PDA

View Full Version : Media Spin



randya
12-05-07, 11:24 PM
Cyclist Doored, Killed by Truck in Midtown
A truck driver opened his door into the path of a 63-year-old cyclist this morning, sending him into traffic, where he was run over by another truck. Though the cyclist, who has yet to be identified, was conscious immediately following the collision, he was later pronounced dead at Bellevue Hospital.

Here is the wire report:

FINAL UPDATE,RESP-4 REPORTS A CYCLIST TRAVELING NORTH BOUND 6 AVE BTWN 36 & 37 ST WERE A RED PICK UP TRUCK WAS PARKED BY THE HYDRANT WHEN THE PASSENGER OPENED THE DOOR AND STRUCK THE CYCLIST . THE CYCLIST WAS STRUCK BY A PASSING BOX TRUCK.THE CYCLIST WAS TAKEN TO BELLVUE HOSPITAL {DOA} ..SIGNS & MARKING IN GOOD WORKING ORDER..PER OP-26

And here is how it was reported in the Daily News. Note the number of steps taken, and not taken, by the cyclist to put himself in mortal danger -- starting with the headline.

Bicyclist killed after falling in front of truck

A 63-year-old man bicycling in midtown Manhattan Wednesday morning hit a car door and flipped into the street before he was run over and killed by a box truck, police said.

The man, whose identity wasn't immediately released, was not wearing a helmet, a police source said.

It's as if every action -- hitting the door, flipping into the street -- was initiated by the cyclist, who wasn't even wearing a helmet. The drivers of the vehicles, meanwhile, are never mentioned in the story. In fact, the article makes it seem as if there were no drivers.

The Ace Hardware truck that hit the man stayed at the scene.

Of course this isn't the first time we've seen this kind of victim-blaming, even in the News.

Here is the 1010 WINS account:

Police said Wednesday that the victim, a Manhattan resident whose name was not immediately made public, was riding northbound on Sixth Avenue near 36th Street when he encountered the open door of a parked vehicle. The impact caused him to land on the street, where he was struck by a passing truck.

In this version, the cyclist encountered the door of a parked vehicle, which he apparently decided to crash into. At least this article refers to him as a "victim."

And though it almost goes without saying:

There were no charges, cops said

http://www.streetsblog.org/2007/12/05/cyclist-doored-killed-by-truck-in-midtown/

ekitel
12-06-07, 02:33 AM
media spin has been a fact of life since before the printing press was invented, it's just gotten relatively worse lately in this country, they need to make cycling look dangerous, and cyclists look unreasonable, to keep people in their cars and taxis and increase demand for increasingly expensive petroleum

also the Daily News is not a real newspaper, and they'll admit it whenever they're charged with slander, who believes anything they read in the daily news?

ParkingMeter
12-07-07, 02:35 AM
The cyclist wasn't by chance riding in a bike lane? That would make the city largely responsible in my opinion for building a dangerous traffic control device ("door-zone" bike lane). That's not to say that whether a bike lane was there or not would have prevented this, but it's irresponsible for a city to encourage (or require by NY law) riding in a dangerous part of the road.

It's funny how they always mention whether a helmet was being worn. Like that would prevent you from being crushed under the wheels of a giant truck. That always seems to be a means of portraying the cyclist as "irresponsible" and thus partly responsible for their accident. It also bothers me that there's this false dilemma where its either the cyclist or the motorist to blame. Consider the engineering....

dydst
12-07-07, 03:51 AM
The Daily News is such a P.O.S. They take every opportunity they get to take the reactionary side of a story.

San Rensho
12-07-07, 11:27 AM
Maybe I'm paranoid, but I believe that the vast majority of people who do not ride bicycles, have a deep-seated hatred or dislike of bicyclists. These people believe that cyclists just should not be on the road and that they deserve anything that happens to them.

This mentality explains the drivers that pass me on the street, when I am obeying all traffic laws, and yell and screamed obscenities at me telling me to get off the road.

I don't think it's out of line to assume that most people to write these articles are not cyclists, and therefore their anti-cyclists bias will demonstrate itself in their articles.

How to change the tenor of most articles written about bicyclists? I think the only way he is to aggressively write letters to the editor whenever these articles appear.