Foo - Picard or Kirk?

Well I'm bored at work.


So who is the better Captian!


My vote is for Picard. Got to love him.

Definitely Picard!!!


Now the next question is who was the bigger ladies man?
Kirk or Riker? :D

My... Vote Goes... TOO... Captain KIRK. The only...man who was ... Born Too.. delivery a sentence...Like thIS one.

Morgan

Definitely Picard!!!


Now the next question is who was the bigger ladies man?
Kirk or Riker? :D

Kirk, Riker couldn't score with a bar fly within a hundred miles of Kirk.

Janeway!!!!!!!!!! :) I want my hair do do what hers does in a big fru fru bun :)

http://echosphere.net/star_trek_insp/insp_captkirk_preview.jpg

Janeway!!!!!!!!!! :) I want my hair do do what hers does in a big fru fru bun :)

She was definitely MORE OF A MAN than either Kirk or Picard. ;) :p

Picard. He's an INTJ (http://www.wischik.com/damon/Texts/myersbriggstrek.html#intj) like me.

Picard. He at least acted like a captain.

I'm amazed the Earth wasn't sanitized by some species after Kirk's One Man's PrimeDirectiveTM on the galaxy. To compare Kirk and Riker, is like comparing Gary Cooper and Don Knotts. Pickard for the Captain's Award. Kirk gets the Errol Flynn Swashbuckling The Universe Award. Now Scott Backula in Enterprise didn't do too badly, but he had a sexy Vulcan on staff to harass.

She was definitely MORE OF A MAN than either Kirk or Picard. ;) :p

hehe, it was definitely the voice, wasn't it? :p

Picard. He at least acted


Fixed that for you.

Oh please! Everyone knows Spock really ran the Enterprise!

If you're asking me who was more enjoyable to watch as the captain...Kirk all the way. But FWIT.....I enjoyed Picard, and Janeway and even Scott Bakula's version of a Starfleet captain.Kirk will always be my favorite though.

Scotty! Because when he had command of the Enterprise, the weapons were always warming up and you just knew they were going to fry some alien butt!

Anyone except Janeway! $%*&()#$(&(% Janeway! Leave it to a woman to continually mess with time. Hated those time travel episodes. HATED.

7 of 9 ran Janeway's ship. hmmmm 7/9

http://www.motleycrow.com/ImageHost/spock_fascinating2.jpg

http://img.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2007/05_02/pirateDM2505_468x456.jpg

^^^ most unpirate looking bloke to ever be called a captain!

http://cg.scs.carleton.ca/%7Emorin/misc/capn/header.gif

http://img259.imageshack.us/img259/7492/inspfightmusicnt9.png

I liked both.

Gotta go with Picard although I have love for Kirk because I've watched the original series since I was 3 yrs old.

Despite my reservations about Scott Bakula, I ended up liking Archer a lot. I should also add that I think Enterprise was a great series while DS9 and Voyager both stunk.

I thought DS9 was ok. Didn't watch voyager.

Captain Chekov in Star Trek V.

Picard outclasses most actors anywhere. He is the real thing. I have seen Shatner
'act' on stage. It was painful to watch. He is a ham, and if you think he's hamming it up on the small screen, he does the exact same schtick on stage.
Blecch.

No one has mentioned Avery Brooks. I give him second place. He's a decent actor.
One thing I learned from talking to Trekkies is that you need a pretty good actor who has some gravitas to pull it off. Picard set a very high standard. Scott Bakula
couldn't do it, and his series died because of him more than anything else.

Kate Mulgrew is a problem. She grew into the role over time, but many of the die hard trekkies never accepted her. I don't blame them. If she had come along later, the series would have died an early death just like Enterprise did.

But having said that, I Netflixed the entire series last winter, by and large, I enjoyed it. Netflix helps. No commercials, an episode a day, no summer reruns,
and the narrative plot doesn't get interrupted all the time. I think that helps for
a linear narrative like Voyager.

I thought DS9 was ok.DS9 was decent the first season....then something happened and I started not liking it as well. I couldn't quite put my finger on it...then one day I nailed the reason. It had turned in to a farkin soap opera (and I stopped watching).

Picard outclasses most actors anywhere. He is the real thing. I have seen Shatner
'act' on stage. It was painful to watch. He is a ham, and if you think he's hamming it up on the small screen, he does the exact same schtick on stage.
Blecch.




That is true. Patrick Stewart is an amazing theatre actor. He's done one man shows of the Cruicble and A chrismas Carol.

I always thought they should have developed a series around "section 31" that explored the darker side of the federation.

But I'm happy with how Battlestar Galactica turned out. :D

Kirk kicks ass! Come on! Like this is really a toughie! Kirk did not need a ships counselor and he sure as hell did not have Klingons on the bridge! Picard is a pansy! Janeway......pleaseeeeeeeee

Actually Captain Pike was the main main with the green broad!

All Star Treks variants are just lame Doctor Who "wannabes" anyway. :D

Kirk. like there's any question.

100 reasons (http://www.pathcom.com/~boby/kirk.htm)

i like number 46: Ever heard of a bar shooter called "Make it so?" No? How about a "Beam me up Scotty" then? See the difference?

All Star Treks variants are just lame Doctor Who "wannabes" anyway. :D

Wait a sec! What kind of enemies sound like someone talking into a high speed fan?:D

Picard all the way!
Like someone else said, he acted like a captain. TNG was generally very well written, and Picard's stuff even more so.

Archer just softened up the rest of the galaxy for those jokers.

All Star Treks variants are just lame Doctor Who "wannabes" anyway. :D

http://www.turboconnection.com/images/picard.jpg

Wait a sec! What kind of enemies sound like someone talking into a high speed fan?:D

Um.....about half of them (from either series). ;)

Picard. Acted like a captain and I got a thing for bald heads:).

Captain Sheridan on Babylon Five,

FTW.

Steven

WESLEY CRUSHER! Oh yeah. He could take Picard and Kirk in a fight.

Gotta go with Picard although I have love for Kirk because I've watched the original series since I was 3 yrs old.

Despite my reservations about Scott Bakula, I ended up liking Archer a lot. I should also add that I think Enterprise was a great series while DS9 and Voyager both stunk.

Voyager suck? I beg to differ

http://users.aol.com/alscherer/7of9.jpg

There's only one true Space Pimp who just laughs at your feeble Enterprise.

"Yeah, I shot first. What of it?"

http://www.criticalgamers.com/archives/pictures/HanSolo.jpg

Captain Sheridan on Babylon Five,

FTW.

Steven

My favorite B5 character was Londo. But the story was the centerpiece of the series. The characters all get moved along by it, some grow, some die. J'Kar
is one of my favorites because he learns so much and winds up being the Narn version of Thomas Jefferson.

I think I may watch it again this winter.

http://homepage.mac.com/awcg/.Pictures/Bike/Mirth/Chipcom1.jpg

WESLEY CRUSHER! Oh yeah. He could take Picard and Kirk in a fight.

FTW!!!!!

http://img90.imageshack.us/img90/4668/wesleyfi0.jpg

http://homepage.mac.com/awcg/.Pictures/Bike/Mirth/Chipcom1.jpg

Good work AG, you've elevated BF Pshop Innovation to a new low.

I have to say Picard, as at least he was trained to act and can.

Chipcom of BORG!!!! :):):):):)

Good work AG, you've elevated BF Pshop Innovation to a new low.

That's rough....no only are we at a new low....but apparently we had to be ELEVATED to get there. :rolleyes:

There hasnt been a real Trek since Kirk. :eek:

Could you see this Stewart posuer singing McArthur Park
or Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds ??

Shatner :beer: