Road Cycling - Switched from triple to double.. *Update*

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




BlueDevil
05-15-04, 01:48 PM
First off, to anyone out there considering this switch.. DO IT!! :) I couldn't be more pleased!

I was a bit worried to switch from a triple to a double, as there are a few steep (13-16% grade) hills around here, and thought I would struggle getting up them (and my normal routes usually take me up at least one of these hills!). Well, I went out the first day, on very flat ride, with the new 39-52 front, and a 13-25 cogset in the back. It is AMAZING the jump in quality when moving from Tiagra in the front to Dura Ace! At one point, I thought something was wrong.. I was cruising along at about 22mph, pushing away at those pedals, and something just didnt seem right.. I couldn't place what it was.. then it hit me- SILENCE.. all I could hear was the wind, and the tires on the pavement.. no clicking/sound from the gears.. I also found that over 18mph or so, there was much less drag with the Shimano 7701 wheels over my Ksyrium Elites. My average speed increased about 3/4 of a mile per hour on the flats, with this new combo (keeping my heart rate the same as it was before, on a day with no wind).

So today was the true test. The new gears felt great, but how would they work when I attack the hills. I wont lie- I had to work a little harder not having that granny gear, but every one of the big/steep hills I hit, were do-able with the 39-25 (in fact, on a couple hills that had killed me in the past, I was able to push up in the 39-23). I was debating between the 12-27 and a 12-25, but this just sealed the deal- I'll go with the 12-25 (seeing as I climbed the hardest two hills in the area with the 25, no problem..).

So, now it is time to switch out the shifters and front derailuer.. btw: I had heard in the past that you had to switch up a bunch to move from a 3 to a 2... my stock Tiagra front deraiuler, and shifters worked just fine on a 2 ring DA crankset.. all I had to switch out for this test was the BB and crankset. It just took a little adjusting, and everything worked fine.


boyRacer
05-15-04, 03:13 PM
First off, to anyone out there considering this switch.. DO IT!! :) I couldn't be more pleased!

I was a bit worried to switch from a triple to a double, as there are a few steep (13-16% grade) hills around here, and thought I would struggle getting up them (and my normal routes usually take me up at least one of these hills!). Well, I went out the first day, on very flat ride, with the new 39-52 front, and a 13-25 cogset in the back. It is AMAZING the jump in quality when moving from Tiagra in the front to Dura Ace! At one point, I thought something was wrong.. I was cruising along at about 22mph, pushing away at those pedals, and something just didnt seem right.. I couldn't place what it was.. then it hit me- SILENCE.. all I could hear was the wind, and the tires on the pavement.. no clicking/sound from the gears.. I also found that over 18mph or so, there was much less drag with the Shimano 7701 wheels over my Ksyrium Elites. My average speed increased about 3/4 of a mile per hour on the flats, with this new combo (keeping my heart rate the same as it was before, on a day with no wind).

So today was the true test. The new gears felt great, but how would they work when I attack the hills. I wont lie- I had to work a little harder not having that granny gear, but every one of the big/steep hills I hit, were do-able with the 39-25 (in fact, on a couple hills that had killed me in the past, I was able to push up in the 39-23). I was debating between the 12-27 and a 12-25, but this just sealed the deal- I'll go with the 12-25 (seeing as I climbed the hardest two hills in the area with the 25, no problem..).

So, now it is time to switch out the shifters and front derailuer.. btw: I had heard in the past that you had to switch up a bunch to move from a 3 to a 2... my stock Tiagra front deraiuler, and shifters worked just fine on a 2 ring DA crankset.. all I had to switch out for this test was the BB and crankset. It just took a little adjusting, and everything worked fine.

Tiagra with Dura ace... :D Glad you like the change. :)

But personally I think its all in your head. ;)

Poor1
05-15-04, 03:24 PM
I can see that happening. I have a double up front as well. I can always climb hills better then the other people that go with me and they have triples. I think it is that they become too dependent on having that really low gear. Of course, if I get up into these mountains around here where the REALLY steep roads are, I might have a problem, but only one way to find out.


BlueDevil
05-15-04, 03:27 PM
Tiagra with Dura ace... :D Glad you like the change. :)

But personally I think its all in your head. ;)

:D Only temporarily (the Tiagra and Dura Ace that is..). We just decided to put the front DA crankset on, to see if I could survive the hills with a double.. On Monday or Tuesday, we'll be upgrading the rest (DA Front Der., and ultegra everything else..).

It probably is in my head.. but if I can use my head to pedal 3/4 of a mph faster, on the same course, with the same heartrate, then so be it!! :D (Or maybe its the more aerodynamic wheels.. heard that can make a pretty big difference.. dont think it is the components making that big of a diff.)

Pat
05-16-04, 03:35 AM
I can see that happening. I have a double up front as well. I can always climb hills better then the other people that go with me and they have triples. I think it is that they become too dependent on having that really low gear. Of course, if I get up into these mountains around here where the REALLY steep roads are, I might have a problem, but only one way to find out.

It might be that stronger riders tend to choose doubles and weaker riders tend to choose triples. Very few strong riders choose triples unless they love to climb at high RPMs.