DogBoy
01-02-09, 09:19 AM
I have an xtra-cycle, and I'd like to add an electric assist (stokemonkey) to it. I'm also inclined to upgrade the drivetrain from the 7-speed derailleur system, but mostly because I want to have a disc wheel in back rather than the v-brakes. I have a feeling that a rear disc would be better than rear v-brakes if I'm going to be adding some juice.
So my options, including pros/cons:
Leave drivetrain as is.
Pro: least expense, it works, has decent gear range
Cons: not sure about braking with extra speed/load. I've had no issues to date, but????
Get a 8/9 speed disc hub, a spacer, and keep the 7-speed.
Pro: Next least expensive, gets me disc brakes
Cons: I've had trouble with these spacers before, I'm concerned about not getting tension right with add'l torque load.
Upgrade to a 9 speed derailleur system
Pro: no more fiddling with spacers
Con: have to buy new shifter as well (derailleur is modern XT, so wouldn't need that), any thoughts on the durability of a 9-spd chain with the extra torque load from e-assist?
Go IGH (Alphine 8, SRAM 9, Nuvinci, Rohloff is too $$$)
Note: there's a whole discussion on this already, so rather than splitting out WHICH IGH, just consider any of them, and defer the pro/cons of particular IGHs to the other threads.
Pro: chainline, simplicity, durability
Con: Cost, I have less experience dealing with IGH systems
Right now I'm kind of leaning towards the IGH route with either the Nuvinci or Alphine hub, but I have no idea why. I'm thinking my best bet is to go with the 9 speed upgrade, and maybe even get buy on the friction shift setting on the 7-spd xt thumb shifters. I bet it would cover most of the gear range. Anyway, I'd like input from those of you who have more experience with these things. First, should I even worry about disc brakes vs v-brakes in the rear? I guess if the answer to that is no, I have no reason to consider the others questions.
Any advice out there on this?
So my options, including pros/cons:
Leave drivetrain as is.
Pro: least expense, it works, has decent gear range
Cons: not sure about braking with extra speed/load. I've had no issues to date, but????
Get a 8/9 speed disc hub, a spacer, and keep the 7-speed.
Pro: Next least expensive, gets me disc brakes
Cons: I've had trouble with these spacers before, I'm concerned about not getting tension right with add'l torque load.
Upgrade to a 9 speed derailleur system
Pro: no more fiddling with spacers
Con: have to buy new shifter as well (derailleur is modern XT, so wouldn't need that), any thoughts on the durability of a 9-spd chain with the extra torque load from e-assist?
Go IGH (Alphine 8, SRAM 9, Nuvinci, Rohloff is too $$$)
Note: there's a whole discussion on this already, so rather than splitting out WHICH IGH, just consider any of them, and defer the pro/cons of particular IGHs to the other threads.
Pro: chainline, simplicity, durability
Con: Cost, I have less experience dealing with IGH systems
Right now I'm kind of leaning towards the IGH route with either the Nuvinci or Alphine hub, but I have no idea why. I'm thinking my best bet is to go with the 9 speed upgrade, and maybe even get buy on the friction shift setting on the 7-spd xt thumb shifters. I bet it would cover most of the gear range. Anyway, I'd like input from those of you who have more experience with these things. First, should I even worry about disc brakes vs v-brakes in the rear? I guess if the answer to that is no, I have no reason to consider the others questions.
Any advice out there on this?
Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.