Bicycle Mechanics - De-bending handle bars?

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




View Full Version : De-bending handle bars?


rito25
04-14-12, 12:12 PM
I got into a crash the other day. Other than some road rash I'm ok. However my 3ttt handle bars got pretty bent. They feel weird to ride now. Any way to de bend them? Or save up money and buy a new pair. I really liked these handle bars too. So nice and light.


AlphaDogg
04-14-12, 12:32 PM
I'm assuming they're aluminum. Aluminum typically cracks before it bends. If it's bent, they might be cracked. I wouldn't take a risk. A handlebar is much cheaper than an ambulance ride because the handlebar failed.

rito25
04-14-12, 12:37 PM
Yeah. That's what I figured. OH well. Gives me an excuse to upgrade my brakes and maybe put a 130 stem on.


benbrangwyn
04-14-12, 12:41 PM
Yeah, I agree with Alpha. Aluminium fails catastrophically (rather than gradually like steel). I would definitely not risk it. I've known aluminium bars snap suddenly - happened to my brother, and luckily he only got a damaged shoulder.

One time I overtightened some bar-ends on a set of titanium bars, ruining the bars. I thought... let's see just how tough these suckers are. I hammered them, sledgehammered them, jumped up and down on them, put them up against a step and Bruce Lee'd them. They started to unroll , but never lost their form as bars. Seriously, I'd rather use titanium bars that had partially derolled than aluminium bars I suspected of having been damaged. I have ti bars on most of my bikes now.

So don't use them. Ever. For anything.

Nerull
04-14-12, 12:44 PM
Yeah, I agree with Alpha. Aluminium fails catastrophically (rather than gradually like steel). I would definitely not risk it. I've known aluminium bars snap suddenly - happened to my brother, and luckily he only got a damaged shoulder.

One time I overtightened some bar-ends on a set of titanium bars, ruining the bars. I thought... let's see just how tough these suckers are. I hammered them, sledgehammered them, jumped up and down on them, put them up against a step and Bruce Lee'd them. They started to unroll , but never lost their form as bars. Seriously, I'd rather use titanium bars that had partially derolled than aluminium bars I suspected of having been damaged. I have ti bars on most of my bikes now.

So don't use them. Ever. For anything.

Better not look up any photos of snapped titanium spindles.

HillRider
04-14-12, 02:31 PM
+1 Those bars are toast. Even if you could "unbend" them, they would be a sudden failure looking for a place to happen, most likely while you were using them. Cut your losses and get new ones.

rito25
04-14-12, 02:40 PM
What about just using them bent for a few days or so?

cny-bikeman
04-14-12, 03:02 PM
What about just using them bent for a few days or so?

Nobody here should be careless enough to say "Go ahead, it's fine to use," as we just don't know. That being said you are not putting a lot of weight/stress on the bars, and they survived the intial crash. But depends what you mean by "a few days." Til your order for a new set comes in?

benbrangwyn
04-14-12, 06:47 PM
Better not look up any photos of snapped titanium spindles. Stuff of nightmares. But they're probably a very different type of titanium, and there's a big difference between a solid brittle axle and rolled titanium handlebars. The latter are able to deform rather than snap.

benbrangwyn
04-14-12, 06:52 PM
What about just using them bent for a few days or so?

Someone ain't listening. Seriously, why risk it? I guess it could spice up a ride... "will they snap when I go over this pothole, and will I get nailed by the taxi behind me, or have to max out my credit card to replace the teeth I left embedded in the tarmac?"

darinm
04-15-12, 01:11 AM
In my experience, aluminum bends on impact. But after that initial bend, it WILL fracture from ANY stress, be that trying to re-bend or more impact. I wouldn't ride them.

fietsbob
04-15-12, 01:19 AM
Heat treated , they're scrap.. I have successfully flared a set of Modolo Speedy
handlebars a few degrees, but they were not heat treated, and these were not crashed,
just un did some riding use sag.

HillRider
04-15-12, 08:38 AM
Stuff of nightmares. But they're probably a very different type of titanium, and there's a big difference between a solid brittle axle and rolled titanium handlebars. The latter are able to deform rather than snap.
Early Titanium parts, frames, pedal spindles, and others, developed a reputation for failure as they were made of "CP" grade of Ti which has a fairly poor fatigue life. Curent Ti components are made of 3/2.5 Al/V grade Ti alloy which has excellent fatigue life and is much stronger. That said, Speedplay has a 180 pound rider limit for it's Ti spindle pedals.