Recumbent - Marathon Supremes Less Than Perfect

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




rsbeach
05-08-09, 08:13 PM
I don't want to start another tire thread, but I thought I'd tell you guys about my experience with Schwalbe Marathon Supremes. I recently added 42-559 Supremes to my RANS SXP, replacing Stelvios, which had replaced the OE tires, 1" Primo Racers, after a few unexplained flats.

The Supremes were rated 5 bars for speed, grip, puncture resistance and four bars for durability. I found them to have a terrific grip and they gave the SXPX a cushy ride, but they were distinctly slower (2 mph or so) than the Stelvios, which are given four bars for speed. I would definitely rate the Supremes at three bars for speed, given the relative performance.

I have gone back to Primo with 1.25" Kevlar belted Racers, which have me zooming along again. I may add a 1.5" Racer to the back in the future for touring. I'll probably keep the Supremes for off-road trips (at $60 a pop, I can't afford not to use them).


megaman
05-08-09, 09:02 PM
Yeah, I've generally taken those Schwalbe ratings bars with a grain of salt. To me they seem to give high ratings for the newer tires, even though the old tires were better.

BlazingPedals
05-08-09, 09:55 PM
It's hard to beat the 1.25" primo racers for speed and cushy ride. Puncture resistance? OK, two out of three ain't bad! It's not like they attract flats or anything, but they *are* racing tires and they don't have a lot of rubber on them. Marathons are probably better for durability.


oddball
05-10-09, 09:29 AM
Schwalbe does state somewhere on the website that those ratings are only to be used to compare tires of similar category. So you aren't supposed to use them to compare a touring tire (any Marathon) with a race tire (Stelvio, Durano, Kojack)
i am a big fan of Primo's also. Good price, good performance. Durability, good enough. I change to heavy duty flat resistant tires in the winter. Changing a flat on a sunny day is an annoyance. Doing it in 40 degrees and rain sucks!

rsbeach
07-13-09, 09:00 PM
To follow up my original complaint, I have to report that I took the Stratus with Marathon Supremes on a 4 day camping tour and they worked great. I had two tube flats, but they were not the fault of the tires - seam holes that may have been caused by inflating a 1" tube to fit a 1.6" tire. Schwalbe is on my good list again.