Advocacy & Safety - Rural Cycling Safety?

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.
CosmicRay
05-19-08, 11:31 AM
Hi everyone,
I live in a rural area and am thinking of bicycling to work, which is 9.6 miles away. I have done quite a bit of googling for rural bicycle safety, and have really had little luck. If you think that rural cycling involves roads that always have paint or pavement on them, think again :)
Here's my situation: Out of the 9.6 mile commute, a minimum of 2 miles will occur on sand/dirt/gravel roads, and a minimum of 1 mile occurs within the city limits (which I am not at all concerned about).
The remainder could be on sand/dirt/gravel roads, or on paved roads, or some combination. The paved roads in question would include up to 2 miles on a 2-lane state highway (speed limit 65MPH, narrow paved shoulders, wide grass shoulders), and the remainder on a paved county road. The 2-lane county road has no shoulders whatsoever -- white stripe, 1 inch, then about a 3" drop onto grass. It also is somewhat hilly. Speed limit is 55MPH but I have frequently seen people going at least 80MPH there. Both roads are fairly well-traveled.
The country roads are 2-lane in name only. In practice, if you are meeting another car on one of those roads, you're both slowing down to 30MPH or slower and putting your right tire off the maintained area. On the other hand, I only meet another car on the unpaved roads once or twice a month. People occasionally get killed on these roads because other cars are so rare that people don't look out for them. They certainly aren't expecting a bicycle.
Cyclists are not common on any of these roads. Drivers are not really expecting to see them. I see cyclists maybe an average of once a month there, and I drive those roads every day.
So, first question: what roads are safest for me to take? The country roads certainly have fewer people traveling on them, but they're probably less likely to be alert for a bicycle. Also, I often have to ride down the middle or even the left of the road, because there are large piles of sand, gravel, or whatnot where I'd normally ride. (Cars do this too) Sometimes getting over to the right so a car can pass involves me stopping and walking the bike through the thick sand.
There are some visibility problems on all of the roads, mainly due to hills.
It is considerably easier and faster for me to take the paved roads as opposed to the country roads. Pavement is much easier to ride through than is sand or gravel (though if I can find the unmaintained dirt roads, those tend to be pretty smooth). I got passed by probably 3 cars on the country roads, and maybe 15-25 on the paved county roads.
Next question: what sort of safety accessories should I have? (Besides the obvious helmet). I'm thinking a mirror would be great. What do people suggest -- eyeglass or helmet mirror? Would I be able to tell if a driver is not going to pass with sufficient time to react? What should I do to make myself as visible as possible? I have seen some cyclists with tall flags attached to their bikes -- I imagine that they create some drag though, and the bike shop I went to didn't recommend them. Over at http://bicycling.about.com/od/howtoride/tp/Essential-Bike-Commuter-Gear-.htm, there is a suggestion for a reflective vest, but I don't see those readily available online or locally. The local bike shop also suggested strobe lights or reflective tape. Any thoughts?
Finally, I am really a newbie at this. I have a Mongoose Crossway 250 (a hybrid) that I bought back in 2000 when I lived in Indianapolis. I only used it on dedicated trails (the Monon rail-to-trails), so this will be the first time I'll be riding on roadways. Any other suggestions would be great.
Thanks!
Bekologist
05-19-08, 11:42 AM
mirror, high vis to the rear, daytime visible tailight like a Planet Bike Superflash, add a flag, add a safety triangle, wear a ANSI class II or III safety vest with contrasting orange and high vis yellow, and increase your awareness of traffic overtaking and consider it to road and traffic oncoming, and you'll be a lot safer.
Safety flags are commonly used by cyclotourists, etc. Any shop that DOESN'T recommend a safety flag for rural riding like you described does not have your best interests in mind, nor a whit of sense regarding safety riding enhancements.
Do you mind me asking what the bike shop employees DID recommend?
Here's my safety setup for winter riding and rural tours. I ride plenty of roads like you describe, just not on my commute. My avatar is a photo of me riding a gravel country road, middle of the road.
Safety triangle is on a spoke ziptied to the rear rack. It doesn't interfere with panniers going on or off.
CosmicRay
05-19-08, 11:59 AM
What's a good online store to find these things? The bit I didn't mention is that the nearest bike shops are 40 miles away, so I like to go online as much as I can.
Anyhow... I went to one local bike shop, described my conditions as I did above, and asked an open-ended "what kind of safety gear would you recommend?" They suggested a safety triangle, a tail light, and reflective tape (I think they suggested putting it on my helmet, but I'm not positive).
I will never be riding at night or in the rain. (Can't ride in the rain because that means my first 2 miles will be in partial mud; it's hard enough to get a car over that). That Superflash -- you mention it's daytime-visible -- I take it that means it's *significantly* daytime-visible?
None of the online bike shops seem to sell those safety vests. Does anyone make jerseys/shirts with that sort of high-visibility material? (I haven't seen them either) That way I would have the extra weight and drag of a separate vest, but obviously I'll take the extra drag over the extra danger.
Thanks much for the tips.
gcottay
05-19-08, 12:04 PM
Hello, Ray.
One thing I've noticed on rural roads is that unless you are very fast or riding into a strong headwind, your ears are your best friend. You can hear traffic coming for long enough to be alert and, depending on the location, take appropriate action for your own safety.
I believe that very few motorists anywhere have any expectation of encountering a cyclist. Cyclists who ride in a legal and predictable fashion, are usually pretty visible. I don't think that most of the safety stuff works well during the daylight hours. I have been on tours where people used them and I nearly always saw the cyclist long before I saw the little flag. Fanny patches do help a bit though.
I used to ride quite a bit on rural roads in Michigan. Slow moving and hideously large farm machinery on the roads kept the motorists a bit on their toes so that was a good thing.
noisebeam
05-19-08, 12:18 PM
The country roads are 2-lane in name only. In practice, if you are meeting another car on one of those roads, you're both slowing down to 30MPH or slower and putting your right tire off the maintained area. On the other hand, I only meet another car on the unpaved roads once or twice a month. People occasionally get killed on these roads because other cars are so rare that people don't look out for them. They certainly aren't expecting a bicycle.
In addition to tips from Bek I think this is a case where I would use a high intensity steady beam headlight 24hr/day aimed parallel to ground.
Al
Elkhound
05-19-08, 12:19 PM
Does your area have a lot of yahoos who would think it funny to throw beer bottles at cyclists from their pickup trucks?
CosmicRay
05-19-08, 12:46 PM
Elkhound: heh, that's one danger I never thought of. But no, I don't think so.
And Pat, I can totally identify with the hideously large farm machinery.
robertlinthicum
05-19-08, 12:53 PM
Hello, Ray.
One thing I've noticed on rural roads is that unless you are very fast or riding into a strong headwind, your ears are your best friend. You can hear traffic coming for long enough to be alert and, depending on the location, take appropriate action for your own safety. I'm not connecting--how is hearing traffic approaching from the rear suppose to help him? What's he to do, swerve his way out of danger?
Another red herring is the almighty rear-view mirror. In my opinion, it does nothing to make your ride safer. Turn your entire head and LOOK before making a move across a lane. Don't rely on a mirror. Or your hearing. Feh.
noisebeam
05-19-08, 01:06 PM
Another red herring is the almighty rear-view mirror. In my opinion, it does nothing to make your ride safer. Turn your entire head and LOOK before making a move across a lane. Don't rely on a mirror. Or your hearing. Feh.
No one in this thread is suggesting to merge without turning head. A mirror lets one monitor faster rear approaching traffic and the drivers reaction (or lack of) to ones presence. Alternately one can turn ones head a few times a minute which is far more disruptive to the smoothness of cycling on an open rural road.
Al
littlewaywelt
05-19-08, 01:08 PM
Since driver's may close the gap on you very quickly at rural road speed, I think you need to concentrate on daytime visibility.
At minimum on roads like that I'd want (rearward facing) a superflash on my helmet, one on the bike and a cateye LD1100 on the bike, along with an ANSI II fluorescent lime vest. Frontward facing I'd want a real headlight not some whimpy led.
After seven years of commuting without one, I added a rear view mirror. It took me about a month to get used to it, but I do believe it helped my overall situational awareness, I firmly believe it increases safety.
I shop mostly at
www.pricepoint.com
www.bikenashbar.com
www.performancebike.com
robertlinthicum
05-19-08, 01:46 PM
A mirror lets one monitor faster rear approaching traffic and the drivers reaction (or lack of) to ones presence. I turn my head if I'm to make a move in traffic--it's not hard. For me, mirrors are worthless distractions. I don't trust them, and mirrors can't make eye contact with motorists.
Do tell how this new commuter is helped by the advice that he " . . . monitor faster rear approaching traffic and the drivers reaction (or lack of) to ones presence . . ." He is riding in a rural setting. My sense is that overtaking traffic will be moving at a high rate of speed. This is useless (and perhaps unintentionally harmful) advice for him, sorry.
This new commuter needs to focus on
1) Being seen;
2) Seeing;
3) Developing skills that help him/her do 1 and 2.
robertlinthicum
05-19-08, 01:50 PM
Since driver's may close the gap on you very quickly at rural road speed, I think you need to concentrate on daytime visibility. Amen!
noisebeam
05-19-08, 02:02 PM
I turn my head if I'm to make a move in traffic--it's not hard. For me, mirrors are worthless distractions. I don't trust them, and mirrors can't make eye contact with motorists.
Apparently you didn't read my post. Who is talking about 'making moves in traffic'?
Do tell how this new commuter is helped by the advice that he " . . . monitor faster rear approaching traffic and the drivers reaction (or lack of) to ones presence . . ." He is riding in a rural setting. My sense is that overtaking traffic will be moving at a high rate of speed. This is useless (and perhaps unintentionally harmful) advice for him, sorry.
This new commuter needs to focus on
1) Being seen;
2) Seeing;
3) Developing skills that help him/her do 1 and 2.
A rural setting with fast approaching traffic is exactly the conditions where a mirror helps situational awareness - that is because with faster traffic one needs to monitor the rear more often and all it takes is a glance in the mirror a few times a minute. I know in such conditions (low volume fast traffic) the 'hassle vs. actually seeing something' of turning head means I monitor the rear much less. Do you really turn head and look behind you a few times a minute when on such a road?
But I do agree if the OP is new to cycling or cycling in traffic they need to first learn to look back with head when ever required and not primarily rely on a mirror which could (depending on individual mindset) inhibit learning this important skill.
Al
aRoudy1
05-19-08, 02:50 PM
You can order a safety vest here: http://www.forestry-suppliers.com/drilldown_pages/view_category.asp?cat=1111
I have a lime green mesh one and it seems to work ok--haven't been hit yet! :lol:
CosmicRay
05-19-08, 03:18 PM
Thanks everyone for the tips. Interesting discussion on mirrors. I'm glad I brought it up :)
My concern isn't merging across lanes; all of these roads are only 2-lane so there is no lane changing going on.
If I'm riding on sand roads, my bike -- and the wind -- makes enough noise that I may not hear vehicles approaching very early (especially if there is a headwind). Looking over my shoulder several times per mile will work fine some places, but not necessarily when it's hilly. Often times, on these sand roads, I found it takes quite some concentration to keep my bike out of the thick sandy areas left behind by road maintainers or cars, which could cause me to crash or suffer a lack of traction. Sometimes I've got about 6 inches to work with. I want to avoid looking over my shoulder to see if a car is coming, then promptly wipe out right before it arrives because I wasn't watching the road in front of me! Also, on those roads, there will often simply be no possible way for a vehicle -- whether approaching from the front or behind -- to get around me unless I move over.
Several of you suggested a forward-facing headlight of some sort. I'm curious about that. I don't feel particularly concerned about oncoming traffic. I figure I will see the cars before they see me, and I ought to be able to pull over in time, whether encountering a single vehicle on a sand road or someone passing a car on a paved road. Am I being over-confident somehow?
The other thing I'm quite interested in is thoughts on riding on the sand roads vs. the 2-lane paved road. The sand roads are slower traveling, but have far less traffic. On the other hand, there are some risks there -- like piles of sand, dirt, etc. -- that could cause more than a minor accident if I hit them right when there is a vehicle passing. What do you think -- is it safe to ride on a 2-lane paved road with some hills, no shoulders, and (automobile) commuters and semis? How far to the right should I be riding there? On my test ride (a Sunday afternoon, so less traffic than I'd normally see), I rode pretty much on the white line the whole time, and only one driver passed me uncomfortably close.
The other thing I'm quite interested in is thoughts on riding on the sand roads vs. the 2-lane paved road. The sand roads are slower traveling, but have far less traffic. On the other hand, there are some risks there -- like piles of sand, dirt, etc. -- that could cause more than a minor accident if I hit them right when there is a vehicle passing. What do you think -- is it safe to ride on a 2-lane paved road with some hills, no shoulders, and (automobile) commuters and semis? How far to the right should I be riding there? On my test ride (a Sunday afternoon, so less traffic than I'd normally see), I rode pretty much on the white line the whole time, and only one driver passed me uncomfortably close.
I'm not as experienced as some on this list in these conditions, but these are my impressions. 2 lane paved roads with high speeds/low traffic/unpaved shoulders are not so bad, as long as you can see what is happening (mirror is good), and you can control an escape to shoulder when, say logging trucks are passing each other at your location. That is: if the 'shoulder' is a cliff face of hard granite, or 1000 ft drop, it's probably a bad idea (especially if cars go suicidally fast). But if the frequency of traffic is low, and the hills are such that you can see and hear oncoming and passing traffic reasonably well, you should have a pleasant ride.
Other factors to consider are dogs, wildlife, and weather conditions. It might not be so much fun if it is frequently foggy and rainy, due to reduced visibility and traction.
FWIW I would probably try the paved road for a while and see how comfortable I felt. Riding in sand is a lot of work.
If you ride at the same time every day, the drivers will likely get used to you, and look out for you as they go by (I'm guessing that these roads are mostly used by locals).
Good luck.
robertlinthicum
05-19-08, 05:42 PM
Apparently you didn't read my post.
You aren't getting it--my point is that monitoring what is going on behind you, UNLESS you are about to "make moves in traffic", is a distraction and waste of time, and you are recommending just that to a new commuter, who has stated that lane changes aren't on the menu.
But you will persist, so who buys it, eats it.
Nothing necessarily wrong with it, but I can imagine that yours is the school of thought that advises that one must be able to "hear real good" so that one can hear motorists trying to "warn" us with their horns.
Thus endeth my participation (and interest) in this thread. Happy and safe riding to all, especially the OP. (Best course for you is to read the latest edition of Effective Cycling . . .)
JusticeZero
05-19-08, 06:01 PM
High-vis vest - absolutely positively utterly mandatory. If you have to chose between a high vis vest or a helmet, chose the bare head every time.
You can get them from Harbour Freight or whatever, if your sporting goods type place doesn't have them, ask to order some. Get the yellow ones with reflectivity material (Not the 'melted glitter' kind). Here's a link to one: http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/Displayitem.taf?itemnumber=94701
Mirror - I've tried a helmet mirror, I couldn't see a damned thing through it. Ever see one of those puzzles where they take a picture of something, then make you try to identify it by looking at some little fragment of a booger of something in an obscure portion? That's what a helmet mirror is like, except that if you guess wrong or take too long figuring it out, you wreck. Don't do it. Get a bar end mirror, a big one. Convex if you can find one. You need this mostly so you can check to see if someone is coming up on you easier, for lane positioning reasons. Just glance at it if you think you might need to take a little more lane to avoid a hazard, or if passing width seems to be getting sketchy.
Lights - the best you can find. Dinottes or similar, probably.
Then chose roads so that you have high visibility front and rear.
I-Like-To-Bike
05-19-08, 06:15 PM
You aren't getting it--my point is that monitoring what is going on behind you, UNLESS you are about to "make moves in traffic", is a distraction and waste of time, and you are recommending just that to a new commuter, who has stated that lane changes aren't on the menu.
But you will persist, so who buys it, eats it.
Nothing necessarily wrong with it, but I can imagine that yours is the school of thought that advises that one must be able to "hear real good" so that one can hear motorists trying to "warn" us with their horns.
Thus endeth my participation (and interest) in this thread. Happy and safe riding to all, especially the OP. (Best course for you is to read the latest edition of Effective Cycling . . .)
I should have guessed that the Read the Book mantra was imminent from this poster after his references to off the wall head turns and merging into lanes ranting . Good Bye!
On the OP's road with few cars coming the best bet for his peace of mind just may be too pull off the road when the occasional car approaches unless there is a clear indication that the driver will give the OP sufficient room. The mirror and listening can be very helpful tools without any great effort for being aware of those few approaching vehicles.
www.Alertshirt.com for very visible, inexpensive apparel for suitable for the OP's needs.
I agree with Bekologist's skepticism about a bike shop that would pooh-pooh the use of a visibility flag for this purpose. I suppose it doesn't fit the Tour de France image, or there isn't sufficient markup on it. Maybe the LBS will promote them when the pole is made of carbon fiber.
CommuterRun
05-19-08, 07:03 PM
Be obvious.
Be predictable.
Be assertive.
A mirror is helpful to monitor the road behind and much easier than turning your head every few seconds. I like a big, handlebar mounted mirror like the Blackburn Multi Mirror or Blackburn road mirror, depending on which bike I am on. With other vehicles traveling at highway speeds, you will want to know as early as possible if there is a vehicle approaching from the rear. If you have the sight lines, you will be able to see another vehicle approaching long before you will be able to hear it. And at the speed most people drive rural highways, they can be up to you very quickly. Also, the noise of a vehicle approaching from the front will mask the sound of a vehicle approaching from the rear. You don't want to get caught by surprise this way.
One of the reasons I don't wear a helmet all the time anymore is that the wind noise in my old helmet sounded like a car approaching from the rear. So wearing that helmet, I constantly had the sound of a ghost car approaching.
Would I be able to tell if a driver is not going to pass with sufficient time to react?
In my experience, usually not if they are traveling highway speed. The exception to this is the drivers that change lanes way early.
I don't use a safety flag either, but I do wear a shirt that greatly contrasts with most of the background, usually woods, as would be seen by an observer looking at me. I like white, yellow, bright green and bright orange for this. Normally, in warm weather, I wear a white, cotton undershirt.
Active lights are a plus even if you don't plan to ride at night nor in the rain. At night I run 3 taillights; a Cateye TL-LD1000 with one bank of lights steady on, the other bank on rapid flash; a Cateye TL-LD500 steady on as a backup to the 1000 and because it is a CPSC certified reflector, which is required by FL state law in addition to a light; and a Mars 3.0 clipped on the back of my helmet, steady on.
For headlights I run a Cateye HL-EL530 mounted on the handlebar and a Optronics Nightblaster 6000 mounted on my helmet.
On overcast or rainy days I run both banks of the TL-LD1000 on rapid flash, and the HL-EL530.
I have found that the darker the road (the less ambient light from sources other than your own), the less light you really need to see or be seen. In the absence of street lights, stores, houses, etc. any light you generate will stand out like a beacon.
On sand roads in this area I have found that usually only the packed tire tracks are ridable. This typically requires me to pull over and stop for every vehicle approaching from either direction. But it is what it is. Usually these sand roads are so narrow that there is no way for a motor vehicle to get past me if I remain in a ridable road position. This is why I use paved highways as much as possible. Of course some of them just don't go to some of my desired destinations.
Several of you suggested a forward-facing headlight of some sort. I'm curious about that. I don't feel particularly concerned about oncoming traffic. I figure I will see the cars before they see me, and I ought to be able to pull over in time, whether encountering a single vehicle on a sand road or someone passing a car on a paved road. Am I being over-confident somehow?
Not to bust on you, but I think so. It has been my experience that the biggest hazard you will face is not traffic approaching from the rear, as long as you are in a lane controlling and highly obvious lane position, but traffic approaching from the front when one driver decides to pass another as they are approaching you. You want to make it plainly obvious to approaching drivers that they cannot pass until they are past you. For me this means taking the middle of the lane in the presence of oncoming traffic.
Although some of it may sound counterintuitive, the information found here: http://www.bikexprt.com/streetsmarts/
is excellent. Particularly Chapter 2.
If you are going to use the ROAD get a ROAD BIKE. If your are going to use the country roads get a hard tail.. Since this is rual could you get away with crossing a field or wood? Shorten the distance AND aviod all cars?
bkrownd
05-19-08, 08:21 PM
A mirror is a must-have item. I much prefer my glasses-mounted mirror, but my specific brand isn't made anymore. You should always be aware of the vehicles around you as much as possible. You can't watch them constantly, but when you do see a vehicle on your tail who obviously isn't going to pass you safely then you can take evasive action and ride off the side of the road. Failing to watch them is asking to get rear-ended - there are plenty of drivers out there who wouldn't notice a bike if it was in the middle of the lane, covered with flags, and lit up like an xmas tree.
bkrownd
05-19-08, 08:29 PM
Mirror - I've tried a helmet mirror, I couldn't see a damned thing through it. Ever see one of those puzzles where they take a picture of something, then make you try to identify it by looking at some little fragment of a booger of something in an obscure portion? That's what a helmet mirror is like, except that if you guess wrong or take too long figuring it out, you wreck. Don't do it.
My glasses mirror took me about a week to get used to. After that, adjusting focus and head position for it was an instant reflex. It provides a clearer, more detailed, more stable and wider angle view than a handlebar mirror. Of course, some people's eyes might not work well with them. I also have a convex handlebar mirror for those times when I can't lift my head to use the glasses mirror due to rain, but the handlebar mirror gives a far lower quality view, and requires me to take my eyes off the road ahead for longer.
mandovoodoo
05-19-08, 08:35 PM
Think about training. Need that emergency escape all the time. Eventually some yahoo will start a pass into oncoming traffic and you'll need the escape to be there already, rather than having to figure it out. Learn your route so you know where to go. The no escape neck down areas bother me. I make sure to pace myself so I can't hear anyone close as I go through the danger zones.
On visibility, I keep thinking panniers with rain covers in yellow would be great. Haven't gotten around to it!
I got an illuminite vest at Performance cheap that is way visible. I also got closeouts on a bright green vest, a bright green jacket, and a bright illuminite green helmet cover for winter use.
I should have a triangle etc. I have lights. But today I rode home in civies with a baseball cap and a single flasher, some green tape on my fenders. Everyone passed me perhaps better than usual - maybe the helmet gets you passed closer as has been hypothesized.
The passing into traffic thing is the most dangerous aspect on the fast roads. People really will risk their lives to save 4 seconds. It's stupid, but you'll see it. Helps to practice big "WAIT" hand motion and big "WAVE AROUND" motions, as if you're dealing with idiots. Most people aren't, but enough are.
I'd also study other posts and train your mind for what to do at stops and other situations. You'll have the guy pulling up to the stop in the left lane as you're at the stop. I attract attention and inform the fellow that I've seen cops ticket that move for reckless driving, big fine, and indicate cyclists will be out of the way in a second. That way they're appreciative, rather than pissed.
Make friends, too. You'll see the same people. Wave to everyone. Raise a hand to the cars. Do the hand out and down to the bikers. Say high to the people by the road. Stop and help everyone.
On the route - hey, I just don't ride where I'm scared. I'll ride anywhere else and vary my route.
noisebeam
05-19-08, 08:40 PM
(Best course for you is to read the latest edition of Effective Cycling . . .)
I believe I recall reading that JF has changed his position on cycling mirror usage since he wrote EC. My memory could be faulty.
Al
JusticeZero
05-19-08, 08:51 PM
I wore the damn helmet mirror for three months because I kept figuring that i'd eventually get the hang of it. It never got any less annoying and useless. It still had some microscopic amount of utility, and I didn't have any bars to mount a bar end mirror to, so I didn't bother removing it. To the last, it was not helpful.
CosmicRay
05-20-08, 07:12 AM
If you are going to use the ROAD get a ROAD BIKE. If your are going to use the country roads get a hard tail.. Since this is rual could you get away with crossing a field or wood? Shorten the distance AND aviod all cars?
I will be using both country roads and paved roads. I have a minimum of 2 miles on unpaved roads and 1 mile on paved roads, and the remaining 7 miles are up to me. I've got a hybrid now, so it seems my cheapest option is to keep it for the moment.
There are fields, but there is no way to ride a bike across them. The ground is tilled, making it too soft. Plus, there are crops there. Nothing like 3-foot-high wheat or 6-foot-high corn to impede a bicycle.
My old commute http://maps.google.com/maps?f=d&hl=en&geocode=4835296094620759125,44.558240,-75.318840&saddr=canton,+ny&daddr=44.565523,-75.275917+to:McAdoo+Rd+%4044.558240,+-75.318840&mra=dpe&mrcr=0&mrsp=1&sz=12&via=1&sll=44.5579,-75.24404&sspn=0.156075,0.248222&ie=UTF8&ll=44.563077,-75.242958&spn=0.156061,0.360832&t=h&z=12
For the most part it was along a barely maintained two lane country road. No markings, no shoulders. Road was so potholed and broken up that holding a decent line was impossible. The beginning of the commute was along a state highway with broad shoulders. The last couple miles to the plant were a somewhat better two-laner, center markings but no shoulders. Some areas were alligatored pretty goo and required moving my line.
For the most part the rides were uneventful. I rode year round, including when it snowed. Visibility was the key. I'd always run blinkies on my bags and bike. Coworkers often commented that they could see them from a great enough distance to know I was there.
Another factor to consider is that most people you pass on the commute are doing the same thing. In time they'll come to expect seeing you which helps quite a bit.
I'd see maybe a half dozen cars on this route.
nagsheadlocal
05-20-08, 09:24 AM
I ride a rural route to work, but not as varied as yours. I chose my route to avoid the high-speed narrow roads that result when a town expands and formerly rural areas become ex-urbs and country lanes become highways. That increased my ride by a couple miles but it's worth it to me for the peace of mind. I mention this because the section you mention as being narrow, no shoulder, and full of speeding cars. That's the only thing that scares me about your route. The rest of the route could be handled easily by a cyclo-cross or similar bike with appropriate tires.
If there are no alternative routes have you thought about inter-modal cycling? That's a fancy way of saying mixed-use - like driving a car to a bus terminal and taking the bus to work. I have a colleague who would have to drive a couple miles on a really terrible road (narrow, crowded, full of yuppies trying to text while their SUV wanders over the road) if he cycled the entire route. He puts his bike on his car, drives to a park-and-ride lot, and cycles the rest of the way to work. It still saves him a ton of gas as he avoids the stop-and-go traffic of town. Plus he skips paying for the parking garage in town.
I wear a bright-orange vest made of nylon I paid $2 for in the hunting section of WalMart. Also serves as a wind-break vest on cool mornings. I have Cat-Eye blinkie lights on front and rear. My helmet is a reflective white helmet - and if I could find this model in orange or lime green, I'd get that. I can't use a mirror because my eyes just won't focus on one (I'm in my mid-50s) so I've grown a rubber neck from turning it constantly.
I also wave and nod to the people I see daily. They do get used to you and sometimes in the summer when windows are down, I speak to people at stoplights. You'll become part of their daily routine and they will watch out for you.
gcottay
05-20-08, 09:33 AM
I'm not connecting--how is hearing traffic approaching from the rear suppose to help him? What's he to do, swerve his way out of danger? . . . .
Thanks for asking.
I think most of the time, hearing approaching traffic out in the country is just a reminder to pay attention and be predictable.
Some rural roads, otherwise great for riding, also have areas of horrid visibility. One particular road I enjoy is heavily wooded, has some tight curves that drivers take too fast, a series of abrupt grade changes creating blind spots, and little traffic. It's in those spots, under conditions where you hear the car or truck long before they can me, that I will ease onto the sand and gravel shoulder.
jfmckenna
05-20-08, 09:57 AM
Thanks for asking.
I think most of the time, hearing approaching traffic out in the country is just a reminder to pay attention and be predictable.
Some rural roads, otherwise great for riding, also have areas of horrid visibility. One particular road I enjoy is heavily wooded, has some tight curves that drivers take too fast, a series of abrupt grade changes creating blind spots, and little traffic. It's in those spots, under conditions where you hear the car or truck long before they can me, that I will ease onto the sand and gravel shoulder.
I agree with the hearing though I tend to do the opposite. When I hear a car approaching I take the whole lane. In a corner I will ride out more toward the centre so that I come into the drivers increased line of site. Then I can hear the car slow down. If I don't hear it slow I at least have the option of dodging right. But usually you hear the car slow. Now you are in control and when the car is right on you just kindly move over or even stop, sometimes when I see the corner clear I'll wave the driver on.. That's the law in my state, slower vehicles pull over when safe to do so. The reason why I try to control the traffic like that is because if you are 2 inches on the edge of the pavement in a corner (or straight way) then you are giving the driver the split second opportunity to pass you and if there is on coming traffic I'm quite sure the driver would chose to hit you rather then a car head on.
I ride rural roads like the OP's every single day and this technique was intuitive to me and seems to work out fine. Oh and another thing. If you are going to commute every day then chances are the traffic you encounter will also be commuting at the same time so they will get used to you. Get out there and make a presence and wave a friendly wave to every car you encounter.
You mentioned a strobe in your original post; since no one has suggested it I will suggest an electronic xenon stobe such as discussed in several threads LINK (http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=350681&highlight=strobe), LINK2 (http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=360061&highlight=strobe) , LINK3 (http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=159010&highlight=strobe), and LINK4 (http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php?t=271891&highlight=strobe).
I believe these will show up at a distance much better during daylight hours than a good LED such as the Planet Bike Superflash.
Source for one per the threads is LINK (http://www.northerntool.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/product_6970_200199974_200199974) which had thread comments such as "I've received several positive comments from motorists about how visible it is.", "33 watts of rear light might even make you visible by aircraft looking for a place to land!", and "I just installed mine (from Allelectronics) last weekend and this past week, cars went all the way into the next lane (not typical before) to pass me on my dark morning commute...I like it!" .
There are quite a few good suggestions in this thread and I think you will need to use many of them to stay safe in the situation you describe.
The Human Car
05-20-08, 10:57 AM
On route selection I would contact whoever conducted the nearest bike to work day event and see if they have a suggestion.
CosmicRay
05-20-08, 11:30 AM
I also wave and nod to the people I see daily. They do get used to you and sometimes in the summer when windows are down, I speak to people at stoplights. You'll become part of their daily routine and they will watch out for you.
OK, this is probably a stupid question, but... if you're going, say, 20MPH, and a driver passes courteously at 60MPH all the way in the left lane, what is a time where you can wave at the person where they'll see it?
While we're at it, what's the "do not pass" signal that people have mentioned? I'm sure that as a driver, I've seen it from a cyclist and understood it, but I just can't remember what it was.
nagsheadlocal
05-20-08, 12:33 PM
OK, this is probably a stupid question, but... if you're going, say, 20MPH, and a driver passes courteously at 60MPH all the way in the left lane, what is a time where you can wave at the person where they'll see it?
Well, I got the idea from Dave Moulton's blog: http://davesbikeblog.blogspot.com/
The road I use doesn't have any place you can do 60MPH - the fastest stretch is 45MPH and is pretty heavily patrolled due to school busses. I just usually lift my right hand and casually point at the driver. Here in the South, that generally means "You the man, thanks" or similar. Sometimes I give the thumb's-up sign. That's pretty universal. This morning a person pulling out of a driveway waited until I was past - I gave them the thumb's-up and mouthed "thanks" as I went by. The woman driver smiled and waved back.
While we're at it, what's the "do not pass" signal that people have mentioned? I'm sure that as a driver, I've seen it from a cyclist and understood it, but I just can't remember what it was.
I was cresting a hill not long ago and two deer were standing in the road. A guy in a car was coming up behind and I was positive he could not see the deer. I held out my left hand, palm back, at about a 45-degree downward angle. I could hear his brakes as slowed down. The deer were just clearing the road as he came over the hill. As he went around me he waved in the mirror. I guess he appreciated me saving him a few thousand dollars in damages.
Being a cyclist is like being a tourist overseas - you are an ambassador of sorts. If we want drivers to take us seriously, we need to start acting like adults. Or, as I taught both my children, the golden rule of human interaction is "Don't be a d1ck."
I don't want to hijack but I am also looking for pointers on rural roads. If I commute in the
winter it will be dark when I leave for work/get home... I can use lots of lights/reflective
stuff to make me more visible. But when it turns cold and people are too lazy to properly
defrost/scape window they drive looking through a tiny porthole...:winter2:
It might be just safer for me to toss the bike in the truck and drive part way to work?
nagsheadlocal
05-27-08, 05:57 AM
It might be just safer for me to toss the bike in the truck and drive part way to work?
Inter-modal transport. That's what I do when the weather is really bad for the same reason. I drive to a park-and-ride and cycle the rest of the way in. That way you skip the stop-and-go of city driving (where you get the worst gas mileage and the most wear on your patience) and you also skip the most dangerous part of your cycling route. I'm lucky to have a park-and-ride, but if you have a large parking lot along your route (mall, shopping center, etc) you may be able to take advantage of that.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.12 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.