Foo - For once some good news.

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




View Full Version : For once some good news.


Dannihilator
11-16-03, 10:41 AM
Taken from The Harrisburg Patriot News.

An 89-year-old woman who lost her home because of $572 in unpaid taxes will get it back from the man who bought the million-dollar property in a government auction for $15,000.

Helene Shue, who has lived on her 41-acre farm near Hershey, Pa., for five decades, had paid her taxes in full every year – including this one – but was short in her 2001 payment, the Harrisburg Patriot-News reported.

The buyer, Philip Dobson of Middle Paxton Township, Pa., informed Shue's nephew, John Arndt, he would give back the land after the story gained national attention.

Dobson, a business owner who invests in real estate, said, according to the paper, he "had no idea when I bought it that there was an 89-year-old widow living there. I found that out when I was reading the newspaper."

The decision to give it back, he said, "was a no-brainer, a moral issue, not a legal one. The property should be returned to her."

"I got something better than a million-dollar property," he told the Harrisburg daily. "I got a hug from a little old lady. That was worth more than anyone could imagine."

The county has agreed to reimburse Dobson.

Arndt and Dobson went to Shue's home together to give her the news.

"Oh, my God, I can't believe it," Shue said, hugging Dobson and her nephew. "I won't forget this day."

The land and home in South Hanover Township has apple, cherry and peach orchards along with beef cattle and pigs Shue named after family members, the paper reported. She is so fond of the property she once turned down a $1 million offer for it.

The county's tax bureau maintained it gave her all the proper notification before putting up the land for auction, including posting notices on her door.

But when Arndt learned of the sale, he filed a petition with Dauphin County Court to intervene. Officials then set up a meeting between Dobson and Arndt, who said he was "overwhelmed" when Dobson agreed to give the land back, according to the Patriot-News.

"Mr. Dobson is a fine, upstanding person," Arndt said, putting an arm around Dobson's shoulders. "When the land was sold, my aunt said, 'This could kill me.' Now, she has it back."

Arndt's attorney, Anthony McBeth, said the county tax-claim bureau does its best to follow the law, the paper reported. But he believes the law itself needs to allow for better screening so people such as Shue, who have a good track record of payments, "do not have all they worked for exposed to a sale."

Arndt said his aunt planned to pay the $572 tax bill yesterday.

"This had a happy ending," he told the Patriot-News. "I plan to help her more with her mail and bills after this so nothing falls between the cracks."

This definately warms the heart.


Maelstrom
11-16-03, 10:45 AM
Thats is awesome. Such a good storey. I can't believe one missed tax session (overpayment, underpayment, whatever) could justify loosing a home :O

RegularGuy
11-16-03, 11:38 AM
Nice! Thanks for sharing.


jester69
11-17-03, 08:03 AM
It seems like a heartwarming story, but maybe it really isn't.

In some states (well, Missouri is this way anyway) the way the law works is that if you buy a property at forclosure the person forclosed upon has a year or so to get the money together and pay their tax liability, once they do so they get their property back from you. Any improvements you have done since you bought it they don't owe you for.

So, my guess is he knew he had to give it back anyway, so rather than fight it and waste money, he saw an opportunity to get some publicity & make everyone think he's a nice guy.

Its possible that if the law was different, he might have taken a different tack.

take care,

Jester

JCM800
11-17-03, 08:40 AM
So, my guess is he knew he had to give it back anyway, so rather than fight it and waste money, he saw an opportunity to get some publicity & make everyone think he's a nice guy.

It would sure make someone look good if they were planning on getting into local politics.

Regards.

Sandra
11-19-03, 05:49 AM
I'm just glad she got her property back!

LittleBigMan
11-20-03, 09:05 AM
Taken from The Harrisburg Patriot News.

[i]An 89-year-old woman who lost her home because of $572 in unpaid taxes will get it back from the man who bought the million-dollar property in a government auction for $15,000.

This definately warms the heart.
Yes, it does.

I wonder how many elderly people aren't so fortunate when beloved Mr. Tax American decides $572 in unpaid taxes is worth stealing an elderly person's
lifetime homestead. Certainly, the government wouldn't blink at spending that much on a few political dinners. Besides that, any idiot could find a creative way to sell a small corner of her property to come up with a half a grand, considering the land was worth a million dollars. Really, does anybody these days have any heart at all (or brains?)