Clydesdales/Athenas (200+ lb / 91+ kg) - Wheel build question

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.
Nimitz87
09-06-08, 06:31 PM
I'm a clyde but barely...ususally hover around 200-210 range, im 6'5.
Looking at possibly having a set of wheels built compared to buying some.
looking for semi aero, aluminum clinchers.
was looking at the Neuvation's, Easton SL70's or Soul 4.0's.
or possibly building a custom wheel set
using
Kinlin/Niobium 30mm rims
DT hubs
what spokes/nipples?
spoke count? 20/24 or 24/28?
wheel's will be used for everything including crits.
Chad
Tom Stormcrowe
09-06-08, 09:06 PM
Frankly, I'd go with the Deep V from Velocity. A hair heavy, but definitely improved aerodynamics from being a deep section rim, and strong as the breath of a man that lives on exclusively garlic and coffee that smokes cheap Russian tobacco. ;)
DT Swiss or Alpine spokes, in stainless steel, and brass nipples/
Duff Man
09-07-08, 09:14 PM
I recently had two new wheel sets built. One set with dt 240's, cx-rays and deep-v's and the other with dt 240's, 14g dt's and pro elites(tubular version of the deep v's).
With what you want, I would go dt 240's, dt spokes 32/32, and the niobium(assuming them make them in 32 hole).
While they might be a little heavier with the extra spokes and a little less aero I think they will hold up better and the difference won't be that much. For comparison, I went from dt 240's, dt butted spokes and Mavic Reflex tubulars to my current wheels. There is a slight difference in the responsiveness, but I feel like I put the power down much better now, the bike definitely rides better and I just like these wheel sets infinitely more.
Nimitz87
09-07-08, 09:19 PM
I recently had two new wheel sets built. One set with dt 240's, cx-rays and deep-v's and the other with dt 240's, 14g dt's and pro elites(tubular version of the deep v's).
With what you want, I would go dt 240's, dt spokes 32/32, and the niobium(assuming them make them in 32 hole).
While they might be a little heavier with the extra spokes and a little less aero I think they will hold up better and the difference won't be that much. For comparison, I went from dt 240's, dt butted spokes and Mavic Reflex tubulars to my current wheels. There is a slight difference in the responsiveness, but I feel like I put the power down much better now, the bike definitely rides better and I just like these wheel sets infinitely more.
what did the deep v's end up weighing? and how many spokes?
would it be better to build a set of deep v's with less spokes than the kinlin/niobium with 32?
still also looking at the Soul 3.0's as well....
Chad
Duff Man
09-07-08, 09:51 PM
I don't really know enough about this subject to be able to give you a firm answer. I didn't weigh my wheels, I was more concerned with durability and these are much more durable than my reflex's were.
I have 32/32 on both of my wheel sets and I'll never change that. If I were looking to cut some weight I would cut the rim weight and go with the Niobium 30's and then go to a higher grade lighter spoke like the cx-rays. If I wanted to loose more weight I would cut tire and tube weight and then hub weight. The last place I would cut weight is in the spoke count. I have played with lower spoke count wheels, but they just don't work out for me.
Now you are a bit lighter than I am, I'm 250lbs and 6'5". If I was 40 to 50lbs lighter I would be tempted to play with spoke counts, and I would start at 28/28.
At 200# you have a wide range of possibilities. What kind of riding do you do? Long distance? Race? Potholes? Smooth surfaces? Deep V's are probably the strongest but you don't always need a sledge hammer for a nail. Mavic Aksiums are strong and light though I wouldn't recommend them for over 250# and rough roads. Can also pick up a set at Nashbar or Performance and have a wheelbuilder hand tension them.
Nimitz87
09-08-08, 07:49 PM
At 200# you have a wide range of possibilities. What kind of riding do you do? Long distance? Race? Potholes? Smooth surfaces? Deep V's are probably the strongest but you don't always need a sledge hammer for a nail. Mavic Aksiums are strong and light though I wouldn't recommend them for over 250# and rough roads. Can also pick up a set at Nashbar or Performance and have a wheelbuilder hand tension them.
club rides, starting to get into distance rides, most surfaces are pretty smooth, just alot of debris such as glass, etc. lots of flats.
looking for a 30mm rim at a decent weight.
the niobium's with 24/28 and DT240 hubs, CX-rays would weigh in just under 1500g if I did the math right.
the soul 3.0's are only 80 grams from that and ALOT cheaper.
Chad
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.12 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.