Bicycle Mechanics - Why no cage bolt in high-end front derailleur?

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




Mondoman
08-02-08, 06:15 PM
In looking at some high-end front derailleurs (e.g. Shimano XTR), I noticed that their cages didn't have a bolt closure, but rather what seems to be a rivet. For example, take a look at this one: http://www.rscycle.com/site/image_browser/xtr_fd_m970_08_lg.jpg
Why is that? Is it just that the derailleur is so wonderful that it would be sacrilegious to open its cage to install/remove a chain, and the chain must be opened instead?


overturn
08-02-08, 06:21 PM
erm...yes. that's what a chain tool is for.

DannoXYZ
08-02-08, 06:23 PM
You don't want to open the FD cage. You end up bending it and causing alignment issues which results in very poor shifting. It takes less time to push out the pin in a chain anyway.


Mondoman
08-02-08, 06:47 PM
OK, so the *extremely* low end FD's I've seen have a rivet, but mid-range FD's have a bolt. What's the deal with the latter?
(for example, this Deore LX: http://www.benscycle.net/index.php?main_page=popup_image&pID=5032&zenid=40119508d3d3377d3943b9cc0f46bd43 )

DannoXYZ
08-02-08, 06:54 PM
Aside from market-category of the designs, you also have to take in to account the age of the design and cost-of-manufacturing concerns. Sure, low-end designs use rivets to lower costs and increase production-speed. Shimano probably recognized that in their newest designs and use rivets in the XTR. The DeoreLX model you posted is at least 10-years old and it's probably more economical to continue using that design than to start a new one using rivets. But you can bet that when a new DeoreLX model is introduced, it's probably going to have rivets.

Are you familiar with a diagonal calendar spread?

Mondoman
08-02-08, 09:22 PM
Sorry, I'm not familiar with a butterfly spread, but I'm guessing it doesn't refer to my unscrewing an FD bolt causing a Shimano executive's roof to fall in Japan...

Sounds like you're saying that the rivets are used for different reasons on low- and high-end -- low-end because it's cheap and high-end because it's secure. The (now-fading?) use of bolts on mid-range FDs reflects an older era when people were expecting to be able to open their FD's, but we frown on that now.

HillRider
08-02-08, 09:38 PM
The (now-fading?) use of bolts on mid-range FDs reflects an older era when people were expecting to be able to open their FD's, but we frown on that now.
In the older era of friction shifting, minor distortion of the fd cage was no big deal since you could adjust it's position anywhere you wanted. Index shifting systems are far less tolearant of fd cage configuration so bending it to pop the chain in and out can have a negative effect on shifting.

jsmithepa
08-02-08, 09:50 PM
Why? are u anticipating repeat removal of the FD?

z415
08-02-08, 10:29 PM
I feel like I stumbled upon a trading floor dominated by bike enthusiasts.

Deanster04
08-03-08, 12:06 AM
You don't want to open the FD cage. You end up bending it and causing alignment issues which results in very poor shifting. It takes less time to push out the pin in a chain anyway.
Well said...!

Mondoman
08-03-08, 12:08 AM
Thanks, HR -- makes sense.

ivan_yulaev
08-03-08, 02:28 AM
Get a master link. Way easier than pushing pins or bending FD cages...

graeme
08-03-08, 03:46 AM
Wouldn't you have to open the chain to get it through the rear stays?

Albert '55
08-03-08, 05:48 AM
Wouldn't you have to open the chain to get it through the rear stays?Yes.
By removing the screw that holds some FD cage together you can slip out the chain which then allows you to lie the bike down, move most of the chain out past the dropout. The chain can be cleaned in a flat tray using degreaser.
You only spread the cage just enough to slip the chain out or you could possibly distort it as others have said.