Cyclocross - Feedback on converting a mountain bike or XO-2 for a child's cross bike

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




curt_k
09-19-10, 06:58 PM
I'm looking for a 'cross worthy bike for my 11 year-old daughter. I posted a wanted to buy ad on local Craiglist and got a response from a great guy, self-confessed bike pack rat. Anyhow, he has a couple bikes that could work, but I'm wondering a couple of things and thought I'd ask here.

One is a 14.5" mountain bike (Univega Alpina 5.3, double butted cromoly, mid-90's, no suspension, slightly smaller, so slightly better fit for now). The other is a Bridgestone XO-2 (I think also double butted cromoly). He understandably wants $100 more for the XO-2, so I'm kinda leaning to the Univega! But I'm concerned that putting drops on a mountain bike and racing 'cross on it could have some problems, like the geometry of the mtn bike wasn't intended for drops, or something like that. And yes, the final bike has to have drops because my daughter likes them (I don't blame her).

They're both 26 inch wheels, both would wind up 1 X 7, both would run ghetto tubeless 26 inch cross tries of some sort. So the decision seems to me to be mostly about geometry (and price, all else being equal, I'll buy the $100 cheaper bike!).

Any thoughts on the geometry or otherwise about these bikes??

Take care, Curt


4Rings6Stars
09-19-10, 07:01 PM
IMHO the Bridgestone is a MUCH nicer bike and the geometry would be more appropriate for drop bars. See if you can talk him down on the price?

curt_k
09-23-10, 02:05 PM
Just to follow up on this in case a similar question comes up for someone (looking for an affordable cross bike for a child), we wound up with the Univega with drops and "skinny" 26 inch tires (1.5 inch -- 35mm?). My daughter loves it. I do too, wish it fit me so I could play around with it. It's kind of heavy, but *way* better than her old dept store mountain bike. It's got bar-end shifting, which I'm not very happy with, but the man who built it up for us didn't have any STI stuff around. So that's the next move, but for now, it's a perfectly useable cyclocross / street bike for not a lot of money.

It's a great bike, a real beast, she'll kill in mud, be kinda slower in dry stuff.

BTW, I found some reviews that talked about the Bridgestone XO-2 as not cut out for racing. It seems there's a consensus from owners that it's a great bike for laid back rides -- not the thing for cross!!


Cynikal
09-23-10, 02:42 PM
That review was when the bike was introduced and no one knew what to think about them. The XO-2 would be the better of the two to race cross due to the geo.