Road Cycling - Need some Road Bike buying advice (steel vs aluminum)

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




freeball12
08-07-04, 02:23 PM
I live in New York City and have recently been doing a lot of biking on my Gary Fisher mountainbike. I'm starting to do close to 30 miles when i ride, and have realized I need a road bike. Im pretty athletic (5' 7", 140 lbs) and find I always ride in the top few gears. I am planning on doing a century in a month.

I'm looking to spend around 1000-1200 for a bike, and have looked at a Cannondale R600, Trek 1500, Bianchi Eros, Specialized Allez Elite, and Allez Elite Cro-Mo. I really liked the ride of the Allez Cro-Mo and even thought it is a little more expensive, I find that most of the streets in New York are bad, and the steel frame really helps to make it smooth. This has me leaning toward steel, but I am also concerned that if I decide to get into racing or even just group rides, the weight of the steel is going to hurt my performance. Finally , I rode a Specialized Allez Comp (aluminum compact frame with a carbon seatpost) and found this to be closer to the feel of steel, without the weight (but at a greater cost).

Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


Markedoc
08-07-04, 03:10 PM
Ahh, the frame weight wars ... cracks me up how much people worry about a few grams or ounces of weight - especially the ones (like me!) who could lose a few pounds around the waist.

The steel will be fine and I don't think you'll notice a difference is speed. If anything the comfort should work to your advantage on long rides. You'll be fine on group rides too. I'm guessing that if you really get into racing, you might do that on your next bike - what you are looking at is pretty entry level.

Flaneur
08-07-04, 03:17 PM
you are kinda answering your own questions........

when you think you've tried enough bikes in the price range you are happy with, buy the one you like best, not the one you think 'might be best', for some other reason.
Comfort is every bit as important as weight when racing; can't ride too far if you can't sit down, for example!

A lot of the weight weenies never rode a race in their lives.........


Addicted2cyclin
08-07-04, 04:39 PM
Just buy the heavier one and get fast on it, then in the future get a light one so you will be a bullet

orguasch
08-07-04, 04:44 PM
Just buy the heavier one and get fast on it, then in the future get a light one so you will be a bullet
that's another way of doing it

jukt
08-07-04, 05:16 PM
I find that most of the streets in New York are bad,

Get the heavier bike.