Bicycle Mechanics - Any experiences with Sturmey-Archer's XRD-5? Five-speed drum brake IGH?
Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.
05-20-11, 02:11 PM
Been searching the internets and aside from a Vancouver Crusiers post from last year, there's been nothing else about this hub.
Has anyone used it? If so, how's the shifting and maintenance?
05-20-11, 02:34 PM
200 miles+ so far, no problems, several rain days. tire/tube change can be done on brake side without disconnecting the drive side and having to readjust.
05-20-11, 06:47 PM
No direct experience with a 5 speed with drum brake, but I've been riding an XRF5 for going on 5 years with no issues. Started off with the twist shifter that came with the hub. It worked fine, but when one of my grandsons knocked the bike over and broke the housing where the cable exits the shifter, I took it as an excuse to try the trigger shifter, the DLS 50.
(DLS52 for wide range)
The shifting is flawless, right down to zero degrees f. No issues whatsoever.
I used to sell bikes with 8 speed SA hubs with drum brakes, and they worked very well when set up properly. It's the same brake as the 5 speed.
I deal with a lot of them at work. No complaints, other than a couple incidences of hubs with cracked internals out of the box. Haven't seen that in at least two years, though.
Like many of Sturmey's hubs, they're a bit more rough around the edges than, say, a Shimano Nexus hub (adjustment indicator isn't quite as user friendly as shimano's, shifting is a bit more touchy pedal load-wise), but they seem to be good workhorses. The drum brake works well and seems reliable.
05-22-11, 12:10 AM
The 5 speed is a simpler hub than the 7, 8, and 11 speeds and has been in production for decades... they are a workhorse and have a pretty decent range albeit with some wider jumps.
The drum brake offers decent all weather stopping power and overhauling and maintaining them is rather simple and inexpensive.
The 5 speed...has been in production for decades...
Sturmey has built 5-spd IGHs since 1966, but, and it's a big but, it's been several different designs over that time period. No single design has ever been built for multiple decades. The current (W) series debuted only last year. The previous "ball locking" Summit series came out in 1999. Prior to that was the Sprinter series that began in 1993, and before that was the 1991 StAr5 (arguably Sturmey's worst hub design ever).
...Has anyone used it? If so, how's the shifting and maintenance?...
I have one on my commuter/shopping bike. The hub has extreme cool factor, the look can't be beat. Gear steps are kinda large, it makes it difficult to ride with a group of friends with 27 speed commuters. The brake has lost some of it's braking efficiency, I suspect there's been some lube leakage into the brake drum. It's a Sturmey Archer, requires care whilst shifting, cable tension in 1st gear is really tight, watch out for the shifting cable/axle nut if you have big feet.
05-23-11, 11:15 AM
looks like the wide 5 speed has the .75 and 1.3 gear ratio in 2 and 4 , like AW3.
1st & 5th, outside of that, higher and lower.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.12 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.