Touring - XD600 with Tiagra Triple Front Derailleur (but what version....?)

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




fast_track
03-05-10, 11:29 AM
I am setting my XD600 (48/36/26) for a 45mm chainline on either a 110-113 BB (have both to try). I see all over the forums that a very popular front derailleur is the Tiagra Triple. I am using DA bar end shifters. I am running a 9 speed chain/cassette.

That said, many of the post on this topic are several years old. People always say "The Tiagra Triple" works great. Until a few years ago the model was called the FD-4403, and this version allowed for a 45mm chainline, a min tooth difference of 10T, and most importantly could handle a tooth difference of 22T (which is what I have)

The new version that replaced the FD-4403 several years back is now called the FD-4503. It still has a 45mm chainline, now has a min tooth difference of 11T, BUT is now listed as only handling a 20T difference (to me this is a problem for my 48/36/26 combo)

I am having an impossible time finding the IRD Alpina D in stock anyplace on the planet or else I would just get it. Avoiding current Shimano mountain derailleurs because of the 50mm chainline.

SO..... Is anyone running at 48/36/26 combo with the NEWEST Tiagra Triple (the FD-4503) or are most people using the older model from a few years ago?

May need to look for old stock on the 4403.... Thanks


robow
03-05-10, 12:06 PM
fwiw, I'm running the FD 4503 on my roadie and it's a 52/42/30 with no problems. Generally Shimano is fairly conservative on what the FD/RD will handle.

fast_track
03-05-10, 01:41 PM
Thru some luck and a 20 minute search thru some old stock of used derailleurs in a giant tub, my LBS was able to find me a cleanish version of the FD-4403 (older triple version) for $20. They even put a 28.6mm clamp on it for me they pulled off a double of the same vintage so I didn't have to use some unsightly shims. Thumbs up to my LBS for taking the time to look, clean and adjust an item at such a low price point! You can't go wrong really for $20!!


oldride
03-05-10, 02:30 PM
I'm running a triple 105 FD on the same 48-36-26 crankset. Works great.

kaliayev
03-05-10, 02:54 PM
Congrats on the $20 find. Thumbs up for your LBS.

fast_track
03-05-10, 04:00 PM
I'm running a triple 105 FD on the same 48-36-26 crankset. Works great.

Good to know. Just curious, is it the current version (listed as 20T max difference, 10 speed) Model FD-5603? I think the OP is right, the listed range is conservative by Shimano.... If it is the older version the FD-5503 then it was designed for a 22T difference. See shimano tech doc link:
http://techdocs.shimano.com/media/techdocs/content/cycle/SI/105/FD-5503-5504/SI-57Z0C-En_v1_m56577569830603724.pdf

It looks to me that the TIAGRA FD-4403 and the 105 FD-5503 were speced for 22T and their replacements FD-4505 and FD-5603 both dropped to 20T.....

fast_track
03-05-10, 04:01 PM
Congrats on the $20 find. Thumbs up for your LBS.

I love Yellow Springs! Grew up in Columbus. Tons of great riding near you.