105 5700 rear shift - should I expect better? :(
#1
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2014
Posts: 3
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
105 5700 rear shift - should I expect better? :(
Hi everyone, glad to have found this forum - my first post here
I have a 2012 BMC SL01 Road Racer, 105. I keep it clean and well maintained and it's all in perfect shape, but I've never been impressed with the rear shift, especially coming from the SRAM X9 on my 2011 MTB. (I'm not trying to start the inevitable flamewar here, it's just my empirical observation!). What I'd like to establish is whether my 105 shift is below par and can be improved, or whether "that's just how they are". Any thoughts most welcome!
Symptoms:
Having checked (and fixed) hanger alignment and adjusted limit screws, it's still impossible to find any indexing adjustment where it's happy to go all the way up and down the cassette, click by click. The best I can get is to adjust it so that it just about clicks up a gear (i.e. to a smaller sprocket), and then accept that I sometimes need to "over shift" beyond the first click to drop down to a bigger sprocket. Of course that's not possible when doing double shifts as there's no additional movement in the lever after two clicks. It's worse around the smallest couple of cogs, sometimes the first click down from top gear will just be "absorbed" and it takes a second click to get it to next sprocket, which screws up the alignment for the rest of the cassette.
I had hoped that fixing the hanger alignment would solve it, but there's been little improvement. It feels like the dérailleur is "weak" - as if it doesn't have enough pull against the cable to keep everything really taught. It just seems vague and unsatisfactory and not what I'd expect after 2+ decades of indexing development! In comparison my SRAM X9 shift is so positive and precise, and yet that has a harder life - larger cog gaps, dirt, lower chain speeds... Should I expect better from my 105?
Thanks for any thoughts!
sim
I have a 2012 BMC SL01 Road Racer, 105. I keep it clean and well maintained and it's all in perfect shape, but I've never been impressed with the rear shift, especially coming from the SRAM X9 on my 2011 MTB. (I'm not trying to start the inevitable flamewar here, it's just my empirical observation!). What I'd like to establish is whether my 105 shift is below par and can be improved, or whether "that's just how they are". Any thoughts most welcome!
Symptoms:
Having checked (and fixed) hanger alignment and adjusted limit screws, it's still impossible to find any indexing adjustment where it's happy to go all the way up and down the cassette, click by click. The best I can get is to adjust it so that it just about clicks up a gear (i.e. to a smaller sprocket), and then accept that I sometimes need to "over shift" beyond the first click to drop down to a bigger sprocket. Of course that's not possible when doing double shifts as there's no additional movement in the lever after two clicks. It's worse around the smallest couple of cogs, sometimes the first click down from top gear will just be "absorbed" and it takes a second click to get it to next sprocket, which screws up the alignment for the rest of the cassette.
I had hoped that fixing the hanger alignment would solve it, but there's been little improvement. It feels like the dérailleur is "weak" - as if it doesn't have enough pull against the cable to keep everything really taught. It just seems vague and unsatisfactory and not what I'd expect after 2+ decades of indexing development! In comparison my SRAM X9 shift is so positive and precise, and yet that has a harder life - larger cog gaps, dirt, lower chain speeds... Should I expect better from my 105?
Thanks for any thoughts!
sim
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Medway, MA
Posts: 2,727
Bikes: 2011 Lynskey Sportive, 1988 Cannondale SM400
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 20 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
If the hanger is spot on, I would suspect the cable- a badly cut housing can do a number on shift precision, as can a too-tight curve anywhere along the housing run or any damage to the ends of the ferrules (like a single strand of the housing wire poking through). 105 should be VERY precise.
#3
Mechanic/Tourist
A little logic goes a long way. The amount the lever moves from gear to gear never changes. The geometry of the derailleur never changes. The cable links them, so any difference in behavior from gear to gear, assuming an unbent hanger and derailleur, has to be due to the cable/housing not transmitting lever movement to derailleur movement.
#4
Senior Member
FWIW, I'm not overly impressed with my Ultegra 6800. (105 is going there with 5800 this year).
My expectations might have been too high but I find that it's just..........meh.......shifts no better or worse than the Alivio setup on my hybrid.
Only thing I can offer is that downshifts can happen 3 at a time (on either my Ultegra 6800 or Alivio 9 speed) and shifting ONE-CLICK is not as precise as on, say the Front Derailer where you've only got ONE-CLICK, regardless. (On my compact double, that is)
So, I'd say that you SHOULD have good UPSHIFTS (one click at a time cuz that's all the brifters allow) but that there is some rider influence on the downshifts (1, 2, or 3 clicks at a time, thus you have to limit the 1-click yourself).
I try to make quick & accurate shifts.........(I just hate hearing the chain rumble against either derailer when shifting slowly so I try to be quick about it)...........and that can sometimes get me 1-1/2 clicks or 1 when I intended 2 or 2 when I intended 1. That may not get me the GEAR I wanted but it's just that I over or under shifted by half a click.
Even Di2 is not perfect all the time!
My expectations might have been too high but I find that it's just..........meh.......shifts no better or worse than the Alivio setup on my hybrid.
Only thing I can offer is that downshifts can happen 3 at a time (on either my Ultegra 6800 or Alivio 9 speed) and shifting ONE-CLICK is not as precise as on, say the Front Derailer where you've only got ONE-CLICK, regardless. (On my compact double, that is)
So, I'd say that you SHOULD have good UPSHIFTS (one click at a time cuz that's all the brifters allow) but that there is some rider influence on the downshifts (1, 2, or 3 clicks at a time, thus you have to limit the 1-click yourself).
I try to make quick & accurate shifts.........(I just hate hearing the chain rumble against either derailer when shifting slowly so I try to be quick about it)...........and that can sometimes get me 1-1/2 clicks or 1 when I intended 2 or 2 when I intended 1. That may not get me the GEAR I wanted but it's just that I over or under shifted by half a click.
Even Di2 is not perfect all the time!
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: SoCal
Posts: 6,517
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 276 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 6 Times
in
3 Posts
I just ordered a 105 group to install on one of my bikes. Someone in another thread mentioned that I should use metal ferruls instead of the plastic ones that come with it. Don't know if that is a major deal but he said it can greatly improve performance
#7
Mechanic/Tourist
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 18,138
Bikes: 2 many
Mentioned: 13 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1266 Post(s)
Liked 323 Times
in
169 Posts
That may be true, but if you're going to take out the inner wire and inspect it, you might as well replace the housing anyway. It's not a big job or a large expense.
It's possible there is dirt or rust inside the cable, that may not come out even after cleaning. Checking the cable housing ends for a flat even cut, might help too.
#10
Senior Member
sim, Reads like there is some cable drag somewhere. Make sure the rear loop of housing from the chainstay to the RD isn't too tight, the housing may need to be lengthened.
Brad
Brad
#11
Really Old Senior Member
Is the B screw properly adjusted?
I was having trouble with the upshifts "hanging" on my hybrid.
Adjust cable tension so that they would shift OK and I'd have to over travel the lever to shift down to a larger cog.
I'd forgot I'd adjusted the B screw for a larger cogged cassette for my vacation and failed to back it out when I went back to my 12-23.
I was having trouble with the upshifts "hanging" on my hybrid.
Adjust cable tension so that they would shift OK and I'd have to over travel the lever to shift down to a larger cog.
I'd forgot I'd adjusted the B screw for a larger cogged cassette for my vacation and failed to back it out when I went back to my 12-23.
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Roswell, GA
Posts: 8,319
Bikes: '93 Trek 750, '92 Schwinn Crisscross, '93 Mongoose Alta
Mentioned: 30 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1438 Post(s)
Liked 1,092 Times
in
723 Posts
Is the shift wire routed correctly around the anchor bolt? The correct routing is sometimes counterintuitive. Incorrect routing will cause incorrect derailleur movement per shifter click.
#13
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Ohio
Posts: 243
Bikes: 2014 Salsa Vaya 2, 2013 Trek Stache 8
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I also have 5700 and have the same sentiments about the rear shifting. There have been several new threads in the last few months specifically about 5700. I think this was the beginning of when Shimano started routing the shift cable out the back and along the bars instead of exiting from the sides. I've read of similar friction/cable issues on the first generation of Ultegra that used the same routing (6600?), which I assume got passed down to 105. The 9-speed Tiagra shifting on my last bike was a lot more crisp than the 105 on my new bike. Kinda disappointing.
#14
Custom User Title
Join Date: May 2013
Location: SE MN
Posts: 11,239
Bikes: Fuji Roubaix Pro & Quintana Roo Kilo
Mentioned: 40 Post(s)
Tagged: 1 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2863 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 31 Times
in
14 Posts
If you're having issues with the shifting it has to be something with your setup because my 5700 shifts flawlessly.
#15
Senior Member
The only problem that I ever had with mine was corrected by lubing the cable really well in the rear loop.
#16
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Oklahoma
Posts: 9,438
Bikes: Trek 5500, Colnago C-50
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 7 Times
in
6 Posts
If the pinch bolt washer tab is forcing the cable into a slightly longer route this will also change the actuation ratio and may explain the OP's shifting problems.
#17
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2014
Posts: 3
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Just wanted to say Thanks for all the amazing feedback, it's really appreciated. This is the first chance I've had to catch up on the thread since last weekend. Anyway just before doing so I took another look at the bike, indoors this time for "lab conditions" I double-checked the hanger alignment (having corrected it last week) and it still looks good. I did however notice that one of the hanger bolts would not tighten properly as the allen key would turn inside the slot. This meant there was some movement in the hangar. Anyway I replaced the bolts and it's all solid now. I also lubed the cable as best I could.
BUT
The shift is no better and remains highly unimpressive! For example in the middle of the block, it's possible to click it up and back down one step and it does almost nothing. I've lubed the deraileur joints (and always have done) and the return spring seems ok.
I'm going to check the anchor bolt routing now - it makes sense that it could change the actuation.
The chain is the factory fit KMC, FWIW. No significant chain stretch from what I can tell. Oh I forgot to mention, the bike has around 2500km on it, from new, well maintained. No rain except when caught out occasionally during a ride.
New cable then?
BUT
The shift is no better and remains highly unimpressive! For example in the middle of the block, it's possible to click it up and back down one step and it does almost nothing. I've lubed the deraileur joints (and always have done) and the return spring seems ok.
I'm going to check the anchor bolt routing now - it makes sense that it could change the actuation.
The chain is the factory fit KMC, FWIW. No significant chain stretch from what I can tell. Oh I forgot to mention, the bike has around 2500km on it, from new, well maintained. No rain except when caught out occasionally during a ride.
New cable then?
#19
Senior Member