Bicycle Mechanics - Which front mech ?

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




View Full Version : Which front mech ?


385xza
10-23-10, 08:29 AM
Hi All.
I am currently re-building an old Raleigh Pioneer 120 frame into a city bike, i.e for commuting etc, as the entire drive train was toast when I rescued it I have started again from scratch and the last piece of kit I need to consider is the front derailleur.
I have rebuilt using a 53/39 double crank set with a 6 speed 14/28 Shimano freewheel on the rear running through a Shimano RD TX31 derailleur with grip shifts on straight bars for comfort. I have road tested the set-up and I am happy with the ratios as they are as it makes for an easy ride.
What front derailleur would the members of this forum suggest? It needs to be suitable for bottom pull control and 28.6mm band on fitment, it will be run through a friction shift twist grip, I would like it to be Shimano if possible to complete the set.

385XZA


Retro Grouch
10-23-10, 09:42 AM
53/39 means that you need a road front derailleur. They'll all be bottom pull so that's a non-issue. A friction shift Grip Shifter will work with anything so you're OK there too.

I'd just use whatever Shimano derailleur I could find that fits the seat tube. I like to use one that generally matches the component quality level of the rest of the bike.

Grand Bois
10-23-10, 11:02 AM
I didn't know they ever made a friction grip shifter. What is the brand?


surreal
10-23-10, 12:44 PM
i'm thinking you'll be better served with an older front derailer, as the 10-speed parallelograms can be too narrow, and cause some rubbing with 8speed chain. If you havent actually tossed out the original front derailer(mech), it is probably salvageable. If not, get a tiagra or a sora, 28.6 clamp.

As far as friction grip shifters, these are more accurately referred to as "ratcheting" than as friction. Basically, these will "click click click", but the clicks do not coincide with an indexed position. They're quite adaptable to many different drivetrains.

-rob

385xza
10-30-10, 04:53 AM
Thanks everybody for the replies, I now know what I am looking for. With regards to the friction shift twist grip I mentioned it is a "no name" I purchased of the Bay and as surreal suggests it is the "click click click", type which is perfect for what I need. The old front mech was totally trashed, all the pivots were worn and the cage bent.
Thanks again for the replies.

385xza

385xza
11-13-10, 10:59 AM
OK guys an update, after considering the advice offered I went looking for a front derailer I ended up with a brand new Campagnola unit sold as a "9 speed" for just 10 pounds sterling. Its a beutiful piece of kit and looks very well made.
Fitted it last weekend and after a bit of adjustment it works great and handles the jump from the 39 tooth to the 53 tooth rings no problem..... The only problem now is I wished I'd got a Campy rear mech as well .....

surreal
11-13-10, 07:56 PM
you may find one for cheap later, and swap. in the meantime, just enjoy the ride.

congrats on the successful build!
-rob