Southern California - Newport Beach Hit-n-run ends in tragedy

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.
idoru2005
12-10-09, 03:28 PM
http://www.ocregister.com/news/police-223221-beach-vehicle.html?pic=1
Hi,
Very sad. I don't ride that stretch of road very often (a few times a year) but I never thought of it as being dangerous -- especially in that area as it is very wide. Hope that Mr. Murphy pulls through this tragedy well.
idoru2005
12-11-09, 08:34 AM
Yeah, very sad. If you read the comments under that article, you'll see that apparently Mr. Murphy did not make it, someone mentioned that he was taken off life support later that evening. I ride that stretch of road sometimes (southbound side). I think that the width of our roads in general give motorists a false sense that they have a wide margin of error. That because there is a bike lane, that they don't have to pay as much attention to the road because they can drift for a few feet before hitting the curb. The reality is that the presence of cyclists makes their margin of error much smaller than they realize. What we need is a movement to get municipalities to turn the white line that denotes the bike lane (in some areas) to a raised curb - especially on roads like this where the difference in speed between bikes and cyclists is HUGE. I don't fully believe in separated bike paths and trails because I'm a bike commuter. Orange County has plenty of trails, but they don't lead me from home to work.
Anyway, back to Mr. Murhpy, there is talk about a ghost bike memorial. I really hope that happens.
Rick@OCRR
12-11-09, 08:59 AM
Here are the details from one of the cyclists in the group:
The last two days have included some of the saddest moments I have experienced and I thought I might share some of them.
I struck out on the usual Wednesday morning bicycle ride yesterday (11/9) with my friends, Pete Fildes and Don Murphy. Being experienced riders, we were each decked out in warm clothes and bright reflective orange or yellow jackets and, of course, bright lights in front and flashing lights at our backs (we would be back before daybreak).
After our turnaround point Don and I were just about to the top of the biggest climb on the route (Pete had cut short and was waiting at the top for us) with Don about 100 or so yards behind me. Just as I reached Pete we heard a loud thump behind us. At that instant I did not process the sound as catastrophic, thinking that one of the very few cars out at that hour (5:50 AM) must have run over something in the road. Then we saw a dark SUV speed past us (45 or 50 mph, normal for that stretch) and Pete and I remarked that whatever the SUV had run over must have gotten stuck under it since we could hear a scraping sound and then saw sparks under the car and commented that there must be some metal in whatever was being dragged.
Then Pete suggested “Could that have been Don?!” We both turned and saw Don lying in the road against the curb about 60 yards back. We raced to Don and, even though there was no visible trauma (just a little blood from his nose), he looked to be in terrible shape: no pulse, no breathing. I dialed 911 and gave my phone to Pete to summon the paramedics while I started CPR on Don.
When Pete had finished the call, he started to try to flag down a passing car (with surprisingly poor results). After many unsuccessful attempts, we got someone to stop and a woman told me she was “familiar with CPR, but that it had been a long time." I showed her how/when to do the chest compressions as I continued the breathing for Don and after a minute or two she told me that she thought she felt a heartbeat (elation!). She monitored the heartbeat and I continued the breathing until the paramedics showed up (between 5 and 10 minutes from the call). As they took over, they took Don’s blood pressure: 110/86 (more good news).
While they worked on Don, I called my wife, Carol and told her the terrible news and asked her to call Don’s wife (a friend of Carol’s). She called and went over to drive Heather, Don’s wife, to the hospital. After they transported Don, I stayed at the accident scene to do the best I could with the police. I noticed that the police were paying special attention to an area far down the road from where we found Don. When I walked down to see what they were looking at it became apparent that Don had been struck far down the road from where we found him. I paced off the distance: 55 yards.
The police told us that they had located the hit-and-run vehicle parked behind a restaurant a mile and a half down the road from us and were questioning the driver. Pete and I rode our bikes to the restaurant. It was a sickening ride. Pieces of Don’s bike were strewn the entire mile and a half. When we got to the restaurant we saw the SUV and the police asked us if it was consistent with the one we saw drive past and, of course, it was. When we got a closer view (they wouldn’t let us into the parking lot – crime scene tape) we saw the smashed windshield and crumpled hood and parts of Don’s bike were still protruding from the front of the car. The police were talking to a Hispanic woman whom they identified as the driver (but they wouldn’t let me talk to her – probably wise of them).
Pete and I opted for the bike trail to ride home and Carol called me in route to say that Don had been taken into the ER and Don’s youngest daughter, Chandler, had already gotten to the hospital. She recognized one of the paramedics (they had been lifeguards together) who said to Chandler that he was so sorry her dad was in such bad shape. Carol also told me that Don’s older daughter, Madison, was stranded at UCLA without a car, but they were going to wait to see what developed before making arrangements to get her there. I protested and told them to find a way to get Madison to the hospital a.s.a.p. As soon as I disconnected from Carol, my phone rang again and it was another riding friend, Helen, who said that she had just learned of the accident (Madison had tested Helen’s son about it). Helen asked if I could think of anything she could do. There are no coincidences. I told her about the need to get Madison back to Orange County and had her call Carol to coordinate that while I rode home to change clothes and get to the hospital.
In a crisis, activity is almost a blessing; you do what needs to be done with a sense of urgency, but without having to reflect. At the hospital, waiting was almost unbearable. Family and some friends had gathered around the ER while the tests were run on Don. Then the doctors ushered those who were there into a small lounge and delivered the grim news. Don had suffered two fatal injuries: serious damage to the lining of his brain and a broken neck (between C1 and C2). They said there was no operation that could be done, no brain activity, nothing that would change over time (and no hope). I will not forget Chandler’s anguished cry when the words sank in. Either grief or numbness washed over those in the room. Carol had to step out. There were a few questions, but nothing more could really be said.
Madison and Helen arrived from UCLA and the wound was reopened as the finality of the situation was shared with them. In ones and twos, we stopped by the room where Don was connected to the life support systems and begged him to come back. Chandler’s paramedic friend phoned her to tell her he had talked to Don in the ambulance the whole way urging him to hang on. Over the next hour the sadness deepened.
I understand that today was the day they were to disconnect life support and do the organ donor thing, but we have let the family grieve by themselves.
This has been one of the saddest episodes I have experienced. But I am just a spectator. Don and his family have had so much taken from them. Every time I think of them rekindles that sadness.
Don was such a good man with a wonderful family. While his loss may felt more acutely by Heather, Chandler, Madison and his immediate family, there is a huge group of people in this community who feel a great sense of loss and we are all pooer now.
Godspeed Mr. Murphy.
My condolences to his family, friends and loved ones.
A very sad day for all cyclists in Southern California.
bigtempo
12-11-09, 11:48 AM
So sad.
grrlyrida
12-11-09, 12:11 PM
My condolences to his family and friends. Thanks for the narrative, Rick. It was very poignant and extremely sad. Thanks for sharing it with us.
alicestrong
12-11-09, 12:26 PM
Thank you, Rick.
Rick@OCRR
12-11-09, 01:44 PM
My condolences to his family and friends. Thanks for the narrative, Rick. It was very poignant and extremely sad. Thanks for sharing it with us.
Yes, I got that in an email from David, a friend of mine, a guy I've ridden with on several doubles. I didn't know Don Murphy, however. I thought that David's report would clear up a lot of questions that the newspaper article left unanswered.
Rick / OCRR
That's really terrible news.
RIP Don Murphy. All of us SoCal riders mourn your passing.
CbadRider
12-11-09, 08:36 PM
How very sad. I feel for his family.
His family members are better than I........
http://www.ocregister.com/news/family-223891-murphy-john.html
Jaguar27
12-13-09, 01:50 AM
Thanks for posting that Rick, I really don't know what to say...it was a terrible tragedy, may His Family find the strength to cope with this...
Garfield Cat
12-13-09, 07:12 AM
Thanks for posting that Rick, I really don't know what to say...it was a terrible tragedy, may His Family find the strength to cope with this...
When the family plans the funeral, let us know if its going to be public. That will be our expression of support. If the family wants us to donate to a charity, let us know.
Hollow_Cyclist
12-14-09, 03:46 PM
I notice these moronic drivers coming into intersections at about 30mph and coming to a quick stop. They sometimes dont even look in the direction of oncoming traffic or expect cyclists and I think thats why they are so dangerous. They pull up on the right side with enough space for oncoming traffic to pass but almost dangerous for cyclists as I would have to swerve past them or come to a stop. Sometimes that creates a chain reaction of me swerving and then making the driver behind me uneasy about the erratic movement. I get somewhat irrate when this happens and yell at the driver coming into the intersection so quickly. They are not safe in my opinion. I make sure I know whats going on 360 degrees around me. If I wasnt so cautious those situations would have likely turned into accidents.
idoru2005
12-21-09, 09:54 AM
I drove on Jamboree road for the first time after hearing about this "accident". I was looking for a memorial or even a ghost bike to mark where this happened. I didn't see anything.
However I was shocked when I notice that this part of Jamboree (between Ford and Bison) HAS NO BIKE LANE MARKINGS. Not so much as a fog line or anything else for that matter. The road itself is VERY wide - it has very wide shoulders for cyclists to use. In my mind, it comes as no surprise that the driver hit the cyclist. There was absolutely no visual indicator (aside from a cyclist's blinking light), showing where the driving lane ends and the bike lane begins. It's easy to see how a bad driver could easily think they are driving in the right place especially when there's no line indicating the edge of the roadway.
His family members are better than I........
http://www.ocregister.com/news/family-223891-murphy-john.html
why is the family praying for this person and why are they forgiving her?? I could understand if she killed him and pulled over, but she kept going.
I dont get it...
Garfield Cat
12-21-09, 03:55 PM
I think they're a Christian family. I'm guessing at how they think, but Christians see life as from God, and one's permanent home is really with God in heaven. Life, here, is transitory. It doesn't mean that life here is without value, or insignificant. The family is praying for the person causing the fatality because taking a human life is a serious matter. When that matter is applied to the driver, its unknown to the family, her intentions, her state of mind. The driver's level of culpability (willful intent) determines the seriousness of sin. Praying for the driver, is interceding (intercessory prayer) on behalf of her, asking God for forgiveness of sin. Secondarily, prayer is asking for emotional and spiritual healing for her.
I think they're a Christian family. I'm guessing at how they think, but Christians see life as from God, and one's permanent home is really with God in heaven. Life, here, is transitory. It doesn't mean that life here is without value, or insignificant. The family is praying for the person causing the fatality because taking a human life is a serious matter. When that matter is applied to the driver, its unknown to the family, her intentions, her state of mind. The driver's level of culpability (willful intent) determines the seriousness of sin. Praying for the driver, is interceding (intercessory prayer) on behalf of her, asking God for forgiveness of sin. Secondarily, prayer is asking for emotional and spiritual healing for her.
Thats pretty devout...If someone killed my wife or my dad I dont think I would act like this. ESPECIALLY since she tried to run away. I can understand praying for her because things happen but when you try to flee.
Anyways, I still think the state should press charges, even if the family "forgave" her.
bretgross
12-21-09, 06:44 PM
I attended the funeral (my second funeral in two days, but that's another story). It was a moving and encouraging experience, an affirmation of life.
If you didn't know Don, his eulogy and the remarks shared by his wife, daughters and brother certainly painted a picture of a caring, compassionate, and committed man who was full of life and shared his time and talents with others.
Carpe Diem!
Garfield Cat
12-22-09, 08:39 AM
Thats pretty devout...If someone killed my wife or my dad I dont think I would act like this. ESPECIALLY since she tried to run away. I can understand praying for her because things happen but when you try to flee.
Anyways, I still think the state should press charges, even if the family "forgave" her.
Cultural conditioning. In Mexico it used to be that drivers would normally leave a scene of an accident. I don't know if that's still the case now.
Cultural conditioning. In Mexico it used to be that drivers would normally leave a scene of an accident. I don't know if that's still the case now.
Well, this ain't Mexico. If this is how they do in Mexico, then I don't really care to ever go there! I am also an immigrant, in case people look for an anti-immigrant bias in my response.
I would hope for, and expect people to stop if they run over a pet, not to talk of a human being.
She should have stopped, even if all she could do was to give Don Murphy a sip of water or talk to him in his last moments.
alicestrong
12-24-09, 09:28 AM
There is now a ghost bike for Mr. Murphy...
Well, this ain't Mexico. If this is how they do in Mexico, then I don't really care to ever go there! I am also an immigrant, in case people look for an anti-immigrant bias in my response.
I would hope for, and expect people to stop if they run over a pet, not to talk of a human being.
She should have stopped, even if all she could do was to give Don Murphy a sip of water or talk to him in his last moments.
I asked my gf's friend about this(shes mexican) and she said people in Mexico would not run away from a scene of an accident. She said thats the most obsurd thing shes ever heard.
I asked my gf's friend about this(shes mexican) and she said people in Mexico would not run away from a scene of an accident. She said thats the most obsurd thing shes ever heard.
I thought so. Every mexican I've ever met has been a good and decent human being. I just could not fathom anybody driving away from an accident, especially one where another person has been seriously injured.
Fat Boy
12-24-09, 03:26 PM
Horrible story. I'm really sorry for the family and their loss. Very moving post describing it.
Thanks to the Ridazz for the ghost bike. This could have been any one of us.
idoru2005
03-19-10, 09:38 PM
Here's an update on this story - the driver has finally been charged:
http://www.ocregister.com/news/murphy-240205-izquieta-death.html
bretgross
03-20-10, 11:32 AM
Thank you for posting the update.
Though there is certainly enough pain to go around, I think that Don's family is much further down the road to healing than the driver.
Here's an update on this story - the driver has finally been charged:
http://www.ocregister.com/news/murphy-240205-izquieta-death.html
bmclaughlin807
03-20-10, 01:28 PM
Most absurd quote of the day:
Murphy's family issued a statement in December forgiving Izquieta, saying she did nothing intentionally wrong.
Let's see... driving without a license???? Driving while under the influence of medication that I'm POSITIVE includes a warning about not operating heavy machinery?
Let's see some side effects, shall we?
Side-effects
Common
Drowsiness[22]
Impairment of cognition, judgment, or memory
Irritability and aggression[23]
Psychomotor agitation[24]
Lack of motivation[25]
Loss of libido
Impaired motor function
Impaired coordination
Impaired balance
Dizziness
Diarrhea
Cognitive impairments
Increased sleepwalking (If used in treatment of sleepwalking)
Auditory hallucinations
Short-term memory loss
Anterograde amnesia (common with higher doses)
Some users report hangover-like symptoms of being drowsy, having a headache, being sluggish, and being irritable after waking up if the medication is taken before sleep. This is likely the result of the medication's long half-life, which continues to affect the user after waking up, as well as its disruption of the REM cycle.
Adverse effects of methadone include:[13][21][22][23][24]
Thrombus
Hypoventilation
Constipation
Increased sweating, heat intolerance
Chronic fatigue, sleepiness and exhaustion
Constricted pupils
Nausea
Low blood pressure
Hallucination
Headache
Vomiting
Cardiac arrhythmia
Anorexia
Weight gain
Gynecomastia
Stomach pains
Dry mouth
Perspiration
Flushing
Itching
Difficulty urinating
Swelling of the hands, arms, feet, and legs
Agitation
Mood changes
Blurred vision
Insomnia
Impotence
Skin rash
Seizures
So... she willfully got behind the wheel of a vehicle while unlicensed and under the influence of several (they don't tell us how many others there might be) prescription drugs that are EXTREMELY likely to impair her ability to operate it. But she did nothing intentionally wrong.
I HATE PEOPLE.
I HATE PEOPLE.
werd... i hate reading stories about peoples poor actions or horrible acts...
there are some sick people out there...
Captain Insano
03-20-10, 08:12 PM
The (alleged) murderer plead not guilty yesterday:
http://www.dailypilot.com/articles/2010/03/19/publicsafety/dpt-izquieta032010.txt
By the way, methadone is commonly used to treat heroin addiction. Reach your own conclusions.
Well, this ain't Mexico. If this is how they do in Mexico, then I don't really care to ever go there! I am also an immigrant, in case people look for an anti-immigrant bias in my response.
My doctor practices right here in the USA, he has had several patients who were hit my motorists. He says that in every case the motorist fled the scene.
To my doctor's experience, drivers in the US do not stop when they hit cyclists.
idoru2005
02-02-11, 12:33 PM
There's been an update to this case - the driver has pleaded guilty!
http://www.ocregister.com/news/murphy-286676-izquieta-hit.html
CritEastwood
02-02-11, 12:41 PM
...and looks to get a whopping three year sentence.
...and looks to get a whopping three year sentence.
This is the tragic part. Three years in jail is a long time for anyone, but seems an awfully short sentence for the actions described. Pretty awful read all the way around.
CritEastwood
02-02-11, 05:33 PM
Face it man, when you are on a bicycle out here, you aren't worth a damn as far as the law/judicial system are concerned.
Johnelwood
02-02-11, 09:52 PM
Very sad, and I'm not satisfied with the sentence either. However, wouldn't she have gotten even less if she had run into another car and killed the driver or a passenger and fled the scene? Or about the same as if she hit a pedestrian? I don't know that bicyclists are being dissed by the legal system.
idoru2005
02-04-11, 02:47 PM
Kill an anonymous cyclist - get 3 years.
http://http://www.ocregister.com/news/murph...uieta-hit.html
Kill a well-known entrepreneur driving an expensive car - get 9 years.
http://www.ocregister.com/news/kirby-287059-lewis-never.html
CritEastwood
02-05-11, 01:11 AM
Kill an anonymous cyclist - get 3 years.
Kill a well-known entrepreneur driving an expensive car - get 9 years.
http://www.ocregister.com/news/kirby-287059-lewis-never.html
Ridiculous, isn't it?
fishymamba
02-07-11, 04:21 PM
Kill a well-known entrepreneur driving an expensive car - get 9 years.
http://www.ocregister.com/news/kirby-287059-lewis-never.html
I don't think this is valid because the man was drunk and he was taking part in a illegal street race
fishymamba
02-08-11, 09:55 PM
Just saw this online: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-oxfordshire-10845907
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.12 Copyright © 2012 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.