Living Car Free - Car Free Cyclists in Haiti

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




View Full Version : Car Free Cyclists in Haiti


cerewa
06-11-09, 05:17 PM
Let me start with a couple thoughts on car free bicycling in Haiti. Almost all Haitians are car free in the sense that they do not own or operate a car for non-business purposes, but the car free bicyclist has become something of an anomaly, at least in the area I stayed in this past month in Haiti (near Darbonne and Leogane).

Bicycles in Haiti are mostly leftovers from the United States, it appears - bicycles originally sold at Wal-Mart or another big box store, (brands like huffy, mongoose, etc; parts that are clearly of the quality level you expect at cheap walmart bikes).

It's really cheap to have an experienced bike mechanic fix your bike in Haiti. And by Haitian standards ve bikes and parts at the quality level of your typical USA Local-Bike-Shop type bike are extremely expensive. So it makes economic sense to use the lower quality brand bikes there. The heavy wheels and tires of these cheap offroad bikes are actually pretty well suited to the poor quality unpaved roads that are found throughout the country. Speed tends not to be a priority (people who want to go fast shell out the cash for a motorcycle if they can afford it) so the heavy and fairly durable frames are certainly acceptable. On rural roads at slow speeds, brakes are a luxury rather than a necessity, which is lucky because keeping those lame low end side pull caliper brakes working at all is hard, and keeping them working well is pretty much impossible. It appeared to me that most of the bikes there had derailer shifting that actually worked (at least sort of, you might have to kick the derailer!) but I never saw anybody shift gears. A couple people had removed the derailers and shortened the chain to go singlespeed. (I'd be kind of inclined to go that route to save on maintenance.)

For safety, if I were biking in Haiti I would much prefer to have a front brake with good stopping power, but if I couldn't afford working brakes I'd just do like everybody else, and ride carefully at speeds no higher than 7mph.

In the area where I stayed, something like 1 in 2000 people had a private motor vehicle. Probably 1 in 500 owned a motor vehicle that was used as a privately owned "bus" (these are actually usually small pickup trucks that are slightly modified, so that they can carry up to 16 people crammed in the back plus 4 in the cab). Something like 2% of the population owns motorcycles, and most of those are used as moto-taxis, squishing up to 5 people on to a fairly small motorcycle at one time. Motor transportation is common for all but the poorest people in that area, but it's in these forms that are extremely low cost by first-world standards and use very little fuel per-passenger-mile. And yes, the vehicles use don't have any of the expensive eco-technology that's seen on modern vehicles in developed countries, so they're not nearly as environmentally benign as we'd like them to be. Given the economic circumstances, blaming Haitians is probably not going to do any good but I'm sure there are a lot of possibilities for helping the situation if we want to. Anybody interested?


gwd
06-12-09, 07:14 AM
I'd expect bikes with coaster brakes would be better for their conditions. It reads like those people who collect junk bikes in the US for shipping to third world countries have been dumping them in Haiti. Maybe there are some unintended consequences going on?

Platy
06-12-09, 08:47 AM
What do people do there when their bike tires wear out? Also, do they have enough tire pumps?


cerewa
06-12-09, 03:51 PM
I know that when motorcycle tires wear out, people replace them with brand new ones that are packaged in plastic. I suspect bike tires are also purchased brand new.

I saw at least one hand powered bike tire pump. In addition, bike tires can be pumped anywhere motorcycle and automobile tires are pumped up. There's no shortage of small businesses that'll fill your tires. They'll probably charge you 5 gourdes (12 cents) or thereabouts for the service.

Roody
06-13-09, 11:32 PM
What do you think Haitians will be using for transport in 10 or 20 years? Probably more scooters and motorcycles? How much does gas cost there?

Would it make sense for development agencies to encourage/foster a homegrown bicycle manufacturing industry? I think that Trek and Bicycling Magazine have tried to do this in an African country.

Robert Foster
06-14-09, 12:20 AM
I don’t know just how to put this without sounding callous but a home grown Bike industry in Haiti doesn’t seem real practical. Haiti’s main economic growth comes from foreign aid. I don’t know how they are surviving this last economic downturn but I don’t know how the people would be able to afford a local bike industry. If the major economy is based on foreign aid then the people aren’t likely going to be able to buy even an entry level top notch bike. While labor may be exceptionally low in Haiti the raw material will still be a consideration.

I wonder just what can be done.

Roody
06-14-09, 12:40 AM
I don’t know just how to put this without sounding callous but a home grown Bike industry in Haiti doesn’t seem real practical. Haiti’s main economic growth comes from foreign aid. I don’t know how they are surviving this last economic downturn but I don’t know how the people would be able to afford a local bike industry. If the major economy is based on foreign aid then the people aren’t likely going to be able to buy even an entry level top notch bike. While labor may be exceptionally low in Haiti the raw material will still be a consideration.

I wonder just what can be done.

You're probably right. But if some people can afford scooters and motorcycles, there might be some who can afford bicycles, if good ones were available at a reasonable price. It might be better if there were bikes actually being made in Haiti--providing employment and economic development as well as transportation--rather than only having castoff bikes from American and European thrift stores.

Maybe bicycles aren't the best answer for Haiti, but it seems that they need capital and business expertise almost as much as they need food aid.

cerewa
06-14-09, 01:38 PM
You're probably right. But if some people can afford scooters and motorcycles, there might be some who can afford bicycles, if good ones were available at a reasonable price. It might be better if there were bikes actually being made in Haiti--providing employment and economic development as well as transportation--rather than only having castoff bikes from American and European thrift stores.

Maybe bicycles aren't the best answer for Haiti, but it seems that they need capital and business expertise almost as much as they need food aid.

Absolutely. The solution to Haitian economic dependence on foreign gifts is not to look for more foreign gifts - it's to look for economically feasible ways to have Haiti produce for its own market (or, possibly, for export).

The trouble, I think, is that a low end bike frame is worth very little in Haiti, just like in the USA. A working bike costs $80 (one of those used wal-mart clunkers) but the frame alone only represents a fraction of that. Components require a lot of precision and are hard to manufacture. I think focusing on Haitian-based enterprises in the realm of solar stoves (http://www.google.com/search?q=solar+stove) and agriculture (http://haiti-hope.blogspot.com/2009/06/personal-mission-around-food.html) is probably a better idea.