Choosing the right fender set...
I'm a somewhat novice city commuter (Chicago), and I'm currently obsessing over which fender set to buy for my bike, which is an '89 Stumpjumper with 26X1.4 slicks...I am pretty much set on the Planet Bike Cascadia series, and I need to choose between the hybrid/touring model (45mm), and the ATB model (60mm)... 60mm seems a bit wide for tires that are only about 35mm, but these are designed specifically for 26ers, while the hybrid/touring model is the right width(45mm), but is advertised for up to 27 1/4's... too big?
I'm not sure what to do. I want the fenders to be effective, but I want them to look good, too, and I think narrower is better in that regard.
What do you think?