Bike Forums

Bike Forums (http://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Clydesdales/Athenas (200+ lb / 91+ kg) (http://www.bikeforums.net/clydesdales-athenas-200-lb-91-kg/)
-   -   Platforms are Too Much Fun (http://www.bikeforums.net/clydesdales-athenas-200-lb-91-kg/839904-platforms-too-much-fun.html)

Mark Stone 08-16-12 07:51 PM

Platforms are Too Much Fun
 
Starting in about 1982 or 83 I finally started using toe clips/straps and used them (on various bikes) until 1997 (14 years), then switched to SPD and rode SPDs on both road and mountain bikes until 12 months ago (15 years). Primarily because I didn't want to change into work shoes every day, I decided to commute on platform pedals at that time. Well, the hardest thing to get used to when you start using platforms is keeping you feets from slipping and sliding around, and finding (and maintaining) a good foot position on the pedal. Now I've been on platforms for a year, and so today I put my SPD's on the "Black Knight" bike (because I want to be a real bicyclist?). I bombed around the neighborhood for a half hour - and rode back home and put my platform pedals back on! Maybe it's my age (59-1/2) or maybe it's just that I've gotten used to them, but when I'm attacking the neighborhood streets/sidewalks/parking lots and doing quick stops/starts and being a general old-man nuisance, my platform pedals are just too fun. :)

mcrow 08-16-12 10:08 PM

Personally I don't see the use of clipless pedals unless you are going to be in the saddle a long time and don't plan on stopping much. In most urban areas it seems like you'd be clipping and clipping all the time. I like the platforms that have the little spike that dig into your shoe really well, you almost never slip.

OiS 08-17-12 01:00 AM

Have to agree generally. I have clipless on my roadbike, but that bike only comes out if I am specifically going out for a ride, not going to anywhere, just going out for the purpose of riding, and then it is for at least 1 hour.

For going to and from places and bombing around town, I have my other 2 bikes, both with platforms. It is a totally different type of riding! :)

Mark Stone 08-17-12 03:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mcrow (Post 14616566)
Personally I don't see the use of clipless pedals unless you are going to be in the saddle a long time and don't plan on stopping much. In most urban areas it seems like you'd be clipping and clipping all the time. I like the platforms that have the little spike that dig into your shoe really well, you almost never slip.

Yep, I've got those same little spikes that make a ring around the outside of the pedal :thumb:

CJ C 08-17-12 07:54 AM

why not have the best of both worlds? this is what i roll on

http://www.crankbrothers.com/images/mallet_3_red.jpg

Condorita 08-17-12 08:54 AM

Eventually you'll come to your senses and dump the drops, and ride upright to enjoy the scenery!!

/reverse snobbery

Mark Stone 08-17-12 08:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Condorita (Post 14617807)
Eventually you'll come to your senses and dump the drops, and ride upright to enjoy the scenery!!

/reverse snobbery

Amen!! Preach it!!

stevel610 08-17-12 09:01 AM

I rock these.http://media.performancebike.com/ima...-GRY-ANGLE.jpg

mcrow 08-17-12 09:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stevel610 (Post 14617842)

Those are the ones I have too, they work awseomein all conditions.

FrenchFit 08-17-12 09:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Condorita (Post 14617807)
Eventually you'll come to your senses and dump the drops, and ride upright to enjoy the scenery!!

/reverse snobbery

This has been GP's rant for years, all the marketing hype about how you SHOULD ride has taken the fun out of bicycling.

Mark Stone 08-17-12 09:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stevel610 (Post 14617842)
I rock these.

Those look awesome, and they're Performance house brand? Must have a great price, too. Mine are similar but the little spikes are plastic

Mark Stone 08-17-12 09:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FrenchFit (Post 14617953)
This has been GP's rant for years, all the marketing hype about how you SHOULD ride has taken the fun out of bicycling.

I say "Ride Free"! On the road there's only you and the bike (unless you're in a "peloton") so ride your own style and your own equipment/configuration. Be free!

RichardGlover 08-17-12 09:39 AM

I keep campus-style pedals on my commuter. It's great to be able to just strap on a helmet and go, no matter what shoes or clothes I'm wearing. It's also nice to be able to ride it with cycling shoes.

I like options.

mcrow 08-17-12 09:40 AM

I think clipless pedals have a place in racing or distance riding but if you are buzzing around the neighborhood, going to be stopping and going a lot or on a mountain bike trail I don't see the purpose.

CliftonGK1 08-17-12 09:42 AM

I have SPDs on my road bike and my CX racer, but I put flats on my MTB and wouldn't consider SPDs unless I'm doing some XC racing. For dirt jumping on trails, or doing gnarly downhills, I want my E-Z-Bailout flat pedals!

Nightshade 08-17-12 11:53 AM

Well now....... I wondered if we'd ever hear from those that DON'T worship at the altar of "Clipless".

My gosh where have you people been?

All the talk , until this thread, is about how great clipless pedals are when in truth platforms have a lot more going for them.

Mark Stone 08-17-12 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nightshade (Post 14618612)
Well now....... I wondered if we'd ever hear from those that DON'T worship at the altar of "Clipless".

My gosh where have you people been?

All the talk , until this thread, is about how great clipless pedals are when in truth platforms have a lot more going for them.

I'm surprised. In the past when I've mentioned platforms as being cool there's been a lot of friction. This is refreshing! But I don't expect it to last long lol

Zorba 08-17-12 01:11 PM

1 Attachment(s)
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=267913
Rivendell "Grip Kings" AKA MKS Lambda. Da Bomb!

yellowsirocco 08-17-12 01:15 PM

Clipless have their place and platforms have their place too. 20 miles this morning clipless on my road bike and it was great, but last nights run to the grocery store on my utility bike with platforms was great as well.

JakiChan 08-17-12 01:15 PM

I think there's a case of "the right tool for the right job". Some folks seem to have too strong an opinion either way - that you should only do clipless or that clipless is insane. What I will say is that for a 5 mile flat ride to work I prefer platforms. For a 60 mile ride with a bunch of climbing I want to be clipped in.

At 95 - 100rpm I have trouble staying planted with platforms. And pulling up for climbs doesn't work too well either. But I also don't like changing shoes at work (and I don't pedal that hard to get there), so I *gasp* go with what's appropriate for the task at hand...

mcrow 08-17-12 01:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JakiChan (Post 14619024)
I think there's a case of "the right tool for the right job". Some folks seem to have too strong an opinion either way - that you should only do clipless or that clipless is insane. What I will say is that for a 5 mile flat ride to work I prefer platforms. For a 60 mile ride with a bunch of climbing I want to be clipped in.

At 95 - 100rpm I have trouble staying planted with platforms. And pulling up for climbs doesn't work too well either. But I also don't like changing shoes at work (and I don't pedal that hard to get there), so I *gasp* go with what's appropriate for the task at hand...

And the evil empire finally shows up. ;)

CliftonGK1 08-17-12 01:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nightshade (Post 14618612)
Well now....... I wondered if we'd ever hear from those that DON'T worship at the altar of "Clipless".

My gosh where have you people been?

All the talk , until this thread, is about how great clipless pedals are when in truth platforms have a lot more going for them.

As others have stated; they both have their place. I wouldn't put platforms on my SSCX race bike. I wouldn't put them on my brevet bike. Either one requires some hefty pulling on the pedals when the terrain gets tough, and platforms just won't cut it.
Flip side: I cringe when I'm at the top of the freeride line at the MTB park, and I see some guy with a hardtail, road helmet, and SPDs. I want to be able to throw my bike mid-air if I know I've eff'd up and won't make my landing, and that isn't happening when you're locked in.

JakiChan 08-17-12 03:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mcrow (Post 14619040)
And the evil empire finally shows up. ;)

Uh, what? Saying that both have their place is the "evil empire"? Uhm, ok. :rolleyes:

mcrow 08-17-12 03:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JakiChan (Post 14619486)
Uh, what? Saying that both have their place is the "evil empire"? Uhm, ok. :rolleyes:

See winkie smilie.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:44 AM.