PDA

View Full Version : VC vs. Hurst's "Urban Cycling"


Pages : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 [11]


Bekologist
11-12-07, 10:21 PM
Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge proponent of wearing bright/visible clothing (much bigger than Robert - let's put it that way). I just happened to learn that in normal good lighting circumstances, it doesn't seem to make much of a difference, at least when I'm using conspicuous lane positioning.

:roflmao: ah, the grand delusions of the armchair ideologue! hahahahaHAHAHAhahaha.

head, you ride (I think) in San Diego, supposedly in rush hour traffic, occasionally. Last time I checked, there's a fair amount of traffic in San diego.

Relying on lane position for safety, particularily when conspicious lane position is only a part time situation, is seriously a pile of steaming ludicrousness.

What, pray tell, does helemt head rely on when he isn't in a conspicuous lane position? the 'panache' of a black jacket he bought off a racer dude? head, you like to pretend you're a bicycle racer, dontchya? poseur!

maybe you should try a lime green fedora, head. motorists might see you better.
Are you running current gen, high powered, daytime visible front & back LEDS to increase your conspicuity regardless of your lane position? of COURSE you're not, you think lane position is your ace in the hole.

ah, fallacies of the armchair rider. good luck, head. you need it!

It's counter-intuitive, I know. But I find centerish lane positioning to be so effective at establishing conspicuity early that any advantage that comes from bright clothing to be negligible.

That's not just counter-intuitive, head- it's idiotic! because bicyclists are never consistently in a primary lane position - yet you postulate you rely on something you only posess part of the time on the roads. Isn't there traffic in San Diego?


Notice that this is consistent with the type of experience Beck reports. With Robert, who, despite what the Mercedes incident and his analysis of it might lead one to think, probably does not ride as far right quite as often as Beck blah blah blah.... Head, you skew my riding. I'm confident I 'take the lane' a lot more miles a week than you, head. I'm quite assertive in my bicycle positioning. I ride, daily, in left hand lanes of four lane roads and use inside lanes of four lanes at traffic signals. All lanes of multi lane arterials, all lane and road positions.

The most common reaction by motorists to a bicyclist as they approach an intersection, regardless of road position or assertiveness, is the averted eyes glance right thru the bicyclist.

do you see that, head? in plain english? or out on the road? Bicyclists, REGARDLESS OF ROAD POSITION, get overlooked. motorists look right thru us. of course, you don't think so. Newbie!

Again, good luck in your black jacket in traffic, hed. you'll need it!

Helmet Head
11-13-07, 11:09 AM
:roflmao: ah, the grand delusions of the armchair ideologue! hahahahaHAHAHAhahaha.

head, you ride (I think) in San Diego, supposedly in rush hour traffic, occasionally. Last time I checked, there's a fair amount of traffic in San diego.

Relying on lane position for safety, particularily when conspicious lane position is only a part time situation, is seriously a pile of steaming ludicrousness.

What, pray tell, does helemt head rely on when he isn't in a conspicuous lane position? the 'panache' of a black jacket he bought off a racer dude? head, you like to pretend you're a bicycle racer, dontchya? poseur!

maybe you should try a lime green fedora, head. motorists might see you better.
Are you running current gen, high powered, daytime visible front & back LEDS to increase your conspicuity regardless of your lane position? of COURSE you're not, you think lane position is your ace in the hole.

ah, fallacies of the armchair rider. good luck, head. you need it!



That's not just counter-intuitive, head- it's idiotic! because bicyclists are never consistently in a primary lane position - yet you postulate you rely on something you only posess part of the time on the roads. Isn't there traffic in San Diego?

blah blah blah.... Head, you skew my riding. I'm confident I 'take the lane' a lot more miles a week than you, head. I'm quite assertive in my bicycle positioning. I ride, daily, in left hand lanes of four lane roads and use inside lanes of four lanes at traffic signals. All lanes of multi lane arterials, all lane and road positions.

The most common reaction by motorists to a bicyclist as they approach an intersection, regardless of road position or assertiveness, is the averted eyes glance right thru the bicyclist.

do you see that, head? in plain english? or out on the road? Bicyclists, REGARDLESS OF ROAD POSITION, get overlooked. motorists look right thru us. of course, you don't think so. Newbie!

Again, good luck in your black jacket in traffic, hed. you'll need it!

Thanks for the tips, Beck.

Bekologist
11-13-07, 11:45 AM
why do you fallaciously insist you rely on conspicious primary lane positioning to be noticed, if primary lane positioning can only be used part of the time?

fallacies from the armchair....

dynaryder
11-13-07, 12:24 PM
You guys wouldn't have to worry about lane positioning if you stayed in the bike lanes. Or the sidewalk.

I'm just sayin'. :D

Helmet Head
11-13-07, 12:24 PM
why do you fallaciously insist you rely on conspicious primary lane positioning to be noticed, if primary lane positioning can only be used part of the time?

fallacies from the armchair....
Good question, Beck.

I don't rely on conspicuity when I'm riding in the margin. I assume that maybe about half the drivers notice me when I'm riding in the margin, whether it's demarcated as a bike lane or marked shoulder with a stripe or not, whether I'm wearing bright colors or not. When I'm being passed by a stream of motorists while I'm riding in a margin, I know what's keeping me alive is their tendency to track near the left edge of the lane, their tendency to follow each other, and dumb luck. Their ability to notice me plays a small factor in that, and I certainly don't rely on it.

That's why as soon as the last car passes by, I look back and move back to my primary position near the center of the lane, continuing to maintain rearward situational awareness, and tend to not move aside for the next driver approaching from behind until he or she indicates she has noticed me (by slowing down and/or adjusting laterally). Thus when I move to the secondary position, at least the first driver has noticed me and his track will be one of giving me space, which tends to set the trend for everyone following him.

invisiblehand
11-13-07, 01:07 PM
You guys wouldn't have to worry about lane positioning if you stayed in the bike lanes. Or the sidewalk.

I'm just sayin'. :D

Actually, lane positioning is quite important in many bike lanes.

Bekologist
11-13-07, 02:48 PM
head- so you DON'T think visibility of a bicyclist is important when a rider is in the secondary riding position? :roflmao:

what a piece of work. Do you even cycle in traffic, dude?

Helmet Head
11-13-07, 02:52 PM
head- so you DON'T think visibility of a bicyclist is important when a rider is in the secondary riding position? :roflmao:

That's not what I said, Beck. Learn to read.

Bekologist
11-13-07, 02:56 PM
sure seems quite in line with what you've been spewing in this thread on the last page, talking about your jacket and conspicious lane positioning. how primary lane position (which is only a part time riding position) is what gets you noticed in traffic, and then when you ride secondary it's not important. Or else you'd subscribe to visibility enhancing techniques many of us bonifide commuters subscribe to.

what lights are you running during the day again? ;)