Found this gem on CL. Probably will be gone soon, but at least it's good for my info.

Asking $800 with horrible pictures. I'm going to let it sink on the list and email in a few days.

http://hudsonvalley.craigslist.org/bik/1358596743.html

Is this price in line or am I out of line? For some reason, I'm thinking like half that at most.

The reverse phone number puts it two houses down from my aunts, and she said she's never seen the old couple that live there use a bike of any sort.