and protect the driver. People involved in a traffic accident are not required to call the police unless there is bodily injury or property damage greater than $3000. They are required to exchange identification and insurance information if police are not called. If 911 cannot be reached, and there is personal injury to a cyclist, the motorist is required to transport the cyclist to medical care. When police are called to a traffic accident, they are required to record ID and insurance information to be included in the police report. Both parties are allowed to get a copy of that report in full without any court order.

To the OP, don’t put up with the BS. Demand a copy of the full report and record names of any police or county clerk that give you any BS. Then get a lawyer and take action against the county and the motorist.

We have our share of "Bubba Cops" here, as well as the good cops.

Buz Carragher
09-24-07, 12:35 AM
Thanks for your input, it helps. Police officer Smith apparently accepted the motorist version of events. As I was unconcious I could not add my side of events and was unable to get any info. Since my head cleared a little I've found the 3rd car to arrive with college students who saw that I was not breathing and restored my air way. People in first two cars were just watching me laying on ground not taking in air. Reported by students they gave differing stories male in first vehicle said I was just laying along the side of the road, female said she saw me fall. Third person gave another verson. Student belive they were lying. Students gave tag number to paramedics, don't know if they gave number to police.

Have contacted Wm. Lawson attorney from Hawaii and asked him for help. Thanks,

AskBuz@salisburyCycle.com

Helmet Head
09-28-07, 11:08 PM
LBM - I gotta side with Beck on this one. I don't see any hostility towards CB HI on his part. It reads like a genuine attempt to get some legit info from CB HI, and he seems to be ready to accept its veracity.

LittleBigMan
09-28-07, 11:09 PM
Thanks for your input, it helps. Police officer Smith apparently accepted the motorist version of events. As I was unconcious I could not add my side of events and was unable to get any info. Since my head cleared a little I've found the 3rd car to arrive with college students who saw that I was not breathing and restored my air way. People in first two cars were just watching me laying on ground not taking in air. Reported by students they gave differing stories male in first vehicle said I was just laying along the side of the road, female said she saw me fall. Third person gave another verson. Student belive they were lying. Students gave tag number to paramedics, don't know if they gave number to police.

Have contacted Wm. Lawson attorney from Hawaii and asked him for help. Thanks,

AskBuz@salisburyCycle.com
Keep us updated, hope you heal quickly, friend...

LittleBigMan
09-28-07, 11:13 PM
LBM - I gotta side with Beck on this one. I don't see any hostility towards CB HI on his part. It reads like a genuine attempt to get some legit info from CB HI, and he seems to be ready to accept its veracity.
I won't muddy this good thread beyond suggesting you ask CB-HI how he feels about it. Beyond that, I bow out.

This is Buz's thread.