Hybrid Bicycles - motobecane vs jamis

shopping flatbar bikes.

consider jamis allegro elite vs motobecane cafe bikes.

having hard time seeing anything atall wrong w/ motos.

it is gonna be hassle to find bike local to match geometry of moto for a test ride

thoughts?
thanx

If you understand the geometry and comfortable doing your own wrenching, moto should be no problem. If you have questions or doubts about either one, then Jamis- because it comes with a built-in support staff at the LBS.

If you understand the geometry and comfortable doing your own wrenching, moto should be no problem. If you have questions or doubts about either one, then Jamis- because it comes with a built-in support staff at the LBS.
if the package starts out fine, im fine w/ online support.
im interested in opinions of bang for the buck, and other real world comparisons.

moto is out of stock for now, i ask now to be ready when stock comes in.

i think i dont understand why moto rep among actual users is sparse or negative.

seems like a fine product at very reasonable price

thnx

I've been VERY happy with my "Jamis" purchases this year. Bought a 2012 Jamis Coda Sport, switched to "trekking bars" and this is my "road bike". Then picked up a left over Jamis Allegro 1 and switched components to make it more of a "dirt path/utility" machine. I've had Jamis since 2009 and their service has been excellent, had a frame weld crack on a MTB, Jamis "rushed" me a new frame, from the next level up model and paid the LBS to swap everything over, can't beat that!
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-VKADiL8aG48/TzBozUy5gzI/AAAAAAAAEBA/YV-sN8rciiA/s640/DSCN0037.JPG

if the package starts out fine, im fine w/ online support.
im interested in opinions of bang for the buck, and other real world comparisons.

moto is out of stock for now, i ask now to be ready when stock comes in.

i think i dont understand why moto rep among actual users is sparse or negative.

seems like a fine product at very reasonable price

thnxMoto doesn't have a bad rep among the people who have bought them- actually, no body really trash talks anything from BD. It's BD that irks people, due to how they hyperinflate the MSRP of their bikes. Add in the fact that complete newbs who order from BD sometimes end up at the LBS to do the assembly and adjustments, the price savings just went away before they even take it fora spin. But the BD or other online source vs. LBS is a long running topic of discussion on these boards, so I'm done commenting on it.

thanx for comments and pic
@bjjoondo: i am surprised that you changed handlebar setup.. just personal preference.. your bike looks nice,, customer service is always a deal breaker for me.

@no1mad: hyperinflate is a big word and this really surprised me.. for the same money that they deliver a product, another manufacturer ( read: that i am considering ) delivers waay less. so a comparable setup does cost way more..

i would appreciate some clarification; as i am not very smart .

this is my 2nd hybrid.. i look at ::

raleigh cadent ft3

jamis allegro pro

now moto cafe century or century pro..

whichever they get that fits and soonest..

thanx

i think i dont understand why moto rep among actual users is sparse or negative.
thnx


I agree with no1mad that a lot of that is coming from people who are not actual owners. I consider myself to be primarily a road cyclist, and I think there's an element of snobbery in the road biking community that feeds into trash talking Bikes Direct bikes. I don't see nearly as much negativity toward Bikes Direct on cyclocross forums or mtb forums.

MSRP on BD is the same on the manufacturer's site. Most brands on BD that has their own website does match same MSRP as BD. Like the Fuji and Motobecane brand etc. If it was me (purchasing for myself). I wouldn't get anything lower than a Motobecane Sprint. That's if you're thinking of getting a Motobecane flat bar road bike. Why? Because it has a better crankset. My wife has the Motobecane Cafe Latte and the crankset looks and feels a bit weak, when comparing to my 2010 Fuji Absolute 2.0. It's probably okay for her, since she's is small and does not weigh too much.

It's a great bike for the money though. Also I don't like the handle bars. It has the foam type grips.

Now the Century or Century Pro that is a great deal and great bikes. I was thinking, if one day that I retire the Fuji. I might want to get the Cafe Century Pro myself.

MSRP on BD is the same on the manufacturer's site.

Yeah, but the brands owned by BD(Motobecane, Mercier, Gravity, and I'm probably forgetting a couple more) are never sold anywhere at the MSRP. For what you actually get, I don't think the BD MSRP's are inflated much compared to what you get for the money from other bike companies. I find it a little amusing that in bike buyer's guides and reviews of BD bikes in magazines, it's always the MSRP listed without mention that the bikes really sell for way less than that.

Yeah, but the brands owned by BD(Motobecane, Mercier, Gravity, and I'm probably forgetting a couple more) are never sold anywhere at the MSRP. For what you actually get, I don't think the BD MSRP's are inflated much compared to what you get for the money from other bike companies. I find it a little amusing that in bike buyer's guides and reviews of BD bikes in magazines, it's always the MSRP listed without mention that the bikes really sell for way less than that.

It has the MSRP and the current price on the page in BD. So purchasing a bike that sells lower than the MSRP is bad?

To me, there's nothing bad about BD's bikes. As long as you know what you want (size, type of bike, components etc). I think the only reason maybe why LBS or certain peoples hate BD so much, is because they can't compare prices. When comparing to same quality bikes as BD. For that BD and other online retailers are taking more customers away from the LBS.

I mean, if I was the LBS. I'll be piss myself.

Buying direct does save you money. Either diamonds or bikes.

What I'm saying is that certain brands sold by Bikes Direct are actually owned by Bikes Direct. Bikes Direct could stick an MSRP on there that's 10 times what they're actually selling a bike for if they wanted to.

Look, all you have to do is compare. Compare other brand name bikes that has the same components, frame etc and it would be around the same MSRP. Just because a brand or a retailer can sell their bikes cheaper. Doesn't mean that it's a bad thing.

No, it's not a bad thing. I even own a Motobecane Le Champion Ti from Bikes Direct and am very happy with it.

No, it's not a bad thing. I even own a Motobecane Le Champion Ti from Bikes Direct and am very happy with it.

...and that's a good thing. :D :thumb:

OP - If you are experienced with bike assembly and things like the basic tune up the bike will need after a few miles of use, buying online makes sense if you like the bike. If you're not you're going to end up paying a shop and if the point is to save money, you likely won't. If the online retailer has something unique that may not matter to you. I'd say the same thing whether you were looking at BD or some other online retailer like Performance or REI. I've never had a BD bike but a I've seen a few up close on club rides and they seem fine.

Pricepoint also markets that way with their house brand Sette(MSRP and actual selling price). Pretty good bike deals there, too, but you have to add in shipping cost.

The amount of saddle to bar drop on the photo of their flat bar road bike makes me chuckle. I mean, who's really going to do that? http://ww.w.pricepoint.com/detail/21883-018_SETXN0-277-Bikes--/Sette-Xion-Tiagra-Flat-Bar-Road-Bike.htm

Pricepoint also markets that way with their house brand Sette(MSRP and actual selling price). Pretty good bike deals there, too, but you have to add in shipping cost.

The amount of saddle to bar drop on the photo of their flat bar road bike makes me chuckle. I mean, who's really going to do that? http://ww.w.pricepoint.com/detail/21883-018_SETXN0-277-Bikes--/Sette-Xion-Tiagra-Flat-Bar-Road-Bike.htm

my mind wants saddle and grip to be level..idk any better tho.. i come from hybrid..

i read BD FAQ.. then emailed them w/ questions..
i went from excluding moto completely to making it a most likely choice..
i still welcome all input but thanx for all input so far...

If I were you, I'd go with the Jamis Coda Sport. Regardless of your age, you'll most likely never have to purchase another bicycle in your entire life, due to its chromoly steel construction. Within five or six years, all of your major components would have been upgraded, and you'll essentially be riding a Jamis Coda Elite (w/o the disc brakes).

The Jamis Coda Series, won the editor's choice award of Bicycling Magazine, for being the best hybrid of 2011.

- Slim :)

You'll still save money, even if you purchase from BD and took the bike to the LBS and get it tune and adjusted. That's because you'll save up to $200 or even more when buying from BD. When comparing to similar bikes at the LBS.

You'll still save money, even if you purchase from BD and took the bike to the LBS and get it tune and adjusted. That's because you'll save up to $200 or even more when buying from BD. When comparing to similar bikes at the LBS.
But what if you have no mechanical aptitude whatsoever? Then you have to take it to the LBS, which adds about $75 to price around here to assemble something they didn't sell.

Add in the fact that when buying from the LBS, some of things like grips, tires, stems can be swapped out for little to no charge before leaving the store. You buy from BD, any ergonomic/comfort/fit changes you have to pay full price for.

Bottom line is that BD makes sense for those that understand their wants/needs, have at least enough mechanical aptitude to do basic adjustments, and possibly have some spare parts/tools laying around already. Most of that stuff only comes through experience. Noobs lack that experience and would be better served in the long run to rely on the LBS for their first (and possibly second and third) purchases.

But what if you have no mechanical aptitude whatsoever? Then you have to take it to the LBS, which adds about $75 to price around here to assemble something they didn't sell.

Add in the fact that when buying from the LBS, some of things like grips, tires, stems can be swapped out for little to no charge before leaving the store. You buy from BD, any ergonomic/comfort/fit changes you have to pay full price for.

Bottom line is that BD makes sense for those that understand their wants/needs, have at least enough mechanical aptitude to do basic adjustments, and possibly have some spare parts/tools laying around already. Most of that stuff only comes through experience. Noobs lack that experience and would be better served in the long run to rely on the LBS for their first (and possibly second and third) purchases.

I do agreed with you about that you need to know what you want and be mechanical enough to do the adjustments, if buying from BD or online. Although I/we have mention about it many times already. Every LBS is different, so you can't really count on the free and not free stuffs that you can get.

My 2010 Fuji Absolute 2.0 cost me $399 at BD. Comparing to a Trek 7.5 I would have to spend more than $700. More like $800-$900 and that's on the cheap side. When I found the Fuji on BD and it was price at $399. I look online to fine how much other places is selling the same bike for and the closes I found was $549 and $649-$699. Same year and everything. So yeah, I did save a lot purchasing from BD. Although Nashbar has a better deal on the 2010 Fuji Absolute 1.0 ($599). Just a step up from mines.

If I were you, I'd go with the Jamis Coda Sport. Regardless of your age, you'll most likely never have to purchase another bicycle in your entire life, due to its chromoly steel construction. Within five or six years, all of your major components would have been upgraded, and you'll essentially be riding a Jamis Coda Elite (w/o the disc brakes).

The Jamis Coda Series, won the editor's choice award of Bicycling Magazine, for being the best hybrid of 2011.

- Slim :)
i couldnt find a real review to read; why is it the winner, pros cons etc..
specs point to moto. geometrys are different.. but i dont find comparisons about frame quality.
especially when its claimed that all big names are made in just a few factories together side by side

if a jamis is expected to upgrade all components, how far would it go. how much to spend.

im gonna go to jamis dealer today or tomm.. i can find out what they would charge for upgrades.. i cant really tell real world geometry till i see it..

i keep my bike tuned myself; anything i dont know, you tube does.

thanx

thanx for comments and pic
@bjjoondo: i am surprised that you changed handlebar setup.. just personal preference.. your bike looks nice,, customer service is always a deal breaker for me.

@no1mad: hyperinflate is a big word and this really surprised me.. for the same money that they deliver a product, another manufacturer ( read: that i am considering ) delivers waay less. so a comparable setup does cost way more..


i would appreciate some clarification; as i am not very smart .

this is my 2nd hybrid.. i look at ::

raleigh cadent ft3

jamis allegro pro

now moto cafe century or century pro..

whichever they get that fits and soonest..

thanx


The handlebar is stock, just went to an "adjustable stem", both my wife and I have "old whiplass" injury problems to this day and the normal, 10 to 20 degree stem that comes OEM on most bikes is quite painful. On my Coda Sport and her KHS Vitamin B (flat bar road bikes), we had the LBS switch out the OEM stem for 35 degree (angle) stems, mine 110mm and her's 90mm (she has SHORT arms). So yes, it's personal preference. The Allegro 1, which is the bottom line Allegro for 2011 is my "Utility/All purpose" bike, put on MTB gearing, fatter, more treaded tires and the adjustable stem so it could be set for different styles of riding. LOL, think of it as a "poor mans" cyclo-cross bike! :) ENJOY whatever you end up with, all look like good choices to me!

jamis is not under consideration atall now...

went to only dealer in town. he did the bait and switch. phone convo said he said my size allegro in stock.. actually had the opposite of my size--- not my size..

tried to steer me into smaller size. blood pressure goes up lil bit.. walked out.

went to cannondale.. salesman argued bout what i wanted; didnt even look at what he had.. maybe i go to another cannondale shop, probly not.

raleigh and trek fx felt the very best.. yet i cant square up w/ all factors i consider..

leaning hard to moto cafe century.. if they restock w/ pro in 60cm.. i buy it and take my chance.. if plain century, thats fine too..

400$diff.. still, something about the component list that might make it worth it to me

That sucks, sorry to hear the Jamis dealer was a PIA, I'm so lucky my Jamis dealer is "EXCELLENT", hope you find something you'll love in the end!

Amkaos says:


i couldnt find a real review to read; why is it the winner, pros cons etc..specs point to moto. geometrys are different.. but i dont find comparisons about frame quality.especially when its claimed that all big names are made in just a few factories together side by side

I can personally attest to the fact that the Jamis Coda Comp was one of the smoothest bicycles that I have ever ridden, and I've ridden quite a few. The Jamis Coda was also one of the best handling hybrids I've ever ridden, as well. This "supple" feature in handling, was exactly what impressed Bicycling Magazines editor, which influenced him to bestow upon the Coda, such a prestigious award, for being the best Flat bar hybrid of 2011.


if a jamis is expected to upgrade all components, how far would it go. how much to spend.

Insofar as upgrades are concerned. The Jamis Coda Sport starts with Acera componentry. While that's considered as low for this community, some people swear by Acera. As it turns out, it's not as smooth as Alvio, but it's durable, and gets the job done effectively. The Jamis Comp, does come complete with both Alivio and Deore. These are the workhorse components of all the MTB grouppos. Of course, Deore is just a step up from Alivio, and the Jamis Coda Elite has all Deore Components.

For an upgrade, that would largely depend upon your preferences. In order to upgrade a Coda Sport to an approximate Coda Elite, you'd have to lose the Acera group and opt for an all Deore cast of players. In all honesty, for most hybrids, once you get to Alivio, you're already in a fairly smooth transition state.


im gonna go to jamis dealer today or tomm.. i can find out what they would charge for upgrades.. i cant really tell real world geometry till i see it..

This is really the best way to determine the actual value of a bicycle, you've just got to see it for yourself, mount it, and test-ride it. It's quite possible that you won't even find a need for an upgrade!


i keep my bike tuned myself; anything i dont know, you tube does.

You appear to be quite a resourceful and independent-minded kinda guy. I'm most certain that you will make the wisest choice in bicycles for your future commuting needs.

- Slim :)

PS.

Sorry the Jamis dealership didn't workout. That dealership is NOT typical of what I've witnessed of Jamis. That behavior should be reported immediately!

BD has fuji absolute 1.

specs look great; components + geometry.. price seems like a steal.

interwebs failed to turn up any negatives about this..

anyone have opinions / experience?

bd doesnt have my size in stock, fuji site for 2012 doesnt match same components..

if bd doesnt downgrade their offer when they restock, its a serious re-consider.. thanx

edit::
finally found weight:: Weight:
10.94 kg / 24.12 lb approx.. still 10% less than cannondale and trekfx

i hoped it wouldve come in around 21-22#.. like raleigh non-CF cafes..
seems like all makers should state weight as spec'd on site

Check out Nashbar for the Absolute 1 also. It looks like they're out of stock now, but previously they were selling it for $100 less than Bikes Direct.

The 2010 Fuji Absolute 1.0 on BD is a great buy. Nashbar have it for $100 cheaper, but only the 17 inch frames are left. Got my 2010 Fuji Absolute 2.0 from BD. Love the bike. Fast and light. Mine is about 23-24 lbs. The 1.0 might land around 21-23 lbs.

No, it's not a bad thing. I even own a Motobecane Le Champion Ti from Bikes Direct and am very happy with it.

Ditto, it is a great bike and a great value.