Bicycle Mechanics - Why big jockey wheel ?

Bikeforums.net is a forum about nothing but bikes. Our community can help you find information about hard-to-find and localized information like bicycle tours, specialties like where in your area to have your recumbent bike serviced, or what are the best bicycle tires and seats for the activities you use your bike for.




View Full Version : Why big jockey wheel ?


aidanpringle
12-26-12, 09:03 AM
Got my new bike today, it's a triban 3. I was looking over it when I noticed the jockey wheel was a lot bigger than anything iv'e seen before. One wheel is the same size as the jockey wheels on my other road bike but the bottom it alot bigger . Its a shimano 2300 derailleur. Is it functional or just a gimmick?

290270

Thanks!


fietsbob
12-26-12, 10:22 AM
Because the engineers in the Company thought it was an advantage.

You probably need to get the definitive answer from them..

this is a FAQ, but as no one here is in the company.

Amongst the Guesses: Effectively wraps more chain,
and increases the radius of the pulley, so the chain does not bend as far to go around it.

Booger1
12-26-12, 10:30 AM
Designers hit the wrong key on the computer?.....Make you think you got your money's worth?.....Who knows what goes through their heads......I'm guessing the bean counters got involved and it's cheaper to make somehow......


Bianchigirll
12-26-12, 11:07 AM
Because the engineers in the Company thought it was an advantage.

You probably need to get the definitive answer from them..

this is a FAQ, but as no one here is in the company.

Amongst the Guesses: Effectively wraps more chain,
and increases the radius of the pulley, so the chain does not bend as far to go around it.

That is what I think it just allows more chain wrap with a standard lenght cage for use with a mega range type FW and compact crank.

Someone needs to market ones that look like a slice or orange, lemon or peperoni.

http://www.bikeforums.net/attachment.php?attachmentid=290270&d=1356537648

aidanpringle
12-26-12, 11:43 AM
That is what I think it just allows more chain wrap with a standard lenght cage for use with a mega range type FW and compact crank.

Someone needs to market ones that look like a slice or orange, lemon or peperoni.

http://www.bikeforums.net/attachment.php?attachmentid=290270&d=1356537648

It has a 3 speed crank-set 50/39/30 with sora front mech, if this is any help...

fietsbob
12-26-12, 12:20 PM
Want something different?
You can go Upmarket to a higher Price Mountain Bike Rear derailleur,
that part was in the build list to keep the price of the bike down, to where you could afford it.

The outer part of the parallelogram is stamped out of sheet metal in one blow.

up at higher price points that part is forged aluminum with a bronze bushing.

it, like an XT read mech, gets close to half of what you paid for the whole bike.

aidanpringle
12-26-12, 12:24 PM
Want something different?
You can go Upmarket to a higher Price Mountain Bike Rear derailleur,
that part was in the build list to keep the price of the bike down, to where you could afford it.

The outer part of the parallelogram is stamped out of sheet metal in one blow.

up at higher price points that part is forged aluminum with a bronze bushing.

it, like an XT read mech, gets close to half of what you paid for the whole bike.

The bike is a road bike, not a mountain bike...

FBinNY
12-26-12, 12:24 PM
A larger lower pulley increases the wrap capacity of the derailleur without lengthening the cage. As the cage rotates backward taking up slack, the chain wraps around the pulley more. Since the arc of wrap increases, more chain is wrapped around a bigger pulley than a smaller one.

southpawboston
12-26-12, 01:16 PM
Agreed, larger pulley wheels increase chain wrap capacity. I've read somewhere that it also makes the drivetrain quieter, though I can't remember the source of that info.

FWIW, it's pretty standard now for new derailleurs to come with 11T jockey wheels, where 9 or 10T used to be the standard.

FBinNY
12-26-12, 01:24 PM
Agreed, larger pulley wheels increase chain wrap capacity. I've read somewhere that it also makes the drivetrain quieter, though I can't remember the source of that info.

FWIW, it's pretty standard now for new derailleurs to come with 11T jockey wheels, where 9 or 10T used to be the standard.

I think we only see them on long cage or wide capacity RDs. Smaller pulleys are still common for short cage versions where capacity isn't an issue.

fietsbob
12-26-12, 01:31 PM
Now.. 10t is Campag, And 11t is Shimano, DA, etc.. I got a Set of Tacx pulleys,
Spares, Rohloff buys the 10t, for their chain tensioner.

I'm going to try them as an upgrade on my Brompton M3L the chain tensioner on that is 10t too..



I've read somewhere that it also makes the drivetrain quieter, though I can't remember the source of that info.

might have been an opinion expressed here, in which case you may need to take a bit of salt, with that.