Want to ride more!
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: South of Seattle, in the rain
Bikes: Marin for dirt, Cannondale for road
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
FSA or Campy compact crank on old Cannondale?
I've been riding and enjoying an '87 Cannondale Black Lightning (R800) recently. Have made some inquiries and received invaluable help here on bikeforums.com. Thanks in advance for any help.
One question I have concerns swapping the worn 52-42 Sugino chainrings on 130 mm BCD crankset for something more suited to my needs; climbing hills, keeping pulse in manageable range for 60-something rider, and letting me shift off the small ring now and then.
Both FSA and Campy make compact cranksets (50-34) and look affordable, are black (style points count), and appear to be suitable for the C'dale. My LBS guru says so. And he notes that there are a number of manufacturers with good moderately priced compact cranks. I mention FSA and Campy because they appear nearly ubiquitous in the ads.
Should I go with the FSA and a JIS-taper bottom bracket (the bike's bb shell is 68 mm wide and english-threaded), or the Campy Mirage, apparently ISO taper? One Campy supplier says I'll need a Campy BB. Both cranksets are widely available on ebay as new takeoffs, and the costs are comparable for the cranksets themselves.
I see these issues. The Campy is a Campy (we all bowed down to them when I got my first 10-speed in the early '70s) and would be cool, IMHO, even for entry-level components. But wouldn't it require a BB that's more expensive? And more installation tools?
The FSA would apparently fit on a number of BBs, ranging from Shimano at about $15 and up. Looks like the Park BBT22 and my trusty rachet would do the job for installation.
So the FSA looks potentially easier to install. The Campy may have better style. Both would be better for riding (our LBS guy says move the front derailleur down and see what happens).
Last, any thoughts about BBs for the FSA if that's the choice? Shimano? Tange? IRD?
What am I missing? What would any of you do? Are there other obvious choices I should include?
Hope this isn't too long, but hoped my thinking might help generate useful responses.
Thanks again, and cheers.
Where the rain slacked off and I got to ride!