Bicycle Mechanics - Snapped spoke

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




View Full Version : Snapped spoke


chevy42083
03-02-08, 08:10 AM
Bike: 1983 Bianchi Alloro. Possibly/probably original wheel set: Campy Record hubs, Mavic hoops. I know for a fact nothing has been changed in the last 4,300 miles. The bike sat for a long time before i got it in '99, so it's probable that it's all original. The hoops do not have any brake groove. There is a noticable seem under the Mavic sticker... not sure whether that is "seam" or "crack". I need to look into that.

Cliffs: Snapped a spoke mid sprint, possibly as I went over a bump, but bump didn't seem that bad. The wheel was pulled WAY out of true.
Options:
1: Replace one spoke, call it good.

2: Replace one spoke, and ride it while looking into upgrade to a new age set of wheels... Bike is slowly losing it's "dated" look anyways.

3: Respoke entire wheel, cause they will all start snapping now.

The long version:
Bike hasn't been looked at by a mechanic for over 2,500 miles (no trueing, nothing...just me lubing it). Just after a sprint at the end of a 63mile ride I look down to see a rear wheel that's WAY out of true, barely rideable, but finish the last 1 or 2 miles. Look it over, and the spoke had snapped midway through the curve at the hub end. I'm worried about snapping others earlier in other rides if I only replace this one spoke... I've never sagged, and don't want to ;) . I wouldn't mind a nice new set of wheels.... depending on what i could find clearance priced, versus what it would cost to overhaul the current wheels.

What should I look for as far as future spokes giving out? Would there be cracks in them now? I see some "seems" on the hoops... so I'm gonna clean them up, and basically give everything a look over now. Don't wanna replace spokes just to realize the hoops are near end of life.


San Rensho
03-02-08, 09:03 AM
Which spoke broke? If it was a non drive side, non pulling spoke, then its a sign that the spoke tension is too low on the wheel. I would replace the spoke and put some more tension in the wheel, then go out and sprint on it as hard as you can in a fairly small gear to see if it holds up.

chevy42083
03-02-08, 09:15 AM
Drive side, compression spoke? When the broken spoke is at the top of the wheel, it goes towards the "back" of the hub. Didn't think about giving that info.


Retro Grouch
03-02-08, 10:16 AM
25 year old wheelset. I'd go for option #2.

San Rensho
03-02-08, 02:30 PM
Drive side, compression spoke? When the broken spoke is at the top of the wheel, it goes towards the "back" of the hub. Didn't think about giving that info.

Thats a drive side pulling spoke, so its not an undertensioning problem. Sounds like fatigue that comes with age. I second reto-grouch's advice.

blamp28
03-03-08, 10:49 AM
Option 2 would be my choice as well. There is very little likelihood that option 1 will get you much time on the bike before you are right back in the same fix again. Option three will not save much over the cost of new wheels and you still end up with 20 year old rims and hubs.